Return to the Shrubs Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Chaenomeles japonica

Posted by Cath923 5b Canada (My Page) on
Tue, Dec 3, 13 at 12:22

Does anyone know if and how I can train a japanese quince into a standard? It is about 10 years old and very untidy. Also, most of the flowers bloom almost out of sight low in the bush. It is now December and it is covered in buds already so I brought some in and am enjoying the flowers now as they pop open!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

These plant sucker so aggressively that I can't imagine that a standard form would be successful. To increase the flowering (and its visibility) you can spur-prune it by pruning the side shoots to 2-3 buds. Best to do this in spring/summer, after flowering. You can shorten new growth as well as prune the spurs. Both should help flowering and overall appearance of the shrub, which is fairly messy at best.

Good luck!

Sara


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

  • Posted by bboy USDA 8 Sunset 5 WA (My Page) on
    Tue, Dec 3, 13 at 16:46

If this is, in fact the quite low- and dense-growing, usually some shade of orange-flowered C. japonica - and not one of the taller kinds (the old fashioned, usually red-flowered shrub which is called by the common name "japonica" in Britain, is C. speciosa; it is also represented in cultivation by named cultivars producing flowers of various colors; some forms on the market belong to the hybrid between the two called C. x superba) - it won't have the right type of growth for training up into a tree shape. (It might be possible to graft one onto a fruiting quince stem to produce a lollipop tree, although I haven't seen this done myself).

What has been done with the tall ones is to train them against walls, cutting them back right after flowering to maintain the flat shape. The flowers can show quite well under such circumstances.


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

Yes, I just looked it up in the American Hort Pruning guide and espalier is one of their suggestions. Be careful, though, may have nasty thorns!


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

Thank you both of you. I can't believe the speed with which you replied! I think I'll follow most of your suggestions with the shrub - I'll spur prune the main plant and then try digging up some of the suckers and rooting them to make an espalier to go against the wall. One of them, I'll experiment with and try turning it into a standard although I agree it probably won't work! Lots to do in the spring!
And yes - those thorns do hurt!


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

first off .... its your plant.. presumably.. you have pruning shears.. go for it ... who cares what the rules are ... what do you have to lose???

but... secondly ... you might be about 10 years too late to be successful ... but again .. what do you have to lose ... get rid of it now.. or get rid of it later ...

and finally.. option C .... most standard plants are grafted ... either once or twice... perhaps choosing a better root stock .. and this MIGHT limit your options ... who knows ...

regardless.. refer to option IV above... what do you have to lose????

ken


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

  • Posted by bboy USDA 8 Sunset 5 WA (My Page) on
    Wed, Dec 4, 13 at 14:31

We're not talking about rules, as in human conventions or customs, we're talking about what is feasible based on the physical structure and growth modes of specific shrubs.

Commercial growers use pruning and training to produce clear trunks and elevated crowns rather often, I'm not sure top grafting for that particular outcome is the dominant approach.


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

The suckering would drive me nuts!
Mike


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

I have found one vague reference to Chaenomelese being grown as standards by Victorian gardeners but there is no mention of how they did it. I would imagine it would be best to start with a single stem rooted cutting, just as in making any 'lollipop' tree, and work from there rather than trying to prune an established shrub into a standard.


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

Oh yes, this is very feasible with some cultivars (Cameo, Crimson and Gold and Rowallane) - I think these are all Xsuperba and have a less exuberant basal growth than the old speciosa. Easier to be done when young. but you can train, prune and lop an older specimen - they are very forgiving of being cut back as long as it is a planned operation done in a couple of stages and you will need a support system of a stout post and possibly a canopy, sometimes used in growing weeping standards (a bicycle wheel, attached to a pole might work). A bit like any pruning operation to lop off lower lateral branches, keeping the main stem as clean as possible. I have seen an old and very gnarly shrub treated in just such a manner (although I am not a fan of standards myself) - a bit like raising a standard wisteria, the key is in the pruning.


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

Thanks so much, everyone! I'm looking forward to lots of experimenting in the spring - though I just might try digging up a sucker while it is frozen and tuck it in somewhere to await surgery.


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

Mike I just removed about a half a dozen due to the suckering and the needed pruning to keep them looking tidy. Too rangy for me. And in this climate, many other things look attractive in late winter/early spring.

Sara


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

Quince is one of those plants that only looks good when it's flowering. Very welcome in early spring paired with forsythia. That's when I enjoy them...in other people's gardens.
No fall color to speak of, and the winter branching pattern looks like a poorly stacked pile of brush. Even in summer the leaves look bad here.
Constant pruning seems to be the answer.... if you can handle the thorns. My garden is rather large and I just don't have the time nor the desire to bleed.
I removed a really old one in sandy ground on a landscape job I was doing a few years ago. The extensive root system gave the bulldozer I was running a hard time!

Mike


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

Mine is espaliered against a stone wall. In the summer it is behind all the other stuff in the flowerbed.


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

What a good way to use this plant, flora(l)!

Sara


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

mmm, I have a Crimson and Gold cultivar espaliered against a black timber structure (which also supports climbing roses and clems). In spring, the vivid new leaves and startling scarlet blooms look absolutely fantastic (and very Japanese/Oriental) against black stained wood - one of my (few) design successes in my (mish-mash of a) garden.


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

Mine's Crimson and Gold, too, Campanula. It's against pale stone.


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

I say that this is definitely a plant that the Brits have figured out how to use! Good show.

Sara


 o
RE: Chaenomeles japonica

I guess the reason I planted the Chaenomeles in the first place is that we had some beautiful ones in the UK where I was brought up and it reminded me of happy days. I must admit I had forgotten the thorns!
The branch I brought in to enjoy has now flowered and is done so time to cut another one! Looks so much better on the window sill than between a rose, a hibiscus moscheutos and an orange daylily! All vying for the same space!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Shrubs Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here