|
| Hi. I like learning new things about compost. I believe it is the way of future farming. We need to fix these problems that todays farming has done. Petrol bases ferts destroying the earth when compost can be used. Synthetics are cheap and grow even more productive plants than organic however after 20 years the land is salt. Organics or teas would just add to the soil. With the right tea there is no need for pestisides,ect..because the tea builds the cell wall of the plant so much it in impossable to penitrate by any insect or bacteria,ect...
It just takes some advanced composting. You can replace ferts all together with a good compost pile.
|
Follow-Up Postings:
|
- Posted by vermontkingdom 4a (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 6:33
| I agree, if conditions permit, gardners should compost. However, at this internet site, you are "preaching to the choir." I suspect most of the visitors to this compost site are compost enthusiasts (whackos?). I know I am and my wife will attest to it. I use the shrimp/kelp compost (store bought)as an ingredient in my compost tea. I put several shovels of my mature compost and a scoop of the shrimp/kelp compost into a burlap bag and put it into 40 gal barrel of rain water. After several days I put this mixture on all growing plants. I do this from spring through the fall crops. It's cheap, fun and seems to be extremely effective. |
|
| however after 20 years the land is salt. Are you suggesting that there is no conventional farm currently producing good yields that are more than 20 years old because they "turned their land to salt"? Organics or teas would just add to the soil. With the right tea there is no need for pestisides,ect..because the tea builds the cell wall of the plant so much it in impossable to penitrate by any insect or bacteria,ect... Your heart's in the right place but try not to go over the top. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 13:24
| TO,gargwarb if you look at a.. say...maple syrup "farm" they feed them ferts and use pestiside..thats why you can buy ORGANIC MAPLE SYRUP. The trees obviusly dont have salt build up in 20 years because they are differnt. Im talking small food crops friend go look up smoe info before making a fool of yourself on here :]. If you have an outside plot and you continu to use chemi ferts you kill all living things in the ground after a while things get bad. You dont know too much about plants or the earth do you? Do you know why the BEE population is almost gone? Do you know what Bees do? Chemi requirs "badages" micro additivs that are chemicals. the same chemicals for in good compost but the petrol based is BAD! Go do some reading and see why we will not have farmable land in 30 years. Its a FACT. |
|
| friend go look up smoe info before making a fool of yourself on here :] You're right. You're obviously far more knowledgeable than me. You dont know too much about plants or the earth do you? If I wanted to show off my skills with some potted plants I would go Chemi. O and I will go over the top and save the earth. Thank you.
|
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 13:47
| I just like rambling. your right we cant do much to save the aerth lol. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 14:05
| Again just like debates. Im sure we both can learn.please post again |
|
| I would but I'm scared witless of your "skills". |
|
| It doesn't hurt to educate the ones that would like to, but circustances prevent them doing so. So don't get on a high horse and complain about inorganic fertilizers...they've saved the planet and the dinner table. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 15:00
| Inorganics saved the planet??? The dinner table yes. The high demand for food is why we farm like this. It is cheaper now but not to the future. If we just grow organic or crop rotation the crops would not be as fast producing thus making the price of produce go up..LIKE IT SHOULD BE!! |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 19:13
| anyone have any other composting ideas? please |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 19:34
| To gargwarb I am sorry about the rude response. Somtimes i can get carried away. I just would like to see us use sustainable agriculture. |
|
| I am an organic gardener, but this is not a organic garden forum. My father farmed the same land for 40 years using synthetic fertilizers & my 3 brothers still use them.The soil that they use has been work the same way for over fifty years now. They have as much, as good of a crop as I do in my garden. One of my brothers has use round- up to kill weeds & grasses before starting his garden & still made a good crop that same year. I have been an organic gardener for 30 year, How long have you been gardening & how long have you had the Master Gardener certificate? Much of what you are calling garden gospel, I have seen with my on eyes NOT to be true. Maybe garden is different in Kershaw sand hills. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 21:39
| nature creates balance.Natural systems, nitrogen is never "lost". but with the application of chemi nitrogen ferts, which are either applied as nitrates, or converted to nitrates through the bacterial activity in the soil, this delicate system is disrupted. Nitrates (NO3 -) are anions, that is, they are not held on cation exchange sites. So anything that's not immediately taken up by roots is quickly leached out, and dissipates into the air as gas, as these fertilizers must be applied with large amounts of water to prevent salinification of the soil. Thus the soil environment deals with the artificially created excess of nitrogen in the way the system works naturally.this leads to the pollution of our ground water and rivers, and the health problems with that. However, an excess of nitrates ca also create other problems. Nitrates are salts, dehydrating the soil. They are aswll very strong oxidizers, literally burning up the soil. You guys are using them correctly and at small scale im talking large scale ag dumping these in the land to stay up w the demand there soil becomes worthless quik. there is alot of ground water you are polluting when using these ferts. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 21:43
| ^Is that "gospel"? or sience? |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, Apr 25, 11 at 22:05
| Source for the above topic^ :www.organiclandcare.org/...fertilizers/ Effects of some synthetic fertilizers.pdf - |
|
| "Source for the above topic^ :www.organiclandcare.org/...fertilizers/ Effects of some synthetic fertilizers.pdf -" 404 |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, Apr 26, 11 at 0:11
| Im sorry the source did not work. I just wanted to provide where i got the info from. |
|
| Keep in mind that synthetic fertilizers were not in general use until after WWII, the late 1940's to early 1950's and the synthetic fertilizers have helped our soils loose as much organic matter since that time as was lost in the previous 100 years. However, not replenishing OM in soils was common long ago and that mindset contributed to the dust bowl of the 1930's. Teas, organic or not, are not the solution to the problem (lack of organic matter in the soil) either. Adding sufficient quantites of organic matter is the solution. Teas, like synthetic fertilizers, are a short term aid to correct a long term problem. If you have a good, healthy soil spraying teas will do nothing to help plants grow. If spraying teas on your plants does help then your soil needs to be looked at to see what is wrong. |
|
| No problem, MasterGardener1. |
|
| When I first came onto this forum twelve years ago, I, too, made the mistake of thinking that the people here were new to composting. MasterGardener, as Vermont said, you are preaching to the choir. Lots of us have been doing "advanced composting" since probably before you were born. In the last 58 years, I have only lived in one house that didn't have a compost pile, and that was only for nine months. I am guessing that if you learned composting from the Master Gardeners' Program, you aren't really doing Advanced Composting yet. For instance, misinformation that the Master Composters' program spreads is that meat, fat and sugar can't be composted. That's hooey. Anyway, your enthusiasm is cute, and very welcome here. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, Apr 26, 11 at 12:14
| "If you have a good, healthy soil spraying teas will do nothing to help plants grow" (If you spray the foliage of the plants with say wormcastings it is a natural pestiside what do you do for pests?) Compost is better than tea for sure it adds carbon to the soil and other organic materials.Im not saying that tea replaces compost. Its just a very nice tool to make the soil become living and healthy. Lets talk about future farms in greenhouses with aero-ponics using highend stable super thin compost teas;] Hydroponics save water. With teas you can achive higher results than using just soil to grow in....you can have a super drainage grow medium that is not to fertal but has extreme drainage. Now you add your "veg" tea for growth and your bloom tea for fruiting depending on what your growing theses could be mixed..now say i added no tea..my soil/meduim would have to have all the organic matter/food in the soil/meduim...this resulting in bad drainag(soil).. crop rotation would be ideal although hydroponics can save the futur aswell. Compost takes a bad toll on the eviroment in Factoty Farming!! The fuel it takes to move all that compost around uses way more fuel then to spray w ferts..(farms are gas relient there machines ect.....). So these organic farmrs are polluting more than chemi..I know economics to well..mass crop productoin could not just use compost that would not be economical..now to make a strong tea that can be sprayed like ferts Would Not effect the soil as bad as ferts do although would be better to just crop rotate. Now in your back yard or even a smaller production garden i could see moving around the compost easy its how it should be.... Hydroponic medium=drainage no fertility/food |
|
| TheMasterGardener1 - it's getting very difficult to follow what you are trying to tell us. I've read the last post a few times as best I can and don't really know what point(s) you are making. Most people on this forum are already making as much compost as they can and those who aren't are wanting to. Are you saying we should all change to compost teas and hydroponics? The site you refer to seems quite sensible but your interpretaton of the information is very confusing. Could you set out clearly what you are trying to share with us? |
Here is a link that might be useful: Is this the source of your Master Gardener label?
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, Apr 26, 11 at 15:58
| flora_uk -thats just it.. I think compost tea and hydroponic greenhouses can work for factory farm production of the future. Greenhouses have huge upfront costs but the amount of water/fert you save is alot. And no need for so much (or none) pesticides in greenhouses. I just wanted to here B What and how do you make your own compost at home and do you make diff ones for diff applications Thank you flora_uk for that point. I am just rambling on aren't I ;). |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, Apr 26, 11 at 17:58
| annpat- "am guessing that if you learned composting from the Master Gardeners' Program, you aren't really doing Advanced Composting yet" Not sure what that is? Dont let the name fool you lol. you are correct im no pro..however you have been composting in your yard for yourself,others,maybe you even sell. Im talking about understanding high production ag. This may be the wrong forum so I see what you are saying. Me saying the land turns to salt in 20 years is a over exaggeration. Look up the effects of what HIGH amounts of ferts do to the soil and if we keep it up we will not have farmable land in 30 years. I would think some ppl would be able to give me some info on what they use in their compost and if they make more than one type..... So tell me what you think about future farming. And tell me some compost hints. Thanks. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, Apr 26, 11 at 18:57
| Again. I guess I kinda went off on too many subjects. Feel free to post. I thought this would make a good discussion. I would like to learn more about ppl real life experience with compost and tea. I can only read so much. On here i can find real life experience tips. Any input on any of these subjects would be nice. Thanks. |
|
| I shouldn't have commented on the Master Gardening program. I went through the program in 1988 when they barely made mention of composting and no encouragement of organic methods at all. The Master Composting program in Maine at present is laughable, from what I've heard, adhering to the old taboos on meat, dairy, fat, etc. I think the program discourages more would-be composters than it converts. I make four types of compost, maybe five. I'll list them. Leaf mold. I make it in bags in the woods or in bags I place around the foundation of my chicken houses for winter insulation. It generally takes two years to become beautiful; I often can't resist it before it's of chocolate cake consistency and will spread it as mulch before then. I run a few hot piles when I can. I make those in one day with ingredients I've gathered off property---at the landfill or the seashore. I generally make the hot piles in the fall. I run two cold piles through the summer. These take the majority of my and my neighbor's kitchen waste. I add straw, chicken litter, seaweed, what ever I can when I can. These piles are built all season, flipped once or twice, and spread in the fall on my sleeping garden whether they are ready or not. I raise my chicken using the deep litter method. It's basically composting in the chicken house with a large component of manure. That's my fourth method, except that I'm abandoning the way I harvest it. I now mix it into my compost piles rather than applying it directly. Kim convinced me it needs longer curing than the fresh manures I used (and loved) my whole gardening life. I make rough compost in a dip in the woods. That pile consists of things I don't want in my regular piles---branches, brambles, diseased things. I've never actually harvested from that pile, but I would if I needed it. Oh, and I guess I'll count my new method of yard management. This was my third or fourth year of it. I pick a spot in my yard whose soil I want to improve, don't care how unsightly it is and where I don't intend, on purpose, to grow anything that year. So right now, my yard across the street is covered under 2 or 3 feet of leaves, now compressed; about 80 pumpkins; a truckload of seaweed; three or four bales of straw; pine needles; woodash; anything I could get my hands on last fall. I am only doing it to build rich soil there for the future, but I know that I'll have a bumper crop of pumpkins growing into the road this summer. I intend to keep rotating my yard employing this effortless soil improvement method. My whole garden focus now is to Make My Yard Attractive to Earth Worms. I figure "Build it and they will come," and when they come, And Boy! do they come! they will fertilize, and work the soil for me. Like you, I make teas, but I use them as much as an imagined way to control pests and disease, as fertilize. My compost, which I apply as mulches, is my primary method of fertilization. I will spot apply fish emulsion fertilizers in the summer. I have five large bins right now. Three of them are immediately harvestable and were hot piles last fall. The last two were my winter piles and will be combined with the litter from my chicken houses when I get the time, then used mid-summer as a mulch somewhere. Welcome to the forum. You're going to love it. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, Apr 26, 11 at 20:12
| annpat Thank you so much for righting. I found it very interesting I hope to have livestock like you some day. I would like to thank you for stating that you use compost tea as a pesticide. I like how you say earthworms till the land for you that is a big advantage of organic farming. Again Thanks. |
|
| I have 20 chickens, but as of last Friday, I now also have about 25,000 honeybees. We think alike, MG1. I think you'll enjoy the forum. |
|
- Posted by AlaskaChris 3b (My Page) on Tue, Apr 26, 11 at 20:51
| Hey MasterGardener. It's nice that you're so enthusiastic but it is sometimes hard to follow what you're trying to say. Also please keep in mind that you're on a GARDENING site. You keep talking about farming and commercial scale greenhouse production. While those topics are interesting folks on here are mostly concerned with how to grow a few veggies for their own families and have compost piles that reflect that level of use. If you want to talk about farming that's fine but you keep jumping between farming and gardening without explaining well which one you are talking about. They're very different... Hydroponics on the home scale is much more wasteful of limited resources than organic gardening in the ground. To start with you need lots of containers (usually plastic), piping or tubing, and a grow medium. Manufacturing and shipping all those things use up a lot of resources. Then you need electricity to run the pump to keep your water moving...another big use of a valuable resource (maybe you can set this up on a solar system but most home growers don't have that). Then there is the nutrients you need to add to the system. Most hydroponic systems use chemicals for that. I know you can set them up on an organic system. I don't know enough about the system to know if just compost tea can provide all the nutrients a hydroponic system needs or not, I suspect it's more complicated than that. Compare this to organic gardening. You might buy some wood to make a bed (although you don't even need to do that) so material costs to get started are pretty low. Nutrients come from the soil. Compost is added to the soil to improve it and add nutrients the plants need. Some people do add all kinds on nutrients to the soil, but I suspect most are like me and have only added a few things (like compost and manure). Sure you can buy these things out of a bag in a big box store but you can also create them right at home and find local sources of manure...so no/limited resources needed to process and ship them. Other fertilizers aren't needed most of the time. There is no electricity needed. So overall which is really better? |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, Apr 26, 11 at 21:27
| Alaska Chris You are right this is the wrong forum to talk about mass farming but I still thank you for the insight on it.A large scale investment of greenhouses would be ideal just look at alot of contries that practice(germany, canada, Netherlands,ect..). I know I have changed the subject many times in this but it is a related in some way. Thank you for responding. |
|
- Posted by realmaster none (My Page) on Wed, Apr 27, 11 at 0:45
| The soil is supposed to naturally have everything in it to grow whatever you need to naturally it comes down to where you are planting what. bannana trees fertilize themselves by fallen leaves or fallen bananas that naturally decompose on there roots Master gardener i can tell you are bored and sit around your room all day you are looking for a friend in the computer world and never did anything relating to farming in your life your little cat told me what you have done in the past 10 years and it has to do with some kind of master but not garden Synthetics are cheap and grow even more productive plants than organic however after 20 years the land is salt. You are a baboon and if the ground were salt would probably extract it to put in salt shakers Thank you so much for righting you are writing rightfully wrong mistaken misinterpreted facts There are such things as sustainable farming practices in many countries even this one and they produce fruits at a commercial rate go buy a bottle of Naked fruit juice or odwalla and read the label on the back |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Wed, Apr 27, 11 at 1:24
| "bannana trees fertilize themselves by fallen leaves or fallen bananas that naturally decompose on there roots" Maple trees do aswell...ecosystem... "Synthetics are cheap and grow even more productive plants than organic however after 20 years the land is salt. Go read the post called Angry Beneficial Microbes in the Permaculture Forum. Im just saying fertilizer applications harm the living soil. And yes I am a baboon ;)
|
|
- Posted by vermontkingdom 4a (My Page) on Wed, Apr 27, 11 at 7:14
| There is no reason to belittle or name call someone with whom you disagree. I've gardened for almost 50 years and find, for the most part, gardeners are firm in their own gardening beliefs but open and considerate of differing points of view. And, usually, and thankfully, that is the case for most gardeners who visit this site. |
|
| "...but as of last Friday, I now also have about 25,000 honeybees." (standing red-faced, wringing hat-in-hand) Hope you get a load of hay or a silver spoon. |
|
| ooooh, I've never had an admirer before! I'm quite pleased about it! I may have to give you a bread exemption, alphonse. (No one else, though.) |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Wed, Apr 27, 11 at 13:34
| Yes I agree with vermontkingdom. No need to name call. This is not the place for that. This is a place to talk about compost! |
|
| TheMasterGardener1, just out of curiosity is "realmaster" a neighbor of yours? Lloyd |
|
| Mastergardener1, are you in fact a certified Master Gardener? If not, your use of the title is misleading. If you are an MG, you should be aware that the title is not to be used as a sign of authority. In any case, it is inappropriate for you to use the MG title in an on-line forum. Doing so is a disservice, and may discredit certified Master Gardeners. For the record, the only reason MGs might discourage use of dairy, bones, fats, etc. in compost is because the typical home composter does not generate sufficient heat that is needed to break down those items. This can result in rotting, smell, and rodents. That is why most purchased compost bins tell you not to add those items, and why some municipalities prohibit composting altogether. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Mon, May 2, 11 at 13:39
| zuni I see what you are saying. I am only a gardener that would like to use MG1 as my name. Are you saying I can not use this name on here? I do not know of anything you are talking about. Composting fats??? What has been going on for the last mil. years?? So are you saying I cant use this name? You have to be certified to be a "Master Gardener"? Thanks. |
|
| annpat, you have MANY admirers here. I greatly enjoy each of your posts. Happy gardening.....Bill |
|
| Mastergardener1: Master Gardeners are trained and certified to provide unbiased, science-based, and sustainable gardening information and advice to the public. Each state and province has their own requirements. In the US, Master Gardeners are associated with the state and county extension agencies and agricultural colleges. In Ontario, MGs complete courses through either of two colleges, and volunteer for a minimum of two years before being certified. As volunteers, MGs are not paid, although they may receive an fee for providing presentations or writing articles. Such fees are used for group operating expenses. Some MG groups have much less rigorous training requirements; but the standard is in being able to accurately identify problems, and search credible sources for sustainable and science-based answers. I do not know if there is a trademark for the title Master Gardener in the US. However, since the 1970s MGs have become an international organization providing gardening information to the public. The title elicits a certain expectation from the public as well as those who have invested much time and effort to become trained volunteers.I hope this answers your question. |
|
| bill, are you trying to get a bread exemption? (DONE!!) (Now I feel like I need to be a better person to deserve your kindness (and I'm worried I can't do it).) TheMasterGardener1, yes, you certainly may use that moniker. There are no rules regarding what we may call ourselves here. |
|
- Posted by nutsaboutflowers 2b/3a (My Page) on Mon, May 2, 11 at 21:17
| TheMasterGardener1, yes, you certainly can call yourself whatever you like here, but I must agree with zuni. Your use of TheMasterGardener1 is misleading. I would also have to agree with AlaskaChris. I have read several of the 63 posts you have participated in within the last week, and find myself confused as to whether or not you have a compost pile of your own, or if the information you provide in an authoritative tone is just from something you've read. I'm finding your posts hard to follow because of the use of many abbreviations, spelling errors, and improper grammar. I am in no way condemning someone if they are unable to spell. However, is it possible if you typed slower and used less abbreviations, I'd be able to comprehend what it is you're trying to say? Welcome to Garden Web, BTW. =:) |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, May 3, 11 at 0:04
| Yea sorry about all that. I will be more proper for now. I was a bit out of line there. |
|
- Posted by darth_weeder z7 NY (My Page) on Tue, May 3, 11 at 9:24
| Posted by pt03 2b Southern Manitob (My Page) on Sat, Apr 30, 11 at 4:24 "TheMasterGardener1, just out of curiosity is "realmaster" a neighbor of yours? could be |
|
- Posted by simplegreenguy none (My Page) on Tue, May 3, 11 at 9:32
| This is the best laugh Ive had all Day Please post some more this is better than Saturday Night Live!!! |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, May 3, 11 at 10:29
| simplegreenguy I thank you for that. I plan to write somthing soon lol. |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Tue, May 3, 11 at 10:52
| Somthing I just found when I typed "advanced composting" online just now. www.advancedcomposting.com/advanced.html |
|
| I'd just like to mention that while Annpat has built many thousands of compost piles constructed of exotic seachickens, kelp manures, and now bee pee -- since the fall of 2005 every single one of those piles has successfully composted while listening exclusively to music provided by moi. All the best, |
|
- Posted by TheMasterGardener1 none (My Page) on Fri, May 6, 11 at 21:08
| Haha. Bee poop mmmmm dont get any better than that. |
|
| As I sit here listening to "I walk along the street of sorrow, the blvd of broken dreams....." I gotta admit what Paddy says is true. We (me and madmagic) met here, we fell in love the same way that me and flora and me and berry and me and, after you, dear alphonse, and my dear new friend bill, and whoops! I can't remember, right now, six vodkas in, who's my friend and who's them what find me annoying (I'm speaking Eliza Doolittle for flora), Well, I'm kim's only friend, so I've gotta be like the best one ever, don't you think? Ok, so I'm thinking hitting send after like six whatever they weres is not the best plan. I'm going to try to redeem myself two ways. Don't I type swell? a.) and b.) I spread a whole heck of a lot of annpat's pretty wonderful compost today. I planted peas, carrots, beets, borage (for the bees, alphonse) snapdragons (for the bees, alphonse), etc. |
|
| "I walk along the street of sorrow, the blvd of broken dreams....." The Diana Krall version. :) Just yesterday I discovered a source for the CDs by a Dutch band, coincidentally named Boulevard of Broken Dreams, who beautifully recorded that tune and many other old standards. Will be sending several your way soon, Ann dear. All the best, |
|
- Posted by dchall_san_antonio 8 San Antonio (My Page) on Sun, May 8, 11 at 21:42
| I wonder if we have a language barrier we're working through. TheMasterGardener1, where do you live? And as a side question, how did you get uppercase letters in your screen name? GW unceremoniously converted us all to lower case letters years ago. |
Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum. If you are a member, please log in. If you aren't yet a member, join now!
Return to the Soil Forum
Instructions
- You must be a registered member and logged in to post messages on our forums.
- Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review the contents and make changes.
- After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
- It is illegal to post copyrighted material without the owner's consent.
- HTML codes are allowed in the message field only.
- No advertising is allowed in any of the forums.
- If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
- If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.