Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
thecomposter

Removing Nitrogen from Soil

thecomposter
14 years ago

Is there anyway to remove Nitrogen from the soil quickly? I over fertilized and it's becoming an issue.

Comments (33)

  • gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
    14 years ago

    Incorporate sawdust, bark, wood chips or any wood product into the soil. That will serve to tie up the nitrogen and make it unavailable to the plants.

  • cowgirl2
    14 years ago

    High carbon material such as leaves or sawdust will work if you can dig it in. If not, watering will leach it out.

  • thecomposter
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    Thank you.

    It sounds like dried grass chipping would work. Plus, grass clippings would decompose faster than wood chips for next years crop.

    I already injected some wood chips into the rootball of one plant.

  • joepyeweed
    14 years ago

    Water... water... water...

  • gargwarb
    14 years ago

    What kind of fertilizer did you use, how much, and what sorts of problems are you seeing?

  • bpgreen
    14 years ago

    "It sounds like dried grass chipping would work. Plus, grass clippings would decompose faster than wood chips for next years crop. "

    No, that will add more nitrogen. You want something with more carbon.

  • struwwelpeter
    14 years ago

    If you can't disturb the plants, apply sugar solution; maybe, I am guessing, about 2 lb in 5 gals water per square yard.

  • thecomposter
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    This is the first I've heard of the use of sugar (not that this means much). It sounds like it will turn into an ant feast.

    Can you explain how the sugar works chemically?

  • joepyeweed
    14 years ago

    Sugar is high in carbon. The suggestions of wood chips or sugar is to add excess carbon to offset the extra nitrogen.

  • thecomposter
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    Will boric acid hurt plants?

    Since the sugar will attract ants, I should control them with boric acid.

  • gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
    14 years ago

    If the sugar is properly diluted in the water and applied to the soil - not the plants - there shouldn't be issues with ants. Ants in the garden are not really a problem unless they are farming aphids. If they appear anyway and you don't want them, bait for them with a saucer of sugar laced with boric acid. Don't apply it to the soil.

  • struwwelpeter
    14 years ago

    Can you explain how the sugar works chemically?

    After supplementing the soil bacterias' diet with sugar, the bacteria anabolize the fertilizer nitrogen and multiply.
    I think most of the nitrogen is converted to bacteria protein and the rest is released into the air.

    It was done in this article:

    Sweet success: adding carbon to counter invasions by plants by Peter Alpert

  • thecomposter
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    Thanks for the sugar info, I like to know how things work :)

    I added the sugar mix to a "test" plant a few hours ago, so see what happens. Can I assume the nitrogen level is reduce within hours of adding sugar?

  • jbann23
    14 years ago

    By all means don't add boric acid. It'll kill the soil like you wouldn't believe. Gardengal48 has mentioned this and she's dead on right. Even a little boric acid will sterilize the area you put it in and you really don't want that. Sugar is almost a pure carbon source but so soluble it passes right through the soil with rain and watering. Your living soil needs to have a 'stay around' source of carbon and fine sawdust is just the ticket. It does have to be mixed in, though, for it to use up excess nitrogen. Watering heavely may wash it out if it is a "blue" additive (MG). If it's something like over-application of blood meal or alfalfa then you'll have to get the carbon into the soil to make the compensation work. Hope this helps with your situation.

  • thecomposter
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    What is said here about sugar reducing the nitrogen supplied to the plants is false, my plants turned greener after adding the sugar solution.

  • gargwarb
    14 years ago

    Did you hurt yourself jumping to that conclusion?

  • thecomposter
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    In plants, much of the nitrogen is used in chlorophyll molecules which are essential for photosynthesis and further growth. Chlorophyll is a green pigment found in most plants

    The only thing I did differently is add the sugar solution and the plants turned greener. How would a different conclusion be determined?

  • gargwarb
    14 years ago

    Well, just for giggles, let's say your problem was an over application of nitrogen. Of course, I have no idea if your problem was over application of nitrogen because you never answered my questions above but let's just say that's what happened and follow it out a ways just for illustrative purposes.
    One of the biggest problems with nitrogen over application is its contribution to salinity. (In regards to this, nitrate nitrogen is a bigger contributor to salinity than other forms like urea or ammoniacal) Anyway, symptoms of salt toxicity may include yellowing foliage. Then time passes and some of the nitrogen leaches out of the soil (along with other salts) and some volatilizes and some is taken up by plants. Maybe even some could have been tied up by carbon sources in the soil. If nitrogen did decrease significantly , then your salinity would also drop, which could conceivably decrease plants stress and improved performance, very possibly resulting in greener plants. That's just one example of something that could happen. There are approximately 300,958,658 bajillion other possibilities. Anything that adds or relieves plants stress can affect performance and appearance:
    nutrients, soil moisture, evapotranspiration rates, root disease, light conditions, soil compaction, and on, and on, and on.....

    "if A, then B; B, therefore A" has a way of turning around and biting your backside.

  • robertz6
    14 years ago

    I use shredded leaves as my main 'brown', and would suggest them as a good short term solution. Wood chips and bigger woody materials may continue to use up soil nitrogen for years as they break down.

  • struwwelpeter
    14 years ago

    my plants turned greener after adding the sugar solution.

    For an experimental failure, that's relatively good news. The worst that could happen is the plants dying and the next worse is no effect.

    I should try it on my lawn.

  • Karenlow
    10 years ago

    Mix 1 gallon non chlorinated water with 1 Tablespoon of Wood Vinegar 1 Tbs Fish Amino Acid and 1 T calcium Phosphate. Some organic farmers also add 1T Brown Rice Vinegar to the water. Spray this on the soil to reduce the Nitrogen in the soil. After heavy rains, you can spray the same amount again as heavy rains cause a lot of nirogen in the air to fall on soils and plants. The rains causes fungal problems too. When you have fungal problems on plants, spray this solution when the day is hot with sun shining but use a fine, very fine mist spray. Hope that helps.

  • toxcrusadr
    10 years ago

    What exactly is Wood Vinegar?

    How do vinegar, amino acids (which contain significant N, although the amount being added here is small) and calcium phosphate actually work to reduce nitrogen?

  • TXEB
    10 years ago

    :-]

    watching

  • sanddaal
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Interesting reading. I to have a too much nitrogen problem with my cauliflowers. From adding too much fertiliser. So after continuous watering, do I resume feeding with a high potassium, low nitrogen food? How long after watering? My current caulis haven't flowered yet but not far from it.

  • armoured
    4 years ago

    Are you sure you need potassium? Is this from a soil test?

  • toxcrusadr
    4 years ago

    Ditto. How do you actually know you overfertilized?

  • sanddaal
    4 years ago

    Im not 'sure' it needs potassium, but thats what helps the plant to flower is it not?

  • sanddaal
    4 years ago

    I posted a pic and question to a garden centre page and asked. Huge lush green leaves and pathetic small discoloured curd. The conclusion was i added more than one fertilizer with too high nitrogen.

  • sanddaal
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I tried to post a pic but it wouldn't work.

  • Nevermore44 - 6a
    4 years ago

    For pics.... after you select your photo ... it shows up quickly but dimmed a bit. You need to wait a while until it shows up fully opaque before hitting post.

  • gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
    4 years ago

    sanddaal, what kinds of fertilizers have you been using and how often? Have you ever had a soil test done? Without one, it is impossible to know what kind of fertilizer - if any - needs to be applied and in what concentration.

    Fertilization is never a requirement. Plants access the nutrients they need for a healthy and productive life from the soil via their root system. In many cases, what they need is already present in the soil in sufficient quantity. Applying ferts when not needed can be counterproductive.

    N is used in the largest concentration but it is the most mobile nutrient and moves through the soil rapidly. It is often deficient as a result but also the easiest replaced. P&K are used in much lower concentrations but are also fairly immobile and tend to persist in the soil long term. Only a soil test will tell you if you have any need to supplement.

  • toxcrusadr
    4 years ago

    If your blooming problem is long standing (rather than this season) it could be a lack of phosphorus. That's what promotes blooming and fruiting. It is very sticky esp. in clay soils and may not be as available even if it is there. If you have a chronic problem with blooming you may need phosphorus. But a soil test would be the way to find out.