Return to the Trees Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Posted by eahamel 9a (My Page) on
Tue, Jan 29, 13 at 20:14

I've lived in Live Oak Country all my life, and this is the first time I've ever, ever seen this. I hope these trees will be all right! I'll check them again in a few months to see if they've leafed out.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Let us know, it looks bad from here.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Ack! Someone call the Humane Society!


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

What state is this?


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

If he had a license, it would be taken away. But no one who does that has a license.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

"What state is this?"

State of ruin.

They have ceased to exist.
They hopped the twig.
They are ex oaks.

tj


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

They're not dead! They're pining!


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

I'm in Houston. I like the comments y'all are making, this is truly a travesty.

An apartment complex near me killed a magnificent old crape myrtle a few years ago by pruning it. It had never been pruned before, and was beautiful, even when not in bloom. Then someone cut it way back, the way they do, and it died. That's what we call Crape Murder.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

All kinds of bad in the photo. Most people believe they know all there is to know about trees, and don't have a freaking clue. Saw some do this same thing to about a 24" dia beautiful Sugar Maple a few years ago, only they cut every limb over about 6". Of course it died. I'm sure they did it thinking they would make it less likely to fall over. Thing is, that was 4 years ago, and the rotting remains still stand and are far far far more likely to fall, than the healthy Sugar Maple they killed. Saw someone cut every branch off an 80'+ pine (leaving only the trunk), and then obviously couldn't understand why it didn't re-sprout. Stupid stuff like that, and "topping" have been rampant since ice storms in 2000, and 2009.

Arktrees


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

I've never seen live oaks without leaves (except when they were deceased). What a horrible way to treat those trees.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

eahamel, maybe you should send that picture to the Houston paper and question the city's knowledge of dealing with their resources.


 o
I found a pic...

of the door to door landscape architect who worked on the oaks. He looks a little shady to me...

Image Hosted by ImageShack.us


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Wow. That looks pretty bad.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Don't know for sure, but they look to be on private property. One would hope there is an ordinance against such treatment but oftentimes there is not, and Billy Ray and his pickup can hack at will.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

I hope that Rhizo will lend her expertise to this discussion. Hopefully she will send the posted picture to an arborist friend who is a live oak specialist for his imput on the subject. I also reside in live oak country and have never seen one pollarded in this manner. Updates on these trees through the next few growing years would be deeply appreciated. This is how we learn.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

WxDano, yes, this is private property, at an apartment complex. The Parks Department does pay attention to the Urban Forest, though, maybe I should send them this pic.

I'll go past the complex again tomorrow, and note the address, so I can keep track of the poor trees. It's on the edge of my neighborhood, and I don't think I've ever been on that street before.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

They will be back. Live oaks can take a lot of abuse. More than most. The wrong person was able to make that decision which is a shame.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

I noticed a few live oaks several days ago that were pruned into the shape of cylinders. I didn't even know that was possible.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

@eahamel, I'm sure the City Forester would appreciate the pic, and maybe a screen shot of Google maps if you can't get out there for an address.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

http://swamplot.com/mysterious-oak-beheadings-at-the-yale-and-610-burger-king/2012-03-05/

Hmm. Looks even worse at another location in Houston, not far from where I was born and raised.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Oh that is just criminal! Tree lovers in Houston need to publicize these atrocities far and wide. Whoever was hired to do these (wonder if it was the same "arborist"?) needs to be exposed so that no one else hires them!

Here is a link that might be useful: Lou's link


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

All it takes is 3-4-5 e-mails from citizens with pictures for action. It shouldn't be hard for the City Forester to act. Even in Texas there is some police power to compel action or to desist. Even two people asking a friend each should be enuf in most places.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Good grief Lou, that is just brutal! They look like uncarved totem poles.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Often businesses HATE having trees around their businesses. They are of the opinion that is prevents customers from finding them. Have seen many times a new development on in, with lots of landscaping as required local municipality, only to be deliberately neglected in an effort to remove "the problem". Have also seen businesses have trees removed a few years after construction when they believe nobody will notice.

I want to be clear, this is not true of everybody, but I know for a fact this kind of thing is all too common. Sadly, governments etc are reactionary in these circumstance, and the damage is already done effectively permanently.

Arktrees


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

It looks bizzare but I'm going to guess this was the other option. Cutting the trees down completely was probably either too expensive, required a permit, or would cause complaints (no more shade on the building).

The complex doesn't look like it throws a ton of money into landscaping, either tenants were complaining about leaves and acorns or an insurance company insisted the trees were too threatening. Businesses don't spend hundreds on tree trimming like this because they want to do what's best for the trees.

If you want to get worked up about something I would look at the acres of treeless parking lots baking in the sun and the hundreds of miles of treeless road medians and empty lots that do nothing more than require endless lawn mowing.

Those trees were there for a couple decades, provided for countless birds, squirrels and bugs and are still there now.... once they recover. If you want to cause a big stir, change laws, impose fines, that's your call. I think the only thing that will accomplish is less businesses planting trees bigger than a crape myrtle.

Just my opinion :)


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Another Burger King! The franchise owner must have hired a landscaping company to do that a multiple locations.

Here is a link that might be useful: More trees butchered


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

This might be what they're aiming to get eventually. I took this picture in Ajijic, Mexico, near Guadalajara. I thought this ficus trim was hilarious. Since then, I've been seeing TREES like oaks pruned to look like this, here in Houston. Maybe they have to cut all branches off and let new twigs grow and then prune them into a cube or cylinder? I used to have a yardman from Mexico, and I had to stop him when he tried to prune a shrub like that. He didn't understand why I didn't want him to do it that way.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Is that a 'box'wood, eahamel? ;)


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

private property. One would hope there is an ordinance against such treatment but oftentimes there is not

==>> do you have any understanding of what PRIVATE property is ...

and what in the world should the city be able to do about it.. they are more likely to dig them out.. and replace them with pear trees .. lol ...

crimminey.. i abhor what was done to these trees.. but government is NOT the solution to every stupid act by a third party ...

ken


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

  • Posted by jqpublic 7b/8a Wake County NC (My Page) on
    Thu, Jan 31, 13 at 19:18

RIP


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

do you have any understanding of what PRIVATE property is ...i abhor what was done to these trees.. but government is NOT the solution to every stupid act by a third party ...

I have a good legal and practical understanding of private property as it is part of what I do for a living, and why I noticed where the trees were located.

Nevertheless, my understanding of private property has nothing to do with whether this municipality has an ordinance or statute on record that prevents such treatment, or restricts private tree care operations to licensed contractors.

There are good reasons why places choose to regulate some or all aspects of trees and tree care on private property. Folks can complain about it all they want - and do.

I would have e-mailed a pic and a few sentences of disappointment to the City Forester by now regardless.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

Those trees used to shade that complex, and I'm sure the tenants appreciated it during the summer. They'll probably have tufts of twigs at the ends of those stumpy branches for a long time now. That will be interesting to see!!

How do I find the City Forester? I know Texas Parks & Wildlife used to have an Urban Forester, I heard him give a talk about the urban forest once, but have no idea how to get in touch with him, there's no link on the TPW website. A search for "urban forester houston" yields a landscaping company.

Way to go, Ken. private means private, even if what they do is butchery. God forbid, they should cut them out and replace them with Bradford pears, though!

I found a city ordinance that regulates the planting of street trees, but I think these are a bit too far back to be street trees. And I learned that the city of Houston requires each new house to have one street tree in the front yard, and it can be a new tree or existing tree. Wow, I had no idea. I have noticed that the landscapers usually stick a small live oak in the yards of new houses, even if the yard is the size of a postage stamp. I can just imagine the damage to foundations and driveways when those trees get large. The tree canopy will be larger than the yards.

Very good, Ghost! Thanks!

This post was edited by eahamel on Thu, Jan 31, 13 at 20:30


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

BTW, the tree in this pic is a Ficus benjaminii. They grow there and will get ginormous. If I can find a pic I took of a mature one, I'll post it.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

The tree would've just needed limbed up in the future, why would they do THAT? I would imagine any future storms will rip off lots of weakly attached sprouts. They should've put them out of their misery instead of leaving poles. The Live oak is so grande and graceful naturally, and then someone does that, makes me sick.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

How do I find the City Forester?

The very first hit on The Googles for the search 'city of houston office of the city forester' gets you right there.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

The trees look ugly of course. Here in TN it is not unusual to see large trees treated like this on both private AND public property. After Hurricane Charlie in Florida many live oaks actually looked worse, no green at all and only main scaffold limbs left. Today you have to look close to see the damage.


 o
RE: Never seen pruned live oaks before!

WxD, thanks! I was just looking for "city forester" and couldn't find it.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Trees Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here