Return to the Tractors Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Opinions please between buying two tractors

Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
Tue, Apr 17, 12 at 15:40

My neighbor asked my opinion about these two models. They both come from Lowes and I have a negative opinion about big box mowers because I work on so many of them, but maybe I'm wrong about the tractors.

A JD140 with 22HP Briggs and a Cub Cadet 1050 with a 22HP Kohler.

It will be used for a multi-acre lot.

Thanks for any input.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

Tell your friend to buy the JD D140 from the local JD dealer. The price will be the same and the dealer will be doing the warranty work regardless of where it's purchased so why not make a friend?


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

Ditto with the CC ltx 1050 - dealer, not BBS. Same benefits.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

  • Posted by larso1 So. CO Zone 5 (My Page) on
    Tue, Apr 17, 12 at 19:11

Except that CC is consistently rated low relative to reliability. Say what you want about Consumer Reports (Consumer Distorts) I take the consumer feedback seriously, why would the consumer lie about their purchase experience?


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

The upper tier CC L&G products are markedly higher quality and uses better components than the entry level MTD made Cubs. Entry level Cubs don't fare well in reviews, Consumer Reports and in the field. Resale value of used entry level Cubs SUCK and used current models are often available on craigslist for CHEAP cause the owners get ticked off at them... especially when bought from the box store and there's no real Cub dealer around.

The entry level JD L&G stuff is backed by dealers with parts departments and trained techs. Resale and trade-in value is higher with a JD product and parts tend to be available for a very long time.


 o
RE: buying two tractors

The upper tier CC L&G products are markedly higher quality and uses better components than the entry level MTD made Cubs. Entry level Cubs don't fare well in reviews, Consumer Reports and in the field. Resale value of used entry level Cubs SUCK and used current models are often available on craigslist for CHEAP cause the owners get ticked off at them... especially when bought from the box store and there's no real Cub dealer around.

The entry level JD L&G stuff is backed by dealers with parts departments and trained techs. Resale and trade-in value is higher with a JD product and parts tend to be available for a very long time.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

once an antlerhead, always. We agree to disagree. Case closed.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

My Toro and my Kubota disagree and your close mindedness defines you.

Is name calling is the most substantive information you can post? Rather than yellow and gold envy defend your position and answer anything I posted with facts.

Do a national craigslist search and see how many current model and last years CC entry level riders are for sale for 1/2 to 1/3 of what they cost new.

For a long time CC was a great marque and put out a quality product but since MTD bought them and took over production of the 1xxx series the Cubs have taken a dive.

In the end it's all subjective opinion and... it's a matter of how much less you're willing to accept for your money.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

justalurker, are you saying that only the low-end Cub Cadets are made by MTD, and that somebody else makes the more expensive stuff? Where's the dividing line?


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

As far as I recall the 2xxx and up Cubs are still in keeping with the levels of quality and features that made Cub what it was. These models are available through Cub dealers.

If you have a local Cub dealer who has a good reputation they are worth investigating albeit for more money than the box store Cubs. If there's no local Cub dealer than the warranty is useless and you'll be waiting for every part you'll ever need to be delivered.

Check with rcbe and ask him if it's ok for you to look at the John Deere X300. About $3k and built on the garden tractor frame with a 4 year 300 hour warranty.


 o
opinions between buying two tractors

Sorry twelvegauge, thought you were the OP.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

I think that I would need to know a bit more on what engines they have. I have several Cub Cadet customers that beat the crap out of their 50" decks. They all pretty much have the Command twin, which I would take over the Briggs. Not a Courage mind you. The Cubs all use they same lightweight drive belt that is good for the first 4 years , then every 2 after that if that's all you replace. Hydros stay strong though. Deere is a LITTLE more refined , but better parts availability overall. 2 plus acres of rough country lawn gets to be a bit much for these, and after 7 years -its time for another. He said antlerhead.... :)


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

Hey Tom, you too?

Every 1000 Cub I've seen the last few years all had the Courage. Not in the same league as the Command. The latest 1000 series Cubs are just Troy-Bilts with the Cub color scheme. Pretty much cookie cutter MTDs in different flavors.

I've run across a few of the 1500 series around here that are 4-5 years old and they are like the old Cubs and much better than the newer stuff.

There's no real Cub dealer in the state so people who buy Cubs here are really screwed cause they're stuck with authorized independent repair shops and around here they all SUCK and don't stock parts. They let it be known that they really don't want to do warranty work.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

Check it out, jal

Here is a link that might be useful: CC ltx1050


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

Almost reminds me of the old cracked frame Craftsman discussions.

If I am not mistaken, the BBS Cub mower decks used to be held up with venitian blind hardware. Is that still the case?


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

Cub Cadet, Lowes Troy-Bilt, Sears. Look familiar in another color?

Case closed...


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

From what I see of the last several years the Cub 50" deck hasn't any issues. Unless they get washed. Nor with the frame or attachment. Seen a few w/ Courage, which the twin isn't too problematic really. The Cub manual at least gave you the right oil cap spec where the K manuals used to be wrong. There have been issues that they've addressed all along, so I guess not a deal breaker if the guy loves yellow. The D seems to be a warmed over L/LA series, which is an old design much like the Cub. Neither are uber mowers, but the budget allows what the budget allows. Deere really does offer better parts support. It's the odd things on MTD that can be problematic.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

Agreed. If there isn't a Cub dealer local to you then I'd pass, but as I said "If you have a local Cub dealer who has a good reputation they are worth investigating" and then the name calling started.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

" Posted by justalurker 10 (My Page) on
Wed, Apr 18, 12 at 11:20

Agreed. If there isn't a Cub dealer local to you then I'd pass, but as I said "If you have a local Cub dealer who has a good reputation they are worth investigating" and then the name calling started."

Ain't what was said at the start of this thread.... and you ain't been called no names by me - not yet.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

"once an antlerhead, always"


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

  • Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
    Wed, Apr 18, 12 at 19:35

Wow, I thought I might get a few opinions, but..........


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

I have looked at the tractors in the BB stores, and just like the rest of the equipment they sell, they are of a lower tier line. No matter the manufacturer. Those tractors are not much more than toys.

A weed whacker is one thing, but a tractor is another. I will always consult with the guys that sell to the pro's. Their equipment is almost always much better for a higher price of course. The value is much more.

My JD LX188 lawn tractor is still running and mowing great after 19 years of use.


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

So Baymee- you will have to report back on what the decision is. But, as far as lurker goes- he must have Deere antlers coupled w/ Toro horns 'cause he has that sweet Xi. Probably be a tough beast to butt heads with on the wrong day!


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

  • Posted by baymee LehighValleyPA (My Page) on
    Thu, Apr 19, 12 at 5:43

The answer is: He developed antlers!


 o
RE: Opinions please between buying two tractors

  • Posted by lkbum North Ga (My Page) on
    Thu, Apr 19, 12 at 8:32

On Big Box Stores..... On any Saturday or Sunday, you can see several 5 to 10 year olds using the tractors on display as a playground (Home Depot, Dawsonville Ga). I used to see it on occasion, it is now everytime I go into the store. The kids are unattended and having a ball, "shifting" gears, yanking on the throttles and chokes and basically having a great time doing what little boys do. This is always on the units inside the store, the others left out in the rain are usually not getting hammered.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Tractors Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here