Return to the Trees Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Tree Question

Posted by RyanStorm 5-7 (My Page) on
Sat, May 3, 14 at 3:13

Some Info:
I have multiple trees, but I have this one that I never liked, so I really never took care of it, but I noticed it dying a couple years ago, at least 1 of the 2 main trunks was. So, I cut down the one down about 1 year ago, because it was covered in bugs, and visibly going bad with lots of dead branches, there were divots all the way up from burrowing bugs. I still have the 1 tree, and I plan on cutting it down, along with some others.

The Point:
I didn't like that tree because over the last couple years it always grew little trees all around it and are all over the yard! It started awhile back, I don't know exactly, maybe when it was first starting to die, but I am not sure, I just know I want them all gone.

Question 1:
Do all trees grow "little trees" around their roots, or around the tree while alive? Or is it only when dying or cut down?

Question 2:
If answer is Yes they grow while alive, are there certain trees that "don't" grow little trees while alive and healthy?

Some More Info:
I ask because my back yard is filled with little trees, like all the time, and it is the most annoying thing a yard owner could ever put up with! You can't walk in bare feet because they have these little "roots" that poke up, and it makes parts of the lawn lame, especially at the base of the tree, the grass is thin! I cut them and kill them at will, but it is so bad, that my neighbor never cut theirs' and they now have a tree just as big as mine (so it has been going on for awhile), so not sure if that tree just does that, or if it started doing it because it was dying. As far as I am concerned they are a bigger pest than dandelions.

I really need assistance in preventing them little pests, if I cut my other tree down, or if I buy a new one, if it will do same thing.

This post was edited by RyanStorm on Sat, May 3, 14 at 3:16

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Tree Question

Big trees create unwanted saplings in various ways. Some, like the live oak, send up volunteers from feeder roots. Others, like the Chinese pistache, produce a fruit or berry, which birds scatter over the area. Then there are seed forming trees, like elms and hackberries, who let the wind do the dispersal. The worst thing you can do is mow over or cut these saplings, whatever their origin. They will just spring back stronger than ever, from the roots. I have to contend with "volunteers" from each of the species I just mentioned. Where feasible, I just hit them with a little squirt of Roundup, taking care not to get any on surrounding plants. Others, I grab at the base, with heavy pliers, and pull up.

What you really need to do is decide what tree you want, and research its propensities.

RE: Tree Question

the first thing you need do.. IMHO ... is ID the tree... and then get rid of it.. IDing it.. only to insure you dont buy another ...

post a pic of the whole... a leaf.. and a flower if any.. if we cant ID it... the name that plant peeps will ...

killing carp trees is good for the environment ... IMHO ... especially if you replace it with a quality tree for your locale... wherever that may be ...

never knew anyone who covered two zones in one garden ...

good luck


RE: Tree Question

Well my city, West Valley, says Zone 7, and the two main zips say either 5 or 7. Based on the zip, I am a 5, but most places I read just said 7. Were talking the difference of less than 1 mile.

I will go ID the tree. I also have a list I am compiling on trees to buy, and researching what I can get, and the type I want, maintenance is an issue if I am getting tons of little trees. I want two feature trees.

I got a split entry home facing west, with sets of windows on left and right side, and I want big spreading trees covering those windows. Plus to the one side, I want a row of some kind of bushes/trees to build a wall, because I got these two very very tall trees and a huge bush, and the two trees suck, one fell on my neighboors house, and the other still stands. The bush ain't bad, but I live on a curve at top of a hill, so it blocks drivers views.

I was looking at getting a set of maple trees or mixed with something else for the two feature trees in front. Then going to do assorted other things in front garden beds, and back yard. Where the tree I am going to cut down, either putting up a new storage shed, or a row of privacy bushes/trees,

RE: Tree Question

> Question 1:
> Do all trees grow "little trees" around their roots, or
> around the tree while alive? Or is it only when dying or cut
> down?

Based on your description of how the little trees "mess up the lawn", it sounds like you are dealing with suckers (new shoots that grow off of an existing root system), not seedlings (new trees that grow from seed from a mature specimen). Most tree seedlings don't have the reserves necessary for continuous regeneration if they get mowed down regularly, but suckers do. So, based on what you are likely actually dealing with (suckers), no, many trees do not regularly produce them.

RE: Tree Question

This is good to know. I want simple front yard and exotic backyard.

I think the name of the tree is called a "quaky". Mine aren't tall like ones in wild, but they definitely look like the ones online trunk and leaf, and it is what my Dad told me they are. All pictures online show quaky's being hundreds of them by each other. Which is what my back yard would look like if I didn't mow.

RE: Tree Question

Ah, that clears it up a lot. Quaking Aspen, Populus tremuloides, is a notorious suckering tree which, in nature, tends to form large colonies of itself. Essentially, very large area of trees is actually one "organism", all connected by roots. In fact, some of them are thought to be among the oldest continuously living organisms on Earth.

Here is a link that might be useful: Quaking Aspen article on Wikipedia (complete with a photo I took)

RE: Tree Question

I wouldn't mind my own "quaky" forest, but I want a grassy backyard. I think I figured it out, that tree is just a problem child, and others have their problems, if I pick the right tree, I won't have to deal with certain problems. I think I have put up with the worst of what is out there, falling big trees, spreading roots, cracking cement, vines getting in siding, and just terrible placement.

I read my Willow is a problem because they tip, but it has actually been hit by lightning, and fallen twice, so technically the branch going straight up, is actually like its left arm! But last summer I put a ton of dirt around it surrounded by huge rocks to make a tree ring, to hide all the old roots that stuck up above ground and all the ones that were raised when it fell. So now she is firmly held to the ground.

If you know any tree that fits this description, that would be awesome:

-Planted on west side of house to cover left and right side windows
-Can plant in next 2 weeks (or later in time)
-Large Shading tree for house, and not so much grass.
-Going to have about 10 feet in every direction to cement.
-Low Maintenance (doesn't drop anything except leaves)
-Doesn't attract bugs, or easily managed
-Looks good
-Won't fall down with solid roots
-Fits my 5-7 zones, basically Salt Lake

My list of "not to gets" that I don't think fit my needs for my two feature trees:
Honey Locust
Mountain Ceder

My List of potentials so far:
River Birch
Sugar Maple
Red Maple
Silver Maple

RE: Tree Question

The silver maple is an under appreciated / over planted fellow. They grow fast here but come apart fairly quickly. I miss the one that was out in my front yard but with its rotting trunk and falling branches over my neighbor's driveway it was time.

For red maple, get a named cultivar.

Sugar maple is more natural looking than the acer rubrum clones imo. How large do they get in your microclimate?

RE: Tree Question

Big Tooth Maple is native to Utah. That is the one you should plant. Leaf color can be gorgeous in the fall.

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Trees Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here