Return to the Trees Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Posted by ashratnam none (My Page) on
Fri, May 10, 13 at 12:20

Greetings everyone!
I've planted this Cassia fistula in our courtyard in the hope that it would grow and provide a neat canopy after attaining a height of around 10-12 feet. The trouble is the tree just isn't growing. I planted it some 2 years ago, and it's still pretty much just as tall and has lost most of its leaves. The ones that do sprout shrivel up, stay small and die in a matter of days. The stem has remained green, and there's no real attainment of height or girth to speak of.
The courtyard is pretty meagre as far as sun exposure goes, the neighbours have constructed a 3 storey house which means it only gets around 5 hours of sun a day. I thought it was a dearth of sunlight which was leaving the tree so puny, so I even made a sunlight reflector to see that it got an extra 3 hours a day. It just doesn't seem to be responding.
And if anyone's curious about the tree guard, it's to protect it from monkeys.
Please provide some suggestions. I really wanted this tree to thrive and have a lush canopy, it's just not happening.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Here's a closer view of the stem. Note how small and unhealthy the new leaflets look. This is by and large as big as they get. They shrivel up and then dry out in a few days.


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Here's a picture of the reflector I had made in action. It adds an extra 2 hours of sun exposure, but really nothing seems to be working. I've tried everything!!!


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

listen Archimedes.. get rid of the reflector.. odds are you are cooking it ...

i think part of your problem.. is your need for instant gratification with a tree ... they grow.. the way they grow.. you cant change its inherent need for sunlight.. if it requires such ...

monkeys. ... ???? .. sorry.. thats outside my experience ...

you say you have tried everything ... perhaps you need to find a plant that can thrive.. in the amount of light that is there ...

another issue might be the lack of humidity .. due to the tiled floor and the little exposed soil ... a water issue ...

ken

Here is a link that might be useful: archimedes' reflected sun ray of death


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Thanks for taking the time out to reply, Socrates.
I'd rather lean on scientific evidence rather than your vaunted tool of choice ('odds') when addressing this - mirrors neither change the wavelength nor the frequency of light, and unless they're concave or convex, which this one isn't, they don't concentrate the light they’re reflecting either, hence don't change the intensity of heat they can generate. So the only way the light from the mirror would 'cook' the tree is if normal sunlight could also cook the tree.
The second part of what's being touted as my problem, the need for 'instant gratification', is to me neither true, nor really a problem. I'm sure you noticed that the tree has been growing two years, which I've read (I do believe your profile advertises how you think 'research is knowledge...knowledge is power') is sufficient time for it to gain some height. My desire to see the tree grow is thereby hardly ‘instant’. And furthermore, I personally think that if everyone just followed the line of logic you’re declaring, namely that you should just allow a plant to grow where it's already growing where it clearly can according to it's nature, there'd be no gardening. Trying to get plants to grow beautifully in challenging circumstances isn't just part of the trial the hobby presents, it's the whole idea.
I appreciate the one sensible thing I could purge from the whole of your reply about the water issue, and have to tell you that the plant's watered regularly and is not being allowed to dry out. The tree is also known for its ability to survive dryness and heat well.
Lastly your link is just a google search on the word Archimedes. Now I’m sure it must have taken you a lot of application and effort to come up with that, and I know how thrilling discovering what Google's used for and how it's done would have been for you, but the world has moved on since.
There's also many other wonderful things you can do here on the internet (or, if I’m confusing you with new terms, the 'interweb', they mean one and the same thing btw - which is By The Way) Here's a link which is actually relevant which you might (or on second thought might not) like, about using reflected light.

This is a place where sensible people come to talk sense. If you want to come and just dish out, be ready to get some back.

Here is a link that might be useful: Not just a google search about 'reflected light'


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

  • Posted by jqpublic 7b/8a Wake County NC (My Page) on
    Sun, May 12, 13 at 3:41

Did Ken meet his match? Clear across the ocean in India, nonetheless?


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Anyone think this could be signs of a sulphur deficiency too? Apparently Indian soils are notorious for their low sulphur levels.

Here is a link that might be useful: An article on the sulphur deficient status of Indian soils


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Goody! I love horticultural mysteries! Lets begin solving (hopefully) this one with two questions:

1. Is there a nearby facility that does soil testing? This is the only way to answer your question about soil deficiencies.

2. What is the age of the 'tile' floor? How is it constructed? Tile on poured concrete? Answer to this question may give us a clue.


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Hi nandina! Thanks for taking interest in the problem, your enthusiasm’s invigorating.
I’ll try and see about the soil testing lab, but I am not too sure if one will be available or forthcoming. Garden soil testing is almost unheard of here, most of the testing done in government labs here is on agricultural soil, and bureaucracy being bureaucracy, I’ll most likely get some curt explanation about why they won’t do it. I’ll check though.
Secondly, the tree has been around for at least a year and a half longer than the tiles. I believe the tree was planted in either 2011 or 2010, and the tiles laid down sometime in 2012. What happened was they dug the soil up around 10 odd inches and then laid down a foundation of large rocks. This was topped off by smaller rocks, and finally stones. Then a concrete mix was made and poured onto the rock foundation, and the tiles were then laid down.
What do you think?
Thanks again.


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

stating the obvious here but i think... the top of the tree may be dead... i would try another if the budget allows....and i'm hoping the 5 hours is direct sunlight...


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Sounds like the compaction of the soil, followed by basically sealing it off from the air (think gas exchange) are the primary culprits. IMHO, your tree will never grow under those conditions. To me it's surprising it's still alive.

Arktrees


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

mmajicmann,
the top of the tree is definately not dead. As we speak it's in the process of sending out new shoots, here's pictures of the new ones. Sorry about the focus of picture, couldn't seem to get the camera to focus on the shoot in the front and not on the background. But the tree definately isn't dead.

This post was edited by ashratnam on Tue, May 14, 13 at 5:28


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Here's another shoot it's sending out, there's another one just budding out as well.


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

arktrees,
thanks for giving some thought to the problem. However I have to disagree with you, because there's a host of other trees we've planted nearby which are doing really well. Their soil to air contact area is much smaller than the cassia as well. I think this has got something to do with either a nutrient problem, water, or most likely IMHO light. The deal is, if it attains a height of around 10 feet, it'll have all the sunlight it wants. The shadows caused by the neighbouring construction work only impinge upto a height of 10 odd feet.


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

interesting... i wonder if from the plants 'point of view' the 'direct' sunlight is coming from the direction of the mirror...also ...i saw a recent 'this old house' episode where long term reflected light off a window actually warped a section of vinyl siding on a nearby chimney. tough dilemma!


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Do I understand that the second picture you posted shows me that the Cassia was planted before patio construction, all the rock work was piled on top of any spreading root growth and a square opening was left in the patio above the original soil line so the tree was not disturbed? If so, as mentioned above, your tree is fighting to to develop root growth in a compressed soil.

Also, you show examples of other plantings in the patio. Were those holes just left as open squares which you filled in with soil as each was planted?

You may in time experience a change in soil pH as new concrete leaches lime for many years which is harmful to plants.

Cassia is a fast grower which should be reaching for the sun. Frankly, I would end the guessing game. Two thoughts: Every time you water use a liquid fertilizer at 1/4 strength. Or, purchase a new Cassia and install with good draining soil so that the top of the root ball is level with the patio surface. Perhaps you can accomplish the same purpose by digging out the original tree. Worth a try.


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Right then, I'm going to start fertilising the tree heavily, and watering more often. The thing is, it's really trying to grow, there's shoots popping out but they just don't seem to have the staying life force. You're right, circumstances for the tree may be a tough, but it's really trying. Even today a new shoot burst out. All it needs to do is reach a height of 10 feet then it'll have all the sun it wants, all day long. Thanks for your input.


 o
RE: cassia fistula just won't grow! help

Hi everyone!
First off I’d like to thank you all for taking interest in my problem and as you can clearly see, whatever we’ve been trying (the mirror, watering twice a day, using garden vegetable fertiliser) has been working. The tree has thrown up a whole host of shootlets and seems to be doing better. I’ve been watering twice a day, and been pretty liberal with the fertiliser.

 photo DSC02699_zps0377434b.jpg

What I’d like your opinions on is whether it would be a wise decision to prune the branches which are beginning to form at the sides so the main stem can grow faster and stronger? The main stem (which I was looking to keep) is marked with a RED arrow, and I’ve marked some of the accessory branches (which mind you are looking very healthy and have some pretty big leaves) in BLUE.

 photo DSC02702_zpse78af479.jpg

 photo DSC02701_zps1ccc66f7.jpg

 photo DSC02700_zps70d8dde2.jpg

 photo DSC02698_zps0a0930de.jpg

Is it too early to start pruning yet? And will chopping off that much foliage hamper the plant’s ability to synthesise food?
Thanks again
This really is a wonderful online community


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Trees Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here