Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
notes_gw

Thin out a pear tree?

notes
10 years ago

Korean Sun Pear. Ornamental. Beautiful. Reddest red of any tree in town. It�s also the densest. Each branch from the trunk has tons of branches growing from it. Should I thin it out or leave it alone? I�d like to let some air get through it in case we have any strong winds, but I don�t want to hurt the tree. Thanks

Comments (7)

  • mikebotann
    10 years ago

    Pear trees take well to pruning. You can prune as much as you want to get what you want. They also make good espalier. Most I see are pruned as if they're an apple tree.
    You can prune them for fruit production or as a work of art, even as giant bonsai. (Niwaki?)
    Mike

  • ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
    10 years ago

    pruning does NOT hurt a tree ...

    i never heard of the air theory ... one would suspect that a tree knows more about growing itself.. rather than some guy with a saw ... its when we start 'improving' mother nature.. that she usually proves us wrong ...

    pix would sure get you more precise answers ..

    and it would help to know where you are.. and what level of strong winds you are talking about ...

    ken

  • notes
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    These were taken 2 years ago. ItâÂÂs even denser now.
    I canâÂÂt predict the weather, but we usually get a few 60mph blasts every spring/summer.

  • mikebotann
    9 years ago

    Those pears are delicious! Several of my friends grow them. I wish I had planted a few years ago. I still might, but my friends always have a lot of extra fruit. They say the rough skinned ones have the best flavor.
    They grow very well here in western Washington and Oregon state and don't seem to be bothered by pests.
    Mike

  • ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
    9 years ago

    i wouldnt prune it..relying on ma nature to take care of it ..

    i would work under the theory that the tree can take care of itself.. again ... its once we start thinking we can do it better than a tree.. is when we create problems ...

    thx for the pic ...

    ken

  • mikebotann
    9 years ago

    Yes, and when you start to prune it, you will be committed to pruning it several times a year. That's fine if you're an obsessive pruner and enjoy pruning very much. I'm with Ken, leave it alone and enjoy it as it is. I don't think the wind will blow it over unless it's growing on very thin topsoil over hardpan.
    I didn't know they had such good Fall color. Nice picture!
    Mike

  • brandon7 TN_zone7
    9 years ago

    There are plenty of good reasons to prune a tree. Pruning can significantly influence aesthetics (make the tree look good), it can keep limbs out of your way when you mow (Ken thinks he does this better than "ma nature"), it can be used to deal with structural problems that "ma nature" made, and it can be used to improve fruit production (in various ways)...among other things. The one things that pruning is not good at is thinning a tree, for any significant period of time, to make it less prone to wind damage. What happens when you thin a tree is that the tree grows to compensate for what is removed. The growth tends to be towards the extremities of the canopy. After compensating growth, wind load (and the likelihood of wind throw) actually increases. In other words, the pruning may help for a brief period, but you and your tree may pay the price in the long run.

Sponsored
MAC Design + Build
Average rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars18 Reviews
Loudon County Full-Service Design/Build Firm & Kitchen Remodeler