Return to the Tool Shed Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Chinese Portable Generators

Posted by starhust (My Page) on
Sat, Sep 16, 06 at 0:58

During the last year I have noticed a lot of Chinese generators for sale at very low prices. These generators have Honda clone engines (GX200) and produce 3,000 watts of power (25 amps @120 volts). There are about 4 major Chinese engine manufacturers that make the engines under a license agreement with Honda and they appear to be of very high quality. Some of these generators even come with an automatic voltage regulation control board and the overall electronic quality of these gensets seems to be very good as well.

Im interested in buying one of these units and was wondering if anyone might have some first hand experience with using one of these generators.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
    Sat, Sep 16, 06 at 10:39

A local building supply company has had this posted on their wall for the last generation:

The bitterness of low quality is remembered long after the happiness of low price has been forgotten.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by canguy British Columbia (My Page) on
    Sat, Sep 16, 06 at 10:48

What baymee said. There is a reason they are so cheap. If they were being built under licence the Honda name would appear on them. Both Honda and Briggs have notified their dealers that if any knockoffs appear on the shelves, the dealership agreement could be cancelled. We wont even try to service them, we don't need the parts and warranty headaches.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
    Sat, Sep 16, 06 at 15:47

I have to correct the saying for future use. I was trying to remember the exact words earlier and now I remember them.

It's "The bitterness of low quality is remembered long after the sweetness of low price is forgotten"


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

"Im interested in buying one of these units and was wondering if anyone might have some first hand experience with using one of these generators."

Do you have a need for a second generator, or did something happen to the Coleman Powermate you posted about on 3/17/06?

AZ


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Hello baymee and canguy! Indeed, I think I know how you feel. When I first saw some of these generators, I dismissed them as cheap junk. I didnt even bother to investigate any farther because I thought it would be a waste of my time. However, curiosity got the better of me and I decided to look closer at these generators.

Further investigation revealed that they looked to be well made but Im glad you brought up the point about parts and service. After all, whos going to fix one of these generators if it breaks? The warranties dont seem to be very impressive and you have to call a toll free number to get service should something go wrong. That aspect causes me some concern.

However, the Coleman Company (the same people that make the popular Coleman Powermate generators) also imports one of these Chinese clones. They call it the Proforce. It has a 5.5 HP engine (GX160 knockoff) and puts out 2,500 watts of power. They are widely available for $299.00 and less. Ive seen them at Wal-Mart and Pep Boys as well as a few other places. The Coleman generator has an excellent warranty and you can buy additional full replacement extended warranties for about $35.00 if you desire.

Hey azinoh, how are you doing? My 5,000 watt Coleman Powermate is running just fine but I am planning to sell it. Its a great generator but its too big for my needs. It puts out about 40 amps at all times and I only need about 25 amps max. For someone that needs the heavy duty power provided by one of these big 5,000 watt units, my Powermate would be just fine for them. However, why should I burn the gasoline needed for a 10 HP engine and produce 5,000 watts when I could instead run a 6.5 HP engine and produce 3,000 watts?

My thinking is that with a smaller generator Ill get all the power I need while using a lot less gasoline in the process. Also, if these Chinese generators are indeed good, I plan to buy two of them. As you know azinoh, I plan to use the generators for hurricane aftermath. With two generators, Ill be able to rotate their use on a daily basis to minimize wear. Also, if one generator breaks, Ill have the other as a backup. Of course the other significant reason for the small generator is to conserve gasoline. A 6.5 HP Honda clone GX200 is going to use a lot less gasoline than a 10 HP Briggs & Stratton OHV Intek.

My real concern is, of course, the reliability of these Chinese generators. Im always working on a better plan to survive a hurricane azinoh!


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

"It puts out about 40 amps at all times and I only need about 25 amps max."

Even with NO LOAD? Hmmm, it doesn't make sense to me. I thought the current delivered was determined by the load.

Do these things run hot like class "A" audio amps?

If I was powering a house with all the usual appliances including a computer, I would go Onan. Not cheap but clean power. I worry about spikes and surges.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Youre right newjerseybt! I should have said that 40 amps is available at all times. Also, you make a good point with the Onan generators. They are expensive and many of their generators are made in China. Onan owns a Chinese factory and is shifting their generator production to China.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

So...you want to trash your original plan before you've gone through a storm with it? And you want to take a loss on your original purchase so you can purchase something cheaper from which you'll have to start saving lots of fuel just to offset the loss...IF the storm comes (a BIG IF.) How much fuel will you save with the smaller generator over a 3 day period? Probably not enough to be concerned about since it's only for hurricane use.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

"Onan owns a Chinese factory and is shifting their generator production to China."
--------------------------------
I TAKE BACK what I said about Onan. First, the Chinese are clueless or don't care about quality control. I have bought middle priced to VERY expensive Chinese products in ALL categories. WHAT A NIGHTMARE!!! JUNK all JUNK from air conditioners to bathroom vanities to tools etc.

Some of the defects are more than obvious and are "covered up" as opposed to replacing the damaged part before shipping. I had doors on a $1200 vanity "touched up" where chunks of solid Cherry were torn out due to poor fitted doors. They put original stain over the gouges which mean't the damage happened at the factory.

I cannot tell you how much time I spent plus gas and wear and tear I put on my vehicles returning defective stuff and PEOPLE DO NOT CARE. The stores get it so cheap that they do not care about your grief. Do you hear that Walmart? Hewlett Packard??

Secondly, what happens in a cold war situation? The American consumer will be sucking wind like beached tunas trying to get parts. I now avoid Chinese products like the plague. Buy AMERICAN when possible.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
    Sun, Sep 17, 06 at 12:20

I'm glad you learned a lesson, BT.

I have occasion to take stuff to the scrap dealer and on the weight scale desk is a notice to the public. China will not accept any scrap metal from any computer or electronic related source.

In other words, they send scrap here but won't take it back.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by canguy British Columbia (My Page) on
    Sun, Sep 17, 06 at 15:21

Baymee, that is funny. I think Chinese products will get better as their government says they are cracking down on counterfeiters. They want to improve their international image. 40 years ago, Japan had a similar reputation and look at them now. Also, as Chinese products get more popular, they will blip on the EPA's radar and be forced to clean up their act.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

starhust, stay with your Coleman set-up. As you may have noticed, gas prices are coming down. And the Chinese generators are not built for the "long haul". Not to mention the aformentioned service issues.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
    Sun, Sep 17, 06 at 20:24

Canguy, I remember well when "Made in Japan" meant plain junk. Then came "Made in Taiwan". Both nations now produce top notch material and are our allies.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Hi anzinoh! My original plan was sound and it will work but I think it could use some improvement. When I put together my original hurricane plan I was limited by time. I had to get it all together and be ready to go by June 1st. Therefore, some of my plan was just plain overkill and the generator certainly falls in this category. I have spent the past several months refining my original plan and I have concluded that the 5,000 watt Coleman Powermate is too big for my needs.

Dont worry about the financial aspect. Ive got that covered and Im not taking any kind of loss on the deal. Actually, Ill make a few dollars! These Chinese generators are very inexpensive compared to my Coleman. I could sell the Coleman and buy two Chinese generators and still have several dollars left over!

A smaller generator will allow me to significantly minimize fuel consumption and extend my running time. Since I do not yet own one of these Honda clones, my fuel consumption and extended running time figures are only theoretical at this point. I need to get one of these generators and test it in the real world to confirm, deny or modify my theory.

I originally looked at the 3,250 watt Briggs & Stratton generator with a 6.5 HP engine. Its a nice unit and I can purchase one for $399.00 but its far more expensive than the Chinese generators and (based upon specification sheets) isnt as fuel efficient. The Honda GX160 and GX200 engines are remarkable for their power and fuel economy and that is the reason why I was drawn to the clones.

Hey hawkeyebob62! Dont worry, Im not throwing out the Coleman setup.. at least not yet. It will be more like a gradual transition if indeed it happens at all. At this point, Im still in the investigation stage. There are several real advantages to the Chinese generators (assuming reliability). I can buy two of these units for less than the money I could get for my Coleman. With my stored gasoline supply, I would be able to run twice as long (i.e. if I could run 5 days with the Coleman, I could run 10 days with the Chinese generator). With two generators I could alternate their use. You know as well as I that none of these consumer grade generators are made for 24/7 output for an extended period of time. If one Chinese generator breaks, Ill have the other as a backup. If the Coleman breaks, I wont have a generator at all.

I was just thinking out loud for you hawkeyebob62. Those are my main reasons for looking at the Chinese generators. The parts and service aspect is becoming less of a concern to me. I have found several sources for both parts and service for these Honda clones in my local area and clone parts are readily available via the Internet. Also, the Chinese generator manufacturer that I am considering buying from (Lifan) is licensed by Honda to produce the GX200 engine for export to the USA and the engine meets or exceeds all EPA and CARB standards.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

"..I remember well when "Made in Japan" meant plain junk. Then came "Made in Taiwan". Both nations now produce top notch material and are our allies."

They were and still are free countries compared to China. People tend to produce much better products under those conditions. It is also interesting that Russia is not in the competitive loop.

Regarding cheap generators...if they are anything like the products I bought, they may turn out to be expensive in the long run. Oh yeah, tomorrow I return my Chinese "Martha Stuart" meat thermometer to Walmart. The pointer spins freely on the shaft...the third one of those in 18 months...also returning my 2nd Chinese optical mouse for my PC by MicroInnovations. What a dud!


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

As part of my interest in and questions about Chinese generators, I was surprised to learn that several of these devices are of very high quality. I recently learned that the Chinese generator sold by Coleman as the ProForce 2500, seems to be almost identical to the Yamaha EF2600. Its even built by the same company, Linhai Power Machinery.

Both generators share the exact same specifications, except for the GFCI and twistlock power outlets on the Yamaha. The Yamaha lists for $900.00 while the Coleman lists for $400.00 (and is often discounted to less than $300.00). The parts diagram and manual for each generator list the exact same part numbers for the crankshaft, ball bearings and all the other parts. Theres no significant difference between these two generators. A little more research revealed that Linhai Power Machinery has entered into a number of joint ventures with Yamaha, Honda, Coleman and several other companies to build generators, small engines and motorcycles.

Does anyone own or have first hand experience using a Coleman ProForce 2500 generator? It comes with a 120 volt duplex outlet and the specifications state it is rated at 20 amps. Thats very impressive for such a small generator. Im interested in this generator and would appreciate any information concerning any practical experience anyone might have in the use of this device.

Here is a link that might be useful: Coleman ProForce 2500 Generator


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
    Tue, Sep 19, 06 at 5:41

This is still my advice:

The bitterness of low quality is remembered long after the sweetness of low price is forgotten


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I found out today that all of the Onan portable generators are made in China too. The engines are Honda knockoff's. They are very good units. The Onan Homesite Power 2400 sells for $566.00 (discounted). It's identical to the Coleman ProForce 2500.

Here is a link that might be useful: Onan Portable Generators


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I made a mistake in the post above. The Onan 2400 actually uses the JIANGDONG JF200 engine (6.5 HP). The generator is made by the same company and is similar to the JD3000.

Sorry for the mix up. I've got to keep the Honda and the Yamaha clones in the right order!

Here is a link that might be useful: JD3000


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by canguy British Columbia (My Page) on
    Wed, Sep 20, 06 at 13:57

Except for a couple of models supplied to Lincoln and Miller for welders, Onan is now out of the aircooled engine business. Still, I am surprised they would go to China for a low end product. The parent company, Cummins, is likely having the same patent infringement problems as other manufacturers.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
    Thu, Sep 21, 06 at 5:50

All this talk about Onans reminds me that I have a brand new 14HP with LP and Gas carb from the 70's and never run. I never did get it to run by holding a propane torch at the carb, as suggested on this forum, but now that I have a new carb for gasoline, I don't have the time.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I have the Coleman 5000 with the 10hp tec. on it, I recently used it for the storm that hit Long Island.I ran it 10 hrs loading my furnace,refrig,den,office,garage and outdoor lights. It was a trooper, Very Loud but ran well. I have a transfer box set up with six switches and works well.

I also saw the cheap China Disels on the market but with me I have to have a reputable name brand. When things are to cheap it raises flags for me.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

You know pjdbm, you sound just like me last year! I fully appreciate your feelings about name brand equipment and low price bargains. The last thing I want is an unreliable generator to quit on me during an extended power failure.

I live along the coast in Florida and after our spate of hurricanes during 2004 and 2005 I decided we needed a generator. We got hit by Ivan and then 10 months later Dennis came our way. Both times we had long power failures.

When I started looking for a generator, the first priority on my list was reliability. I wanted something that was not going to break after a week or two of continuous power production. Naturally the safest thing to do is to stick with the well known brand names such as Coleman, Briggs & Stratton, Generac, Honda, etc. I stuck to that plan and bought a 5,000 watt Coleman generator. Mine is just like yours except mine has the Briggs & Stratton engine. As you know, that generator produces all the power youll need and much more. For my situation, that created a problem.

I dont need all the power that Coleman puts out. I just need to run my refrigerator/freezer, two 8,000 BTU window AC units, a few fans and a few lights. During the daylight hours I only need about 3,000 watts and at night I only need about 1,500 to 2,000 watts. Clearly, the Coleman was overkill. Therefore, rather than needlessly wasting gasoline, I decided to buy a smaller generator.

I looked at the Honda EN2500 and figured it would almost meet my needs. Its specially designed for homeowner use during power failures. The only problem was that its a little too small. So I moved up to the next Honda model and it proved to be a little too small as well. Well, before I could blink, I had worked my way through the entire Honda generator line and I found nothing that worked for me. I was unable to find a model that fit my needs with the right combination of engine size, gas tank size, power output and price.

I then moved on and looked at the Coleman models again but still found nothing there either. I looked at Yamaha, Kipor, Robin/Subaru, Sears, Onan, Generac and a few others. I still found nothing that really suited my needs. While I found plenty of generators that would work, they all involved some compromise. When I bought the Coleman I was working against a time limit. I had to buy a generator, store gas and take care of some other hurricane preparation items before the season commenced. Now I can take my time and do some basic research and make refinements to my hurricane plan. The selection of the generator(s) is just one part of the overall plan.

My investigation is not yet final. However, preliminary results support the conclusion that some Chinese generators (under various brand names) are very well made and highly reliable. The models I have researched are not gray market or unauthorized clones but rather legitimately licensed generator designs that are made in agreement and cooperation with other manufacturers such as Honda, Yamaha, Kawasaki and Coleman. I still have some more research to accomplish before I make my final decision.

For sure, not all of the Chinese generators are good. There are certainly some that are poorly made but its not too difficult to identify and separate the bad designs from the good units.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I hear you,

I am looking to upgrade to a diesel that I can run Home heating oil in. Where I live there is no natural gas and I rather not store propane.Its sort of a pain to run out in the middle of the night to get gas for the generator and If power is out the gas stations are not pumping so my next idea is to go with the diesel.

I would step it up to 7500 watts, the max my transfer can handle. At 7500 watts I can clearly run my whole house with out a worry. I have to say that my Coleman with the tec. engine starts on the third pull.The only issue I have is the noise,it screams!!!! I had purchased a Nelson low tone muffler for it and istalled it prior to the last storm and it was noticable quieter but while running ten hours it actually broke the welds on the new muffler. I had to reinstall the stock muffler.

I guess I would not recommend the Nelson quiet muffler for these machines. :)


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

For your area and situation diesel is a good choice. If I had the desire to go with a whole house generator, diesel would be my choice too. You just have to keep an eye on the fuel and make sure algae doesnt start growing in it. Where I live, all the utilities are under ground. After Ivan many people that had natural gas whole house generators were very disappointed. Lots of big trees were uprooted due to the storm and the natural gas lines were broken. Our area had many natural gas pipeline shutdowns and many folks were cussing their natural gas powered generators.

Propane whole house generators didnt fare much better. A 500 gallon propane tank only lasted them for about 5 days and the average power failure down here was for 2 weeks. The propane generator owners were cussing too on the sixth day and even after because all the propane dealers were closed until power was restored!

Everyones situation is different. Due to medical problems, some people require power 24/7 and their health would be put in jeopardy without a dependable backup generator. My family is not in that category. Also, we dont need a whole house generator. Despite all the recent commotion, major hurricanes are a rather rare occurrence. With any luck at all, well most likely not even need to use our generator. So, for us, it doesnt make a great deal of sense to spend the money for a whole house system. I dont need to power the water heater or any other hard wired appliances in the house. A small portable generator is perfect for our needs.

We just want to run a few window AC units, the refrigerator, a few fans and some lights. If the previous hurricanes are any indication, we may need to run a generator for 2 or more weeks. Thats precisely the reason why I am using a gasoline powered generator and why I am going to sell the Coleman. That big 10 HP engine on the Coleman is going to use at least twice as much gas as a 6.5 HP GX200 clone engine. That opens up several options for me. I can either store less gasoline or continue to store the same amount but double my run time!

From first hand experience I can tell you that gasoline is not going to be available at the pump for at least a week after a big hurricane moves through. After a week, even if you still cant get gas locally, you can drive a few miles and find gas. With a smaller generator Ill have all the power I need plus Ill have enough fuel for any eventuality.

I just received some specification and testing data on the Jiang Dong JF200 engine and the JD3000 generator that confirms my personal observations and the research Ive done. I plan to purchase one these generators and conduct my own tests. Based upon preliminary information I have seen, this generator is able to maintain both its voltage (120 volts) and frequency (60 Hz) at 25 amps of power. Its also very fuel efficient. It seems to be the best price, performance and quality portable generator currently on the market.

I too am familiar with after market small engine mufflers. My next door neighbor wanted to quiet down his generator and I helped him install the Super Trapp Muffler. Its sold by Jacks Small Engines. The Super Trapp works pretty well. We put it on his 10 HP Briggs and it brought the sound level down and also changed the tone of the exhaust as well. The down side is that it also increased the back pressure and reduced the fuel economy of the engine. It burned more gas with the Super Trapp installed. I think youll find that to be true with most muffler designs. Engines run with better fuel economy when the exhaust is unrestricted.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I was able to get the owners manual for the Coleman ProForce 2500 and it answered several questions. The generator will put out 20.8 amps on a continuous basis and you can draw all or any part of that current through one 120 volt outlet. I also got a schematic wiring diagram for the Yamaha EF2600. Except for some minor wiring changes, the EF2600 and ProForce 2500 are the same. The EF2600 is a little less powerful with a rated current output of 19 amps. However, the information I got from Yamaha was much more detailed than what I received from Coleman.

Im very impressed with what I have seen of the Coleman ProForce 2500 and I plan to purchase one next week if I can find a good price. The lowest price Ive found so far is $279.99.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by canguy British Columbia (My Page) on
    Tue, Sep 26, 06 at 23:14

Schematic might be similar but it does not indicate the guage and quality of the windings or components. I have seen a number of entry level units including Coleman fail because the rotor windings softened and distorted from heat. They hit the stator and tear up. One rewind shop I know of can install wedges in the rotor to contain the windings but the repair is more than half the price of a new unit. Hardly worthwhile. I'll save my allowance and go with the better brand names to avoid the headaches.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Another point regarding natural gas. Someone told me that you can lose the supply because it takes electricity to run the natural gas pumps. Therefore, it does not taken uprooted trees alone to "knock out" your service.

Even gasoline consumption on the smaller 10KW generators can be high. Even if you topped up all your cars and trucks and siphoned the gas when needed, you would be hard pressed to keep power up on cold Winter days. I am alluding to the ice storm we had here in PA a few years ago when power was out for 3 weeks and more.

In the above stated cases, the key is versatility. What is the best generator that can use multiple sources of fuel
and run reliably.

I think a stockpile of k-1 kerosene using 23k BTU convection heaters could save the day IMO.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

That raises a good point about the alternator canguy. Thank you for bringing it to my attention. They could have decided to use smaller gauge or inferior wire in the alternator windings. I decided to check for myself. I have a Yamaha dealer that has an EF2600 on display in his showroom. I took a flashlight along with me and looked into the ventilation slots on the alternator end bell and I could clearly see the copper alternator windings. I then went over to the local Pep Boys store and looked into the ventilation slots on the alternator end bell of the ProForce 2500.

The copper windings on each alternator were the same and each alternator end bell is attached with two 10 mm bolts. Identical distinctive markings were apparent on the end caps of all four bolts. Quality control inspection stamps were the same on both alternators as well. They were obviously manufactured and assembled by the same company. Both have floating grounds as well.

Even the Yamaha dealer told me that the two generators were the same. I just figured they were the same since they look identical, weigh the same and have the same maker. I hadnt really thought about the alternator windings until you brought it to my attention. I guess you cant be too careful so thanks again canguy!

You make some very good points newjerseybt. I would not rely upon natural gas or propane in an emergency situation. As previously mentioned, natural gas supplies can easily be disrupted by a storm. Propane seems to be a good choice until you examine its energy content. Propane has a very low BTU content and therefore it takes a huge tank to run a generator. Its just too expensive and basically impractical compared to other fuels.

However diesel, kerosene, fuel oil and gasoline are all very high in BTU content and make excellent fuels for an emergency generator. It just comes down to the logistics of extended safe fuel storage.

Running an emergency generator in Florida is a lot easier than up north. We dont have to worry about starting a generator in sub zero weather, thick oil, gelled diesel, frozen fuel filters, carburetor icing, running a furnace or other such cold weather challenges. Running a portable generator in the middle of a snow storm is a very difficult task. I wouldnt enjoy having to go out in the snow to refuel the generator! Heck, just keeping the generator from getting buried in a snow drift creates its own set of problems. Its no wonder I moved to Florida!

It does get a little cold down here sometimes newjerseybt. I have 10 gallons of K-1 kerosene I keep on hand and 2 Aladdin lamps for light and heat in the winter!


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I guess it is no secret that Honda has been making engines all over the world for many years now. The chronology of the various Honda divisions is very interesting although my main research has centered on the power equipment division (i.e. small engines). To make a long story short, Honda is in joint partnership with China to produce power equipment.

There is the Jialing-Honda Motor Company that makes engines, lawn mowers and pumps. There is also the Honda-Mingdong Generator Company that makes and exports generators. Honda has several small engine plants in the USA too.

Also, Honda has licensed several other companies in China and other parts of Asia to produce a variety of small engines including the popular GX100, GX160, GX200, GX390 and others. The Jiangdong licensed Honda engines are reputed to be better than the original Honda engines from which they are descended. These engines are known for their high quality and low price and are preferred replacements for original Honda GX series engines.

I found it rather difficult to believe that these clone engines could be any good. Originally in my search for a generator, I excluded anything that did not have a well known brand name. I assumed that these clone engines would use inferior parts and that getting replacement parts or repair work done would be next to impossible. Then again, I thought the same thing when John Deere first started using Kawasaki small engines in some of their equipment.

I decided to take another look at the clones since they are becoming more prevalent in the market and because of the low prices. I went to a local kart race track where GX200 engines are popular. I got a first hand look at GX200s and their clones torn down on the workbench. I was told (and saw) that there is little difference between them. The internals from one engine fit the other exactly.

Since these kart racers often run these engines at 7,000 RPM, I think inferior components would show up quickly. Yet all the kart racers to whom I spoke reported that the quality of the clone engines was very high and they confirmed that parts between the Honda engines and the clones are interchangeable and that manufacturing tolerances were similar. I also checked at a small engine repair shop across town and got similar information from the shop owner.

Therefore, based upon the testimony of people that have direct knowledge and use of these engines and my own personal observations and research, I ordered two generators. They should arrive next week.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Sometimes I get fed up of hearing people here think we are so great, that we are simply the best and second to none, as if other people and countries dont have brains, and buildings and machinery and engineers and thinkers who can manufacture as good a product or better than what we have here. Sure we do get some junk products here because we have local importers and businessmen here who get products made very cheaply to their specs in third world countries and as per their own needs and request, then they bring it in voluntarily and sell it back to us with a huge profit, these are the real people getting filthy rich off us and profitering from the situation.

If we are still so great here why is our auto industry rated 3rd behind the Japanese and Europeans and loosing ground year after year, why has are steel industry gone to the dogs, why are so many of are companies in bad financial shape and so many of our companies saved from bankruptcy, ruin and total shutdown, bailed out by European, Asian and off shore companies. May be we arent so smart and so good after all. Maybe many here are still living in the past !

We here only represent approx. 5% of the planets total population, we do not really have a monopoly on anything, we had better stop contemplating are navels and thinking we are numero uno and that we are the greatest, there is a whole other world out there, its alive and thriving but too many here still do not want to see it and acknowledge it. Slowly these countries and their products are replacing ours in importance and financial success.

Maybe we need to travel and go out there and take a look at the real world of today.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

It appears now that Chinese generators are taking over the market in the USA. I noticed that Ace Hardware is now selling the "DEK" brand of generators. Also, as many of you know, American Honda does not allow its dealers to sell or repair Chinese generators. As a result, Honda small engine franchises are beginning to diminish. My local Honda dealer dumped his franchise last month so he could sell and provide service for several Chinese generator brands.

Most, if not all, of the national auto parts stores (Advance Auto, Pep Boys, OReilly Auto, etc.) are selling various brands of Chinese generators too. In addition, a lot of these Chinese engines are being used in pressure washers, water pumps and the engines are being sold as do it yourself replacements for other lawn and garden equipment.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by canguy British Columbia (My Page) on
    Wed, Oct 25, 06 at 19:03

I work for a Honda and Briggs dealership and we do not sell the clones for the reason starhust mentions. Honda or any other manufacturer cannot tell us what we can and cannot service but they do not want us to install their parts in the clones. It is a liability issue and we don't want hassles with warranty so we won't touch them even if the importers supplied the parts.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

"Sometimes I get fed up of hearing people here think we are so great, that we are simply the best and second to none, as if other people and countries dont have brains'
-------------------------------
The Chinese are not stupid people by any means...just the opposite ...it is just that I believe that communism is evil...and when you support a communist country you are supporting evil and no, I do not believe that supporting a communist country automatically sets the stage for a democracy. You do strengthen a communist country though.

I have been trying to do my part lately in buying ALL American made products...at least the high dollar items such as Porter Cable, Ariens, Kitchen Aid. I'll admit that it is hard to walk into Walmart and NOT support communism although they do sell some items that are Made in USA. I would also support Canadian made goods but the politics shipping across the border can be a pain according to some GW members who have tried online shopping.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Regarding windings,if you look inside and think you are looking at copper alternator windings, you have been fooled. What you see is copper colored enamel. If the copper was exposed for you to see on the windings you would have a boat anchor. What is really under the enamel will be 100% copper if you're lucky, but these days you run the risk of having windings made of aluminum, copper clad aluminum, or copper clad steel. All in the name of beating the high price of copper.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

The description of the Coleman ProForce 2500 generator states in part "...100% copper wound brushless alternator with cast aluminum bearing supports for longer life". I provided a link for the entire description.

Certainly, the Yamaha model EF2600 is a very good generator but so is the ProForce 2600.

Here is a link that might be useful: Coleman ProForce 2500 Generator


 o
Far East Generators

Compare these generators yourself.

Here is a link that might be useful: Yamaha EF2600


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

" Regarding windings,if you look inside and think you are looking at copper alternator windings, you have been fooled. What you see is copper colored enamel. If the copper was exposed for you to see on the windings you would have a boat anchor. What is really under the enamel will be 100% copper if you're lucky, but these days you run the risk of having windings made of aluminum, copper clad aluminum, or copper clad steel. All in the name of beating the high price of copper. "

I think that people here are forgetting that although these products are MADE in CHINA which makes them = to the devil I guess, these products must meet safety standards and codes and must be approved or would not be allowed in.
2 of the most modern and up to date cities in the world are Bejing and Shanghai China and they are 2 of the fastest growing also, they have modern plants, very good technology with state of the art production equpment in many plants, staffed with well educated employees, far lower wages as things cost far less there. I guess people here still love to kid themselves, the largest emerging country on this planet with 1.5 billion in population can do an awful lot more growing economically and otherwise than a country with 300 million in population. China is presently starting to live through the same growth as post second world war here. Communism is going to the way side with the pesants in favor of capitalism but this is beginning to be poorly hidden now by the Chinese government. Believe what you want, continue to kid yourself if you wish, but the power, economics and balance is shifting elsewere in todays real world.

10 years from now we will be buying Chinese made automobiles replacing our Honda's, Toyota's, Hyundai's, Kia's etc., we will also gladly be purchasing Chinese electronics, clothing and main stay goods etc. etc. etc.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by canguy British Columbia (My Page) on
    Thu, Oct 26, 06 at 22:54

I don't have a problem with the Chinese people, they are a huge untapped market and likely will be the next economic superpower. The issue here are the counterfeitors that are taking advantage of our greed and flooding the market with low priced junk. Why bother developing and producing a quality product at a fair price only to have it crudely copied and blown out at rock bottom? Eventually, Chinese made products will improve just as the Japenese did. Then someone else, possibly the Russians, will start the cycle again.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

That is as the world has turned for thousands of years.

Roman Empire, Persien Empire etc. etc. etc.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

tahclep,

Why you pasted my information on conductor materials followed by a lecture of yours about China is beyond me. Read my post again. Where am I talking about countries?


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

"The issue here are the counterfeitors that are taking advantage of our greed and flooding the market with low priced junk. Why bother developing and producing a quality product at a fair price only to have it crudely copied and blown out at rock bottom?"

***

You make a bold assertion that these imported generators are "low priced junk", yet you offer no evidence to support such a conclusion. My observations and experience with these Chinese generators lead me to think that they offer very high quality at a very low price. I honestly dont care who makes them. My computer is an IBM clone made in China and it is state of the art. My USB external hard drive was made in China and it too is state of the art.

You also assert that these generators are counterfeit, yet again you provide no evidence to support that claim. I have not seen any counterfeit engines or generators in the USA. The makers and importers of these engines and generators do not attempt to pass them off as Honda made products. They are clearly clones, not counterfeits.

Are you trying to say that these engines violate Hondas patent rights? The Honda GX engine series was developed back in 1983. Are you suggesting that Honda should have the exclusive right to manufacture the GX engine series without any time limit? Industrial patents only last for 20 years and they cant be renewed. Hondas patents on the GX engine series expired several years ago.

Honda cannot renew their patent on the GX engine for good reason. Patents are designed to expire to promote free access, trade and research development. As an example, some of the Chinese Honda clone engines now have their own patents because Chinese engineers improved the GX engine design. The clone engines are now better than the originals in many respects. Kart racers that I have spoken with tell me that they can get more torque out of GX200 clone than the Honda original.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I purchased the kingcraft 2500w 12vdc generator with the 168F 5.5 engine from Aldi of all places. It was $199.00 IT works great I have run 2 refrigerators and a well pump at the same time.Its as about as quiet as a coleman powermate,ITs a little heavy though, I easily put some casters on it.As far as service who cares for 199 bucks Ill just bye another one.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

That Kingcraft 2500 looks very similar to the Coleman ProForce 2500. At $199.00 you got a great deal on that generator and, as you point out, service and parts are not very important at that price! The specifications state that it has a rated output of 2200 watts (18 amps) so its got plenty of power. You found a terrific bargain.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Hello to all.

Found your interesting forum while researching home generators. Costco has a Cummins Onan Homesite 6500 Portable Generator available at $679 which includes shipping and wheels but no battery. (5000 watts, 5500 peak) I also found this model available elsewhere for slightly fewer dollars, however shipping is not included.

While cruising the web, I found a Gentron (6500 watt peak, 6000 continous) generator "Pro Series". The engine is a Lifon (Chinese). The ad stated it had a JD engine, however all models in 2007 will be shipped with a Lifon. This machine is available (or was) for $699, an attractive price which includes shipping. The ad did state: "This is a pre-order special for shipment arriving Dec. 30, 2006", so it may not be available at that price. It did at least give me a benchmark in pricing. Does anyone here have any knowledge of this company and its generators?
http://www.generatordepot.us/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=30

Does anyone here provide a weather shelter for protection, or some sort of a doghouse when operating their machines? It would make sense to add soundproofing material inside a housing shelter to cut down on the noise. Paint it white to reflect the sun and extend the housing lengthwise to contain the noise.

I also found that some machines don't have an "automatic voltage regulator". The Cummins-Onan and Gentron have them although Onan didn't list it in their specs. I called Onan about this, and the woman did'nt know the answer. She asked someone offline, and then stated it had one. Makes me nervous when I get this kind of response.

Any comments or suggestions? I'd like to hear as much as can be provided about the Cummins-Onan. I'm leaning in that direction.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Don't know about generators... My brother bought a cheap azz 49cc Lifan Chinese pocket dirt bike. Required a lot of tweaking and adjustment since it isn't tuned from the factory. However he is on his third year with it and the bike starst after two pulls when cold no stuttering. He started it in -15 degrees celsius no problem. The periferal parts are cheap for sure... But, these parts are easy to replace yourself and the bikes are compatible with high end parts makers. $300.00 over 3 years plus about $60.00 in parts is pretty darn cheap considering he has actually jumped this thing off five foot drops...

Bottom line if it's under $500.00 and it's easy to work on, chinese small engine products are pretty good bang for the buck. After $500.00, it isn't worth the time and money at the begining spent on tweaking and adjusting.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I finally purchased the Cummins Onan Homesite 6500 through Costco after researching several brands and eventually talking to my electrician. He'll be installing the Manual Transfer Power Switch. Now it's time to design & build, or buy a shelter in addition to coming up with some noise reduction solutions. This machine is rated at 76 dBA.

Briefly cruised the web and saw that acoustic materials are expensive. Along with that, I'll need to find something that will safely tolerate heat. I've decided to paint the shelter olive drab to blend in with the nearby foliage, between our Peonies and climbing roses growing against a white barn.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

greendrum, ANY "housing" will need plenty of air flow. these are air-cooled engines.

I use cinder blocks. I stack them higher than the genset, then cover it with plywood, then put some blocks on to keep the plywood down.

The key is that two of the middle rows of blocks are turned so that the holes allow air flow.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I purchased a heavy-duty "plastic" trash barrel storage shed, cut out large openings on three sides to install large gable vents (louvers) and mounted two 20" box fans on opposite ends. The generator is sitting on a set of wheels and feet with rubber tips. The fans are plugged into the generator and come on when it starts. Airflow is from left to right as one fan pulls in air and the other exhausts it. The generator engine exhaust is only several inches from the exhausting fan and the air flows unobstructed around, underneath and over the elevated machine.

The shelter top opens like the hood of a car. I've run the generator twice for testing purposes and with the "hood" either open or closed, the machine runs nice and cool. Outside air temperatures during both runs have been 22F and 30F.

The front of my gen-shed opens with two doors split down the middle. During hot summer months when I excercise it or actually have to use it, I plan to run it with the hood and front doors open. Can't get any more air flow than that. So far, we've had several rain and mixed rain/snow days and this thing is as dry as the inside of my house. The gable/louvers are very effective also come with screens to keep out critters. Next step is to have it wired with a transfer switch by a professional, paint it flat olive drab and watch it dissappear! :)

I store the fans in my cellar at room temperature, by the way. If by chance this thing does get wet, plan B is to purchase some sheets of thin, stiff plastic at A.C. Moore to cover the louvers. I also bought a cover for the generator made by "Classic".


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

One more very important item I left out. The gen-shed is on a slope and is leveled, of course. This prevents water from flowing through or accumulating inside (Boy
Scout days pitching tents). I also added plywood floorboards inside for support.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I have a question about a Chinese generator a 350 watt chicago electric generator. I am trying to find out who made it so I can buy parts when needed here is a picture
http://hudsonvalley.craigslist.org/wan/408778646.html


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Well all I got to say (which most don't want to here)when you by off brands and cheap you better take very good care of this equipment cause parts may be hard or not available and the meterials aren't cast or have the same rust prevention as main brand products, why? that costs too much and they have no good name to ruin.

I don't blame china. at the being of the 20 century they could not cast or forge a rake or a shovel. I blame CEO's who sell out there products for cheap labor so they can pocket hundreds of millions of dollars using near slave labor. All of this defruads the comsumers which don't care as long as they save a buck untill the junk breaks or when the job loss hits home.

Do you really think that once they learn this and have the molds beings they honor no patent or trademarks rules that most of the rest of the world follow their not going to use it????? That's the cost of doing business with third world. Some say china is not the third world, but look how the adverage chinamen lives and what freedoms they have. Yes, this will offend some in high levels of management, but you allow it and want to cover it up at the blue collar worker expence.

China breaks every patent and copies anything they can. We even give them all the opinions to do it and sometimes teach them how. I will not be suprised one day the US gov. will contract out it military work. which is already happening, but not as wide spread as the free enterprise world. Just emagine being bombed by the bombs you built or the plane that dropped them??? How long will it take to copy that!!!??? IMO not long.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Hey everyone... I'm in the market for a portable generator for emergency power for my home... I've got a 150' deep well with a submersible pump, that I'm not totally sure how man HP it is... Some of what I read leads me to believe that submersible pumps can be as much as 1.5HP, and pull 5000 watts at startup or something like that...

So, anyway, I have two concerns...

One is the size of generator I need, which I assume to be at least 5000 Watts... need to run furnace, fridge, freezer, water pump... and a few lights.

Second area of concern... Voltage surges and/or Automatic Voltage Regulation. My concerns in this area are related to my furnace's electronics(or any other 'sensitive electronic' stuff I might have plugged in)... and what happens when say the water pump turns on and off and possibly creates a surge in electricity, etc... One of my neighbors claims his furnace was damaged when his generator had a voltage surge... I've had a electronic board in my furnace fail in the past, for reasons not totally known, but I it looked to me like a voltage surge of some sort, as one of the relays on the board had clearly visible damage that to me looked likely to be caused by voltage spike of some sort...

But anyway... back to "Chinese Portable Generators"...

I've been looking at the "ProForce 6000", you can find them for as little as $600. They have a 12HP OHV (no name) motor, put out 6000 watts... AND have Automatic Voltage Regulation.

It seems most low cost generators sold at big box stores, do not have AVR. I'm not sure I really have to have AVR, but it sounds like a good thing to have...

The question(s) are... Does anyone have any real details or knowledge of the ProForce 6000 (Model# PM0106000). Is there something better out there for $600-$700? Should I be concerned about getting a generator with AVR? (because they are kind of hard to find in a reasonably priced generator).

Thanks for any help that can be provided...

Here is a link that might be useful: ProForce 6000 Watt generator.


 o
Or how about this...

Or perhaps... I'd be better off buying a smaller generator, say a 2500 or 3000 watt generator and only running my water pump as needed... Say most of the time just run my furnace and maybe a freezer or fridge one at a time... then only connect the water pump up occasionally when I need to take a shower, etc... (and disconnect any sensitive stuff if/when I run the water pump) I guess then, the big question would be... will a 2500 watt generator safely operate a submersible water pump and/or it's startup load?

I do like the idea of only spending $300 on a generator... and also like the idea of saving gas when I only need 2500 or 3000 watts at any given moment... Gas is EXPENSIVE these days...


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

No responses???

Well, I figured out that my well pump is only 1/2HP... which by most accounts should not require more then 3000 watts at startup... So, I decided to go with a smallish generator... The one wound up buying is a Champion 4000 (supposedly 4000 watts peak, 3500 watts continuous... Found one at my local Tractor Supply store for $299. Cabela's sells this same generator for like $399...

The only problem now is... Looking at the cost of wiring, it's probably going to cost me darn near as much in wiring as I paid for this thing.

I've done some testing... I was able to start and/run my 1HP Air compressor with this generator... It bogged down and almost stalled the generator like 2 out of 10 tries but it never did completely stall the generator. Obviously the 1HP compressor motor is pushing the limits (possibly exceeding them). However, I pretty much new that 1HP wasn't really likely to work. I am very confident this generator will run my 1/2HP 240 well pump however, I haven't tested it yet, but plan to do so in the next few days.

This generator gets MANY good comments by RVers on the rv.net forums... they have entire threads with over 4000 posts about '3000 watt Chinese gensets'... the Champion is one of the most popular in that community it seems.

Here is a link that might be useful: Champion C46540 Generator


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Hi,

Wiring I think is best left to the professionals. You need eiher a (1) Transfer Switch or (b) an interlock kit. This will allow you to run stuff without having wires everywhere. This instalation will cost you maybe $US 1,000 or so dependent on the number of circuits.

As for generators, I would have recomended the Honda 7,000. This is expensive though at $US 2,200 or there abouts. It is 7,000 watts. The nice thing about it is that it uses power electronics. So the AC power it produces is very clean and good for electronics. It also allows the generator to run at optimum speeds and not 3,600 rpm like most other generators (you need 60 Hz, hence the 3,600 rpm).

I have a well and when the power went out for 5 days it was really bad. Pipes froze too. In the end we ended up with a Cummins Onan RS 20,000. Sort of expensive though.

All the best, Mike.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I've had my Powermate 2500 since Xmas '06, and have put nearly 50 hours on it. Got it off eBay for 170 + 50 S/H as a refurb. Unit arrived with a gas tank fitting leak, but that was solved with an O-ring out of the toolbox.

I did change the oil after the recommended 10 hours...it had a noticeable metallic sheen to it. After that, the oil problem went away. I suppose it was crud in there from manufacture and break in wear.

It's a great little generator. Decent output, starts easily and luggable by one man. Saw them over the weekend for $317 at Wally World and definitely think I got a good deal. Just remember to change the oil the first time.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I've got small horse shelters away from electricity, so Have 4 (3 850 watt and a 2500 watt)I'm in Germany so mine are 230 volt. One of the 850's would have been enough, but the local HD equivalent had them marked down from 99 euro to 49. Too good to pass up?? The only thing that sold me was there was two more and a 2500 watt one there with various broken parts (2 pull ropes and an engine mount)that he said cost more to send back than they were worth. Got the whole lot including the new one for 100 euro.
For what I need, they seem to be OK.

Pro's: noone wants to steal them so I can leave one hooked up at each building.
Con's: Throw them away when they quit, or wing it yourself.

Good Luck,
Think I'd get a bigger gas can and some earplugs and keep what you've got. If you want to give the chinese some money, take your family out for Chopsuey.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

You get just what you pay for and can get better for just a small amount more.Why would you want to trust there products.They try killing our kids with lead in painted toys.They tried posioning our pets with there dog and cat foods.Then they put razors in lollie pops.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

looking for a replacement on/off switch for my generator
it was bought a costco it is a nikota model #06044.. 3500 watt... 6.5 ohv . its red with a simple turn on/off switch.
on wire connects with anothr wire then the unit plugs into the generator itself. i have used the generator before and it had worked very well


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

So, lots of good information, including:
all these low cost generators have Chinese engines and Chinese generators. I don't want to go into all the many reasons I have, (many have been listed on this thread already...), but I don't want to buy Chinese products.
So, what companies are making generators in the 5KW to 10KW class in the good ole USA? (or at least a friendlier country, Canada, Mexico, Japan, etc.....)
Thanks!


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

About a year ago I recieved a generator from someone who owed me money and couldn't pay me. It's a 7500 watt "Titan" diesel generator with 27 hours on it. I really haven't had to use it yet, I only crank it occasionally. I looked it up and it appears that it is Chinese, but the new ones I see are not cheap, they're over $5k. Anybody know anything about these Titan generators?


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Someone stated: "You get just what you pay for and can get better for just a small amount more.Why would you want to trust there products.They try killing our kids with lead in painted toys.They tried posioning our pets with there dog and cat foods.Then they put razors in lollie pops."

I second this opinion. China is attacking our internet sites, stealing our military and commercial information, and in general, means us no good over the long haul, i.e. after they are done sucking us dry as a consumer nation.

I discovered for not that much more, $1400, Generac makes an 8KW generator in Wisconsin, using an engine and generator made in the US. I am not so craven for a "good deal" that I can't or won't spend a few hundred more to have it well made, and well made in the USA. Don't be cheap and unpatriotic, don't buy Chinese generators!


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Just Thought I'd share some of my experiences - I originally bought a Coleman Powermate 6560 with the robin subaru engine on it. It did fine till it hit about 60 hours of use when the generator head endbell bearing went bad and wiped out the entire generator head during a storm (*iss poor engineering if you ask me). The generator was still within warranty (or so I believed) but the company in Nebraska had filed bankruptcy and had gone out of business.

Rather than loose ~300 bucks in groceries and all of my frozen elk/venison/pheasant/turkeys in the freezer I went to Home Depot in our neighboring town and bought a Homelite HG-5000 which 1) was all they had left and 2)I thought was an American brand...

Here it is on the web: http://www.homelite.com/catalog/generators/HG5022P

I got it out of the box, filled it with oil,gas,choked it and and it fired up first pull. I got to looking at it and discovered that not only was the whole thing was made in china by a company named Ducar, it was the same model they make for the chinese army. It uses a 389cc 13hp Honda GX390 Clone engine - it looks the same as the real thing except the stickers.

Check it out:

http://www.ducar.com.cn/cache/pro/20080515173627-60528.shtml

I tried to take it back and exchange it for something a little less communist, however Home Depot was adapting Red Army policies too because they have a zero return policy on generators once you buy one. So I'm stuck with it.

After that storm was over I went over the whole thing and made sure all the nuts and bolts were snug. I didn't over tighten anything, but quite a few were looser that what they should have been. Hopefully they used a torque wrench on the rod and main bearing bolts. I also adjusted the intake and exhaust valves to Honda Gx390 Specs.

74 Hours and 2 oil changes later it has (sadly) outlasted the American made equivalent. That's bittersweet as we used to be a country that made the best stuff. But that's another subject

With 5500 watts I am able to power my furnace, the fridge, a freezer, the basement sump, some lights and the TV. It goes about 9 hours on a tank.

The robin subaru engine that I have leftover from the dead powermate still runs like new so I may just replace the dead coleman head with a new (non coleman) gen head.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I have two cheapo China Clones , ran both for over 6 yrs no problems other than cheap recoil prawl gear and recoil springs , go figure. Only have them for back up got them both for under $200.00 . Both 2-stroke . I usually run my Honda and Yamaha 4-Strokes for Camp , the Chinese are borrowed frequently by my Son for his fishing excursions . If you need a cheap back up Gen Set and you are mechanically inclined the China Units are a no brainer , but don't rely on these for routine usage back in the sticks as your sole power supply ! Peace of Mind comes at a Substantially Higher Price lol .


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Here is a real shocker for you. Just check out the Communist North Korean website. It is listed as something like "http://www.korea-dpr.com/". The Commie North Koreans who hate America more than anyone, are making generators, power washers, cars, trucks, motorcycles, and many other products. I have seen their generators, and I'm sure they are sending them to Red China to sell to us. I wouldn't trust a commie North Korean generator anymore than I would trust a Red Chinese one. I'm sure many are the same ones, just different names and paint jobs. They also have bought the equipment from Japan and other countries to allow them to make these products. You can see the generators they make on that North Korean website. I'll pay more for a Japanese or American generator.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

  • Posted by exmar 6 SE Ohio (My Page) on
    Sat, Feb 19, 11 at 11:22

Word of Warning about Generators. I too was intrigued by the cheap price of the Chinese generators, however if I need it, it's for a multi-day outage during the spring ice storms we get here. So, wanted something reliable.

Decided to go with the Generac 3750 (or was it 3250, I forget), which claims to be American made. Ordered it from Amazon, came in, nice unit, starts easy, runs quiet, etc. etc. I posted an in-depth review at Amazon if anyone's interested.

Anyway, after some research and speaking directly to Generac, I discovered they are American made, EXCEPT for the engines on their "smaller" units which use a "market generic similar to the Honda engines." They wouldn't define "smaller" for me, beyond saying that I had one. That translates to a chinese clone.

I guess I'm satisfied with the unit, I'd have preferred a Honda genie, but that was more than 3 times what I paid for something to sit in the barn and be used every 2-3 years.

Guess, if something touts "Made in America" check the fine print. e.g. Some years back we bought a John Deere Farm tractor, 55 HP Diesel and Deere and American made are synonymous, right? This tractor was made in Germany??? Still a real Deere, but one wonders.

Ev


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I was wanting to know if you can tell me what kind of motor the King Craft has on it?


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

>Guess, if something touts "Made in America" check the fine print.

Yea check out the Harley Davidson Motorcycles which clearly state "Made in America"...they mean essembled here: Austrialian wheels, Japanese Carb, Engine is Korean Block etc!


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

im working on a friend's generator.a collapsed spring.may as well replace both springs.i cant believe how simple the task is.problem is .... i havent figured out where to bye parts.i would love a referral.my application is as follows- i have POWERWISE 3500.( JD3000/JF200 engine ).made by Jiangdong.apparently same as honda gx200,onan 2400...something like that.my jiangdong vin # application and model # are different than honda vin.do i create a ghost engine, to get honda parts on a jiangdong jf200 engine.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Since the origional subject kinda changed into quality and countries, I'll throw my two cents in.

Some Chinese products are excellent. Digital cameras, for example. I've bought four in the last five years and they've all worked fine.

Now Chinese flashlights, that is a whole other matter. I love flashlights for some reason, and I can't stop buying them. I have about 45 now, cheap to medium price. One out of the fifteen Chinese lights works properly. All the others are interminent when waved around in a normal manner. When new. None of my U.S. or other imported flashlight behave like this! I wonder if the springs are made of too thin wire. Can't tell, tried to stretch out a few of the springs. Even a $30 U.S. branded Chinese made flashlight did this. I can't be the only person who noticed this.

This last month I've purchased four belts. Three were Chinese made with names like Tommy Hillfiger. All three showed quality problems in the first month of use. One of the Tommy Hillfiger's stiching unraveled within ten days. Another belt seperated the leather from the buckle within three weeks. The fourth belt was a U.S. made product, but costs more at $40. My question is, why are the major brands selling us this stuff, and why are we buying it?
At size 34 my stomach can't be at fault. I blame the name brand folks who contract this out with an interest in profit over everything else.

So my opinion is that Chinese quality is neither all good or all bad, but differs in various areas.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

You are correct about the quality issue. It varies. My best ever portable drill, a Milwaukee, is made in China. Superb quality. On the other hand I have had some awful tools made in China.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Many people talk about Chinese products as if they were all manufactured by one company when they label all products from China as "junk". As mentioned already, the term "jap c rap" was widely used decades ago for the products coming out of Japan. Now Japanese made products are known for their generally high quality.

I want to make the point that the country of origin does not determine the quality of the product.

I also want to make the point that China did not attack us at Pearl Harbor, or anywhere for that matter.

China is an enigma of sorts because it has a capitalist economy and an authoritarian government - although I hear that some communistic policies are rapidly shrinking as the people see the virtues of a free market. (our government seems to be going the other way!)

I own a few gensets that were made in China. A couple of small 2 stroke generators sold by Harbor Freight that are copies of the Yamaha ET950. They always start and run when I need them. I frequently lend them out to friends if they lose power.

I also own one of the 3000 Watt gensets that use the Honda GX200 clone engine. I got mine at Costco, it is a Nikota Tools brand and was manufactured by Jiang Dong in China. I use it for backup power and to run my 220V air compressor and a small 220V welder since I don't have 220 power in my garage. It has 250+ hours on it, it was purchased in 2007 real cheap because of the non-existent 2006 hurricane season.

I also own a motorcycle made by Lifan in China. Lifan is the largest PRIVATELY OWNED motorcycle manufacturer in China. The bike is a knock off of a Honda CT-70 Trail Cub, except it has a 110cc engine and a 4 speed trans good for 50+ mph. It is street legal, and I use it for running errands around town. I bought it in 2007, it has about 2000 miles on it and has never given me any trouble. I use Harbor Freight engines made by Lifan (GX200 clones) in my mini bikes, go karts and as replacements for power equipment. The GX200 clones run reliably, they are quiet, have cast iron sleeves, full ball bearing supported cranks, and will last longer than the aluminum bore Briggs and Tec engines they are replacing.

I think it's a shame that we don't manufacture these things here in America anymore. Blame it on the unionized worker that thinks they are entitled to $50/hr and full benny's to screw products together on an assembly line.

And don't believe the myth that Chinese workers make pennies a day. The middle class is growing in leaps and bounds in China due to their economic growth. They are tossing their bicycles and scooters for Buicks. (they love Buicks!)

So if you want to bash products, bash the brand, not the country the product was made in. America has produced some pretty awful and embarrassing products in the past. Not everything that is built here is of high quality or best design.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I purchased a Power Pro Model 2000inv Inverter Generator in December 2007 sold by Wen Power at PepBoys. I used it extensively but about three months ago it stopped running. I took it apart recently and discovered that one of the two bearings for the overhead camshaft had done bad and took other parts of the camshaft with it. After reading all this I think I may be SOL but where do you get parts for this thing? Have researched everywhere trying to find parts to replace the whole camshaft. I have noted that the chinese do not appear to document much of anything and do not set up any way to get parts. HELP!


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Hmm, I purchased a 3kw electric start Chinese made generator about 5 years ago. I bought it as backup for a greenhouse I owned. I have since gotten rid of the green house but use the tiny generator to power my house in outages (which happen frequently in NYS). As stated, I pretty much power the whole house, sans the electric stove and Dryer. I regularly run two window AC units, refrigerator, freezer, furnace, well, lighting and two plasma TV's. Yes, I know that is crazy and impossible... however.. it does do it. I do start everything one at a time and if both ac unit the well and refrigerator cycle at the same time the generator practically jumps off the ground, but everything works just fine. That being said, I am looking for a wiring diagram of the thing... That will prove difficult... only draw back.. getting service.. sigh.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I am an Engineer by profession base on fuel generator only , I have many of clients which are under my mentainace shedule ,some Chinse potable gen set are good ie some are made of high quality standard while some are nothing to compare to them . when purchasing any seek specialist advice on the type of genset to recomend to you.
These mistake is taking place every day because of inglorant
1 When buying a gen set for a customer , you must find out
the tppe of applainces the customer is having ,that will determine his requirement.
2 Mentaince shedule , many people do not even know when to mentaince there engine or not.
3 Sort out for specailist ,trained for the job who can garrantee you the life of your generator


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Chinese generator to the rescue!

I live in central NJ and we just got hit with hurricane Irene. We had power throughout saturday night into sunday morning until about 8am when the winds blew over a tree in my development and knocked out the power. The Nikota generator I posted about earlier started on the first pull and powered our freezer, fridge, 42" plasma TV and lighting for about 8 hours until power was restored. (didn't even use a full tank of fuel) I loaned the Nikota genny out to a friend in nearby PA where the power is still out at the time of this posting.

All I can say is that being prepared for a storm is worth every penny. I usually use the generator to power a 220V air compressor and MIG welder because I don't have 220 in my garage, but it served well during this power outage.

All of the little Harbor Freight Chinese two strokes were also lent out to friends in need, and for the record, they will run a 1/6 HP utility pump with power to spare for some lighting and fans.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Chinese Generator 3000W 3568 Hours on it,run every day start first pull,do I need say more?

Here is a link that might be useful: Tool shed forum


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Costco is having a sale on a Portable Generator starting in a week or 2. It is a ETQ 7250/8250 for $650.00 The generator is manufactured in China. Has anyone had experience with this brand. Any thoughts would be appreciated.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Farbie, you asked about the ETQ Brand Gen sold at Costco, my brother has one and is really pleased with it. He has had it for a couple of years and has to use it for power outages up to 7 days. He swears by it and is easily maintained. We were just talking about them last week and he mentioned that they are going up in price at Amazon and you have to pay shipping (wow!!). He said to take a read at the user comments and you would be swayed to make a purchase of the ETQ. He did tell me that the Operation/Parts Manual was poorly printed, but he downloaded from the ETQ website and it is now super.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

I bought a Chinese Wen power 5500-watt generator (13-HP gasoline engine)from Pep Boys about 5 years ago for $350. It sat in the crate for 2 -3 years until I finally put oil and gas in it. Worked fine for a test run, and then later for our community theater who used it to set lights so their show could open on time (regular power was back by opening night) and it powered my house for 1 1/2 days when Irene knocked our commercial power. I had wired a few circuits to an emergency panel fed by a manual transfer switch, fed by the Wen. It powered up our heating, oil fired water heater, dishwasher, portable TV, coffee pot, toster, a few lamps, and three refrigeration units. It did its job very well, although our fancy microwave oven would not operate with the 62-Hz frequency the generator provided. An old, cheaper microwave did work, however, as did everything else. Picked up TV off the air. I maintain an antenna anyway just in case cable goes out. I buy American where possible (I always buy American cars) but I just cannot justify $1000 for a rarely-used generator. They say that peace comes with trade since you do not attack your trading partners. I hope so.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

the chinese made engines are made from the dies that honda sells to other companies. they have a proven track record, and even have their own class among small engine racing applications. i dont belive their is any reason for anyone to call them "junk" as you WILL NOT find any reviews on premium engines or generators that have not had problems or failures. GENERAC, which is a company that ONLY makes generators, now use clone engines. you will not walk into any home store, and find a snow thrower, pressure washer, or lawn mower with a honda or briggs and straton without ann insane price tag attached to it. might i also remind you, that with a labor cost of $95/hr these small engine mechanics charge you these days, is it worth it to fix a 10yr old honda when you can replace it with a new engine for the same money? lastly - there would not be a demand for these, which there obviously is, if the american companies were not trying to suck every last dollar out of the public. a company oversea's can reproduce and SHIP all there engines here for less than half what a honda cost - which i might also remind you - is made in china.. lastly ill bring up one more important point - the people that knock these are the people that dont own them. when you want a good review - ask the people that actally own one - not the people that want to belive their stuff is better just cause they spent more money.
if you have the money to spend, and its for something you need your life to depend on - then yes its probably a better idea to go with a honda. the actual motors are very similar, but honda does use better carbs, better qualtity tanks and will have metal lever and switches in place of the clone's plastic. - but prepared to spend. nobody is saying the clones are "better", but they are far from junk. if you have an old mower or snow thrower that you kept good care of, but the b&s or honda finally gave out, can you justify spending all that money to replace it? for the price of replacement honda these days you can buy a new 2 stage troy bilt thrower with a clone.


 o
Chinese Portable Generators

People require many facilities during different circumstances and situations. Power is an important source and without energy it is very difficult to conduct any business and today everything depends upon power; however, on account of acute power shortages, many times, people are in a position to depend upon alternative sources like generators and inverters. Especially in populated countries like India or China where more people are dependent on power, during the course of any power crisis, people depend upon the generators and inverters.

When it comes to inverters, they can be utilized for minimum number of hours since inverters supply power from the energy already stored in the batteries. On account of several difficulties as mentioned above, nowadays alternative power equipments including portable camping generator are used so that uninterrupted power supply can be made available at any point of time.

Here is a link that might be useful: Power Tools Shop


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

KCTYPHOON............You're WRONG.
"GENERAC, which is a company that ONLY makes generators, now use clone engines. you will not walk into any home store, and find a snow thrower, pressure washer, or lawn mower with a honda or briggs and straton without ann insane price tag attached to it."

After reading your post, I went to my shed to verify you are WRONG. I OWN A GENERAC 2100 PSI PRESSURE WASHER, I bought it about 8 years ago at Lowes and have used it several times a year since I bought it. Lend it to friends all the time, and it has at least 100 hours on it. It has a 3.75 Briggs and Stratton motor and cost me less than $175. I did quickly look on line and it does appear they have a different engine now and costs more...BUT...just so you know, Generak makes more than Generators. ;)


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

In furtherance of the Chinese making junk.......Briggs&Stratton and Generac (B&S owns them also) have generators coming in from China. I did real searches and contacts, and there are no American Made gas generators that are sold for the homeowner.


 o
RE: Chinese Portable Generators

Another way to look at this: maybe the Chinese are the suckers here, in that they are shipping us stuff that is often pretty high quality, for dirt cheap prices. Who benefits more?
Anyhow, the solution might be for us to stop buying everything Chinese, while they stop buying everything U. S. (let's see--agricultural products, luxury cars--Boeing airplanes--what else?)


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Tool Shed Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here