Return to the Soil Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Asphalt concerns

Posted by prussell z6 TN (My Page) on
Wed, Feb 4, 09 at 16:00

I live in a house that's been a rental for eons. I've recently started renovating some preexisting beds for the purposes of veggie and herb gardening (mostly). In one bed, there was a layer of hard, rocky stuff about 3" thick, about 6" below the surface. It looks like crumbling asphalt/blacktop (not so good with my pavement terminology), and broke apart very easily. It took us a while to figure this out, so we had pretty much mixed it in with the rest of the soil and all of our amendments (including precious home-grown compost).

My question is: should we be worried? Is there a possibility that nasty stuff remained in this layer and could add trace nasty stuff to our veggies?

Any insight appreciated!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

If that was asphalt you need to keep in mind that the base material for asphalt is petroleum. Often oil saturated soil will harden and appear like asphalt although it can be a bit more easily tilled up. Because of the need to recycle old asphalt there are some studies that have found that when crushed and mixed with soil asphalt can help stabilize that soil, but I have not yet seen anything about soil contamination. This may be something like recycling tires, the precautionary principle should apply and until it is proven safe it would not be a good idea.
Since your soil already has this material mixed in it and seperating whatever this was out may be too difficult, I'd not plant a vegetable garden there.


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

Asphalt does contain a host of heavy hydrocarbons (how's that for some asphalt alliteration?) some of which are toxic. Most notably the family of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons or PAHs. These also occur in soot, diesel exhaust, and airborne deposition from coal burning in decades past. They are ubiquitous but no less toxic for that. A 3" thick layer is likely to contain a significant amount of these. I myself would think twice or three times before growing food there, even though I am not certain what the uptake rates are for PAHs into plants. At a minimum I would not plant root crops, to decrease the exposure to trace amounts of actual dirt sticking to the vegetables. That will certainly help.

Are you in a heavily urbanized area or more recently build suburbs or what? Just curious about other exposure rates.


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

No clue but, apparently, there are people out there building raised beds on top of asphalt.

Here is a link that might be useful: Asphalt Gardens


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

In some few instances, like when the soil under the asphalt is contaminated, it may be preferable to spend large sums of money hauling in soil to garden on top of asphalt, but far better is to not contaminate the soil in the first place. However, this question is about asphalt, potentially, mixed into the soil and even though asphalt is 95 percent aggregate, stone, sand, etc., and only 5 percent binders, which are bitumen, petroleum products, stuff left over from crude oil refining, that 5 percent can be extremely harmful if ingested by human beings.
So the OP needs to determine if this was asphalt or some other petroleum product that bound that soil into a hard, cohesive mass, and whether they really want to grow food in this soil.


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

Just contact your local county AG extension and ask for a soil test that includes testing for contaminants. Shouldn't be more than $10-15. Then you will know.

Personally, I wouldn't worry about it given it's age and that is was buried. Most of the possible contaminants would have leached out by now into the deeper soil. If worst comes to worst, you can either move the bed or raise the bed sides and add several more inches of good quality compost to it.

JMO

Dave


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

I have to disagree with digdirt's posting, no offense but consider the following from an environmental chemist:

Tests for the kinds of toxins I described are not $10-$15 like a standard soil test. They cost more like a couple hundred. This would be the EPA method called Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds (SVOC), aka SW-846-8270, using gas chromatography and mass spectrometry analysis after laboriously extracting the soil with solvents and cleaning the extract with various procedures. This is done in an environmental lab rather different from the typical soil analysis lab. Whole different ball game and probably not worth it when you could replace the soil for that kind of money.

As to it being safe because of its age, the fact that it was buried, and that it has probably leached away, each of these does not apply in case of asphalt and PAHs. They do not break down in the environment very fast at all. They are not particularly water soluble, so they will tend to stay in the asphalt matrix or bind to soil particles and just sit there. Not much of nature's cleaning action happening here.

The earlier posting about building on an asphalt surface is a little different, since prussel has broken up the layer and mixed it into the soil. Increased surface area means much greater potential for both uptake by plants and contaminated particles sticking to root crops.

I may be making a mountain out of a molehill but that's how PAHs behave. Gardening amounts to a small but real increased risk over time. Will you get sick and die? Probably not. Does it add to your lifetime cancer risk? Probably. You have to decide for yourself what to do.


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

I would guess that somebody dumped oil there many years ago and buried it. I found something similar in my own back yard, and a previous owner had an illegal car repair business going out of his (now my) garage. It is much as you describe, a thick layer of hard but somewhat flexible/flaky/brittle black stuff with a somewhat oily smell. I don't grow edibles back there so I'm not too concerned, but I try to dig it out as I find it as it is nearly impenetrable to both water and plant roots.


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

I thought I had replied to this but I've been having browser issues this past week.

The compost you already applied is the best thing you could have done. In addition to the special soil test suggested by tox above, I would get a soil test from The Texas Plant and Soil Lab and tell them what you suspect. They will give you many ideas as to how to correct any issues they find. TPSL just revamped their pricing. Get the tests that add up to $35 - those tests used to be their basic ($35) test.

I should point out that spraying the soil with diesel fuel is a common way to rid the fence line of weeds in Texas. They sometimes will follow up with molasses spray to help kick start the microbes to restore the soil they just sprayed. I don't know how well that works but the people at TPSL should know.


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

I wonder if it could have been a rock driveway that was sprayed with oil. In the old days they did that to cut down on the ruts and dust. Many people didn't want red clay gravel drives and couldn't afford pavement so they spread rock and oiled it. Enough years of spraying oil and it would have stuck together a bit and looked like asphalt.


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

Note, used oil is much lower in PAHs than asphalt but they are present due to the heat and combustion blowby... and the other components - the oil - DO break down with microbial action much better than asphalt. Smaller more chewable molecules.

The way to tell which is maybe to note whether there is gravel aggregate or not?


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

My but soil tests are really expensive in your neck of the woods toxcrusader! We can get all sorts of toxic material tests done down here @ 10-$15 each - the OP doesn't need the entire range of potential toxins tested after all.

Be that as it may, it is way too easy to go to extremes when discussing issues such as this. We are growing in dirt after all and not a sterile environment. Few have the access to the detailed history of their soil so one makes basic assumptions as to its quality/safety, adds compost to compensate for any questionable elements, trusts to a degree the natural filtering abilities of plants, has it tested, and then moves on.

OR, if one lives in fear of their dirt, they have the option of using containers with sterile potting mix or creating an enclosed bed filled with sterile potting mix and then enclose it so no possible contaminants can gain access to it.

Life is full of risks. At my age and after going on 50 years of gardening now I can attest that your garden soil is one of the lesser ones. ;)

Dave


 o
RE: Asphalt concerns

I love Gardenweb--such a great assortment of answers!

I found some papers about the uptake of PAH's into plants, and they suggested that a)it's low, and b) most uptake occurs via surface contact of leaves or roots to soil. Avoiding the parts that have been in direct contact with the soil (or by covering the soil with sand) seemed a good solution.

That said, I think I'll get the soil tested. I'll repost those results for the curious. I'm not sure of the history of this property, but the car repair in backyard scenario jives with some spotty tales of yore I've been told. Seattle as a whole is a young city, and this neighborhood is on the nicer end of urban housing.

Thanks!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Soil Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here