Return to the Antique Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Posted by jaspermplants 9 az (My Page) on
Thu, Dec 12, 13 at 10:24

I am a lover of tea roses and was noticing today what a graceful plant my tea rose, Souv. de Pierre Notting is. It is a lovely vase shape; just beautiful. Not at all as awkward plant as it's parent, Maman Cochet.

I was wondering what your most graceful rose was (the plant, not necessarily the bloom). Also, what is your most awkward looking plant but most beautiful bloom? I would say mine is Tipsy Imperial Concubine. Incredible blooms on an very awkward, crooked plant! Love it though!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Abraham Darby is the most awkward ugly bush, but oh, the roses!


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Easy i have abraham darby. This is my first year with roses. I have abe next to my deck. Its the ugliest shrub i have so far. The flowers have great fragrance . I have seen nice pics on this site. So i will give it time to mature. I bought it before i learned about OGRS.


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Thats ironic.Ogrose said the same thing as i was writing. Thats it im moving that thing in the spring. Only OGRS from now on.


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

I only grow a handful of older and related roses, so I'm not much of an authority on this topic, but wouldn't hybrid musks tend to have more graceful 'fountain' shapes? At least my two do--Buff Beauty and Jeri Jennings. But maybe hybrid musks aren't "old" enough to count?

Kate


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Dublin everything counts its what you are personally looking for.But i think the question was whats the shrub you dont like the looks of but it has nice flowers. Everyone is gonnaa have an opinion .


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

My Belle Portugaise has the most elegant blooms of any rose in my garden, period. However, it has 12 feet of "bare legs" before it spreads out and blooms. In this picture its legs are covered up by the old tea Anna Olivier (that rose has elegant form AND blooms).

Jackie


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Regarding "most graceful rose bush", almost all of the rose bushes in my garden are graceful - that is one of my most important criteria for which roses to choose.

Here is just one example - actually, I did not choose this rose, my DH's ancestors did. It was years and years before I was able to identify it as 'Cl American Beauty' (1909 hybrid wichurana). As soon as I stopped trying to prune it into a round bush, it got more graceful.

Jackie


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

bman--here is the question I was responding to, as put forth by the OP.

I was wondering what your most graceful rose was . . .

And my answer was, the fountain-shaped hybrid musks like Buff Beauty and Jeri Jennings.

Kate


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

My gangliest plant with the most beautiful roses was Yves Piaget, gone to rose heaven courtesy of a gopher attack that was discovered too late.

My most graceful plant year-round is probably Mutabilis, as long as I do some minor trimming on it. The small, elongated leaves and slightly drooping habit always look charming to me. The fact that the new growth, of which there is always some, is reddish sets of the multicolored blooms to perfection. Of the tea roses I would say the most graceful is probably Le Vesuve, which is thickly branched and also has small leaves, giving it a bit of a wild appearance. I'm very partial to roses that rebloom but still retain the charm of their wild ancestors.

Ingrid


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

My awkward rose is Papa Meilland. I love the bloom and its fragrance. The rose plant is ungainly.


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Dublin sorry wasnt how i meant.


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

That's OK, bman.

Kate


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

When Rhapsody in Blue came out, we all rushed to get one - such a deep purple (not even the most deluded fan could claim it was blue). Lovely blooms, even relatively healthy, but oh, its habit of growth - perfectly hideous. Angular bare branches swoop out at bizarre unpredictable angles, more branches decide to die off almost overnight, stiffly awkward, like a sulky adolescent (and I have had my fair share of them). Banished, to the compost, especially after Peter James built on Cowlishaw's work to raise Blue for You (although the 2 roses are not related afaik). Still one of the nearest approximations of blue.....but sadly, its other defects preclude it from a place in my garden (although I do vicariously enjoy the wayward canes which flail about over my wall from next door).


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

  • Posted by hoovb z9 Southern CA (My Page) on
    Sun, Dec 15, 13 at 23:45

'Eugene de Beauharnais', horrible spindly disease covered sticks, heavenly flowers.

Interesting to hear how horrid 'Rhapsody in Blue' is somewhere else. A neighbor had it, dug it out and planted it on the HOA common area. It blooms every spring, about five of the most stunning deep purple flowers you can imagine, then sits leafless and bloomless until the following spring.


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Of the few OGRs I grow I consider Madame Isaac Pereire to be most unruly and a pruning puzzle for me. Many HTs bred for their blooms tend to be gangly.

Bman and ogrose, I'm not sure what the problem with Abraham Darby is, would you care to elaborate?. Mine is just a recently planted grafted bareroot so I wouldn't know but from the pics I've seen I just guess he has the stiff cane HT growth habit but is much more behaved and full than a lot of HTs I could mention. My plan was to prune him like an HT to become self supporting. He certainly looks to me more 'bushy' than 'shruby', maybe this is the issue since we're in the Antique Rose forum?
Nik


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Hi Nik, Abe is just awkward, the canes grow at odd angles, it's stiff, and the huge thorns get me every time I try to work on him. It's not a pretty bush all covered with leaves, it reminds me of a gaunt old man! It was the first rose I bought from a local nursery right after it came out in the 80's.

I have seen pictures of him trimmed by someone who really knows what they're doing, and he's not too bad of a bush. Every February I whack him back and he returns with gusto and rewards me with the most beautiful flowers, one of my favorites.


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

Love Belle Portugaise. That is a hybrid gigantea, correct? I should try it here but don't really have the room.

I love Cl American Beauty but doubt it will do well in my climate. Beautiful!

Anna Olivier is wonderful. That is one rose I have tried to get but seem to always get Etoile de Lyon instead (or Bermuda Etoile de Lyon). I was able to get Lady Roberts but even though I BABIED it this past summer, it died. I was heartbroken.


 o
RE: Most graceful rose; most awkward plant??

I'm surprised that Abraham Darby is considered awkward. Mine had a very nice bushy shape, covered with leaves. The problem was my hot climate which fried the roses. When I moved it to a cooler spot it developed diseases and barely bloomed. I was bummed; it's such a gorgeous rose.

I'm just now reminded of Queen Nefertiti, an early Austin. It was awkward from the getgo and remained gangly, bare and thorny. The flowers were lovely, though.

Ingrid


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Antique Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here