Return to the Antique Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Your potting soil mix for old roses

Posted by james23 6b/7a (My Page) on
Thu, Nov 29, 07 at 15:05

Q for those of you who grow your antique roses in pots. I'm talking here about smaller but more or less mature roses grown in 20" or larger ceramic, clay or poly pots, not the bands and baby pots used for immature plants.

What potting mix do you prefer? I'm not a big fan of the bagged garden store potting mixes, neither the fluffy stuff with perlite nor the 'organic' stuff, at least, not used on their own. The 'organic' stuff is heavy and drains poorly; while the fluffy stuff is light but also tends to get saturated and has at best zero nutrient value for the roses. So I've been mixing up my own. The last couple of years I have been mixing the bagged, commercial potting fluff with pine bark mulch or better yet, pine bark fines (more finely ground bark), in differing proportions. The pine fines aren't overly heavy and seem to keep the pots draining a bit better, whiling providing acidic and organic component. The roses seem to like it.

I used to just throw mushroom compost into the wooden whiskey half barrels that I used to grow a pair of SDLM, just right on top of my standard potting mix, but every once in a whileI had to lift the plants out and scoop out those barrels because the mushroom compost tended to inhibit drainage.

What do you use? Anybody mix compost or other organic matter into their potting mix? I found a really light weight bagged compost product this summer that I used when I transplanted a few things. It wasn't the standard manure. Wish I could remember what it was composed of, or at least the tradename. It was very light and rather coarse, so might be pretty good for pot culture. And the plants responded well to it.

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

For all my potted roses I use Fafard 52 mix.
IT seems to have the right size materials but needs to be watered more offen.

Stan C

RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

We grow c. 60 roses in pots.

I would not reccomdend using only compost or potting mix for roses, as it will not drain properly.
I use a combination of 1/3rd to 1/2 native garden soil-to 2/3 to 1/2 compost or potting soil.
to this I add amendments if they are not included in the potting soil.
for every 3 gallons of pot space,amendments include
- well rotted manure, the bagged stuff works well for my roses. c. 1 cup or so, for 3 gallons of pot space, mixed in very well to the potting mix.
-a cup of alfalfa, some bone mean,some blood meal, and earthworm castings.
I stopped using mushroom compost after reading a Hortico catalog which suggested that it can harm rosebushes.
I also mulch the pots in autumn with 1/2 well rotted manure and 1/2 composted plant material.


RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

  • Posted by kaye 7a AR (My Page) on
    Thu, Nov 29, 07 at 21:02

We have about 75 OGRs in 5 gallon pots waiting (still) for the new garden beds. My husband blends his own potting mix with a good top soil we buy locally, adds composted manure (mixed with rotted hay from our horses), pine bark mulch, vermiculite and perlite. May be overkill but the roses have done extremely well and some have been in their pots for 4-5 years, still waiting for homes. The mix is lite but holds moisture well. We do feed with time release fertilizer in season and top dress the pots with mulch to inhibit weed growth from the great for us.

RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

Hmm, I just use a commercial organic potting soil that I buy at the nursery. Our local soil is pure clay, not suitable for pots at all, even blended I would guess. Are those of you blending your own working with a sandy or sandy loam soil? In any case, you folks are working way harder than I am!


RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

Yep, a commercial organic potting mix for my container roses too, Rosefolly.


RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

I usually mix coir into a commercial potting mix, because the coir makes the very top of the soil less prone to drying into an almost cardboard-like substance. I don't like to water the plants and have most of it overflow to the side, down the space between the pot and soil, and instantly go out the bottom because the surface won't allow water to penetrate if dry. Of course, perhaps I shouldn't let the soil get so dry in the first place. I have taken to mixing in several generous pinches of worm castings. I also add some perlite with the coir. This has worked very well for me after trying innumerable combinations of ingredients.

However, I don't usually keep roses in pots for more than 2 years, at least on purpose.

RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

Starbucks coffee grounds

RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

Luxrosa, did "Hortico" say why they believe that Mushroom Compost will harm roses? We humans eat all those mushrooms, so I assume it's not because of any chemicals used in growing the mushrooms. I find the statement very interesting and I'm now very curious to know why!!! If anyone has an answer, I would surely appreciate knowing why.

RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

I've used mushroom compost with in ground roses routinely; and to a lesser extent with potted roses. In my experience, it does not 'harm' roses, but i have sometimes found that the bulk stuff is not as aged as you would like it, meaning it can burn the plants if applied directly to them. You can tell, easily, when the MC is not aged enough. When it is too fresh, you have to spread it out on your driveway (or wherever it has been dumped) and rake it around some to expose it for a while. And cope with the smell a bit. For this reason among others, it is always good to share rose blossoms with your next door neighbors.

The other thing to watch out for with MC is that it will push your soil pH to the sweet side. If you are in sweet to neutral soil to begin with, this can be a problem for your plants. Solution is to mix the MC with some acidic matter like pine fines or coffee grounds.

For roses growing in pots, the MC can be rather dense and can inhibit drainage. Again, fix is easy--mix with pine fines.

RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses, pt 2

Luxrosa and Kaye, thank you for sharing your potting mix recipes. I am going to try both this Spring. Some roses are just terrific in pots, and it is great to have a few plants in pots to move around your patio, yard, deck and so on. So, having a proven potting mix recipe is important. I appreciate the suggestions.

RE: Your potting soil mix for old roses

I'll second the vote for the Fafard mix which I've used for years. Miraclo Gro and Schultz also OK. I have about 40 potted roses in various sizes - now all of them are in the house for the winter.
Went to my local garden center for a small bag of the mix to use inside and picked out a 16 quart bag of Fafard with a sign that said $5.60. It rang up at $2. and I protested but two check-out clerks verified the computer and insisted they were right so I stopped arguing. Will have to get more next time if that's the way they feel about it!

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Antique Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here