Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
johnnyplantsseeds

can I just plant in paper cups or do I have to be fancy?

johnnyplantsseeds
15 years ago

I saw some folks on the Internet with fancy setups for germanating seeds (I think that's the term). Will it work to just plant vegetable seeds in paper cups? Will they grow until they are moved to the garden?

Comments (14)

  • belleville_rose_gr
    15 years ago

    I have used Styrofoam cups before just make sure you punch in drainage holes. You can buy plastic pots very cheap @ charleys gh supply

  • johnnyplantsseeds
    Original Author
    15 years ago

    do you you have to have grow lights?

  • sewobsessed
    15 years ago

    Unless you can fit everything you want to grow in a south-facing window and have the time and energy to rearrange and/or turn them constantly, yes.

    Some people have luck with just window light and others find they have a very hard time getting healthy plants unless they place them under lights for about 16 hours a day.

    I'm way up north and don't get the strength of sun (or enough dalight length) in winter/spring I need to go only by sunlight, so I use regular shop lights on this stand.

    Experiment and see what works for you. The easier, the better.

  • Suzi AKA DesertDance So CA Zone 9b
    15 years ago

    Do paper cups have some wax coating? Will that affect the plants? This I do not know, but I hang out in the frugal forum sometimes, and some people plant in toilet paper rolls with the bottoms taped. To plant, just untape the bottoms. The cardboard will disintegrate in the ground.

    Others (like me) love to plant in egg shell halves (I now crack mine nearly to the top so I have 3/4 of the egg shell to plant in. I set mine in the egg carton and poke through the bottoms with an ice pick for drainage holes. I set them outside in the sun and use a spray bottle filled with water to mist them now and then. The egg shell will also disintegrate over time and fertilize the plant.

    I recently was caught eying an empty cardboard wine carton, noticing all those nice compartments. Hmmmmmmmm

  • albert_135   39.17°N 119.76°W 4695ft.
    15 years ago

    I was my experience that some toilet paper rolls will quickly unroll when moist. You might want to test one of your brand first.

    OT, perhaps, but sort of related, I watched a very efficient reforestation project where the new trees were grown in rolls very similar to toilet paper rolls, they did not use anything to seal the bottom of the roll.

    " ... can I just plant in paper cups ... " ? Some paper cups are covered with something like a very thing cellophane wrap, like Saran Wrap, and don't rot well in the soil. Until you have tested yours you will probably want the pop the bottom or cut it off. Testing and experimentation can be fun. Plant at least one intact, see what happens.

  • wordwiz
    15 years ago

    Some people tried paper cups last year and they fell apart before it was time to transplant them. I like the 9 oz. plastic cups as long as they are smooth. But the best is the cells and trays the nurseries use. You can water from the bottom, move them easily, they are large enough so you don't have to move them to a larger cell as they grow, reusable and inexpensive.

    Mike

  • tomakers
    15 years ago

    Newspaper pots are the best. Roll 1 full sheet of newspaper folded in half around the size can you want for a container and fold up the bottom (maybe you could use 1/2 sheet for smaller sizes, but I haven't tried it). One strip of masking tape well placed will hold it together until it is time to pot up or transplant into the garden. Water from the bottom (put them in a tray). I usually unroll or tear them to plant, but they will disintegrate over time. Don't use computer paper, for some reason it molds.
    JMO,
    Tom

  • greenthumbchuck
    15 years ago

    Good question John! I am wondering the same thing. In this little town the plastic trays cost about $3.00 each. OUCH.
    I am going to search for cups online that will be organic (the glue, ect.) I will let you know what I find.
    Chuck

  • greenthumbchuck
    15 years ago

    Hi All,
    I found a good site for this question. :)
    http://home.att.net/~ekyorigins/seedsx.html

    Enjoy, Chuck

  • v1rt
    15 years ago

    I used a regular plate(ceramic), folded damp paper towel, then the seeds, then folded damp paper towel again. Then I put them in a ziplock.

    Once it sprouts, I transfer them to the real dirt. This is also what I did to my Pampas and Foxtail seeds. The dianthus seeds took forever.

    Below are the pictures of my seed germination experiment.
    {{gwi:256155}}

    {{gwi:256156}}

    Dianthus seed germinated
    {{gwi:231917}}

  • wantonamara Z8 CenTex
    15 years ago

    I go to my neighborhood nursery and they have a recycle spot of all their trays and 4" pots. They let me take home all I want. i have a veritable baby nursey going under my oak trees. I germinate seed in them outside in here in Texas. I ahve a bout 100 of them.

  • rjinga
    15 years ago

    I have found the plastic trays from Lowe's or Home Depot, the ones that hold the larger pots until they are sold are PERFECT. they are about 4 to 5 inches deep, they have holes in the bottom already for drainage and there are 6 spots, so you can plant all one thing or several things (just be sure to label well). They obviously come in different sizes and style, they all work :)

    Peat pots BTW are the WORST and I'd never use them again. Styrofoam cups work 1000 times better to me.

    I also recycle the plastic 6 pack trays that most plants come in. Notice the big plastic storage container in the bottom right corner of the photo...these work great too.

    here are some pics of seedlings in these.
    {{gwi:223254}}
    {{gwi:223252}}

    I have also taken them from these containers and then transplanted them to the styrofoam cup after they get their first true leaves...They to the garden.

    PS: They are free. And these take out trays work great too
    {{gwi:249839}}