Because obviously it isn't dead.

On what planet is that tree dead?

What made your husband and neighbor think it was dead?

most likely.. a lack of faith.. dont you think.. apostle???

ken

This time of year, southern magnolias shed their old leaves as the new growth gets started. It's pretty common for people to think that this indicates some sort of problem, but it's totally normal.

Magnolias shed leaves almost all year long, but if I remember correctly, they have a heavy 'shedding season' in early summer.

I used to collect the leaves for flower arrangements and wreaths.

Yes, normal, heavy shedding in May and early June (here) for Southern Magnolias (not true for northern/deciduous species which shed in Fall), but they never can be said to look "dead" as the shedding occurs simultaneous with rapid, new growth. So, yes, there is a late Spring clean up needed--rest of the year, virtually none needed though. Which basically means (because I grow both Northern and Southern species), I need to do clean up all year long.

Thank all of you I knew my tree was not dead but live and declare Gods glory through its beautiful fragrant flowers. I will learn more about her in order to provide good care.