Return to the Trees Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Posted by poaky1 6 Pa (My Page) on
Tue, Jun 17, 14 at 20:43

I know of Compton's oak, Q. Virginiana X Q. Lyrata. Any other Virginiana hybrids? Any other non-shrubby oaks that get low and wide? Likely no, right? I know about all the Live oaks. I suppose Q. Alba is the most like Q. Virginiana in zone 6. Well, I guess if it existed it can be found on the web. Anyone have experience with Bebbs oak? How about Cherrybark oak? Not like Virginiana, but anyone have either one, and do you like them?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Q. alba and virginiana are not prominently described as compatible but probably are though flowering may be offset enough that it would require human intervention? If virginiana x macrocarpa works and alba x macrocarpa works....

I know of one Bebb's Oak...it's 115 years old at the Dominion Arboretum in Ottawa, Canada. It's the biggest tree there.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

I wonder if Q. Virginiana X Q. Macrocarpa hybrid trees would be tall like the Burr or short and wide like Virginiana? Yes that would be a 50/50 chance. I am glad you answered Smivies, I wasn't aware of the Live/Burr hybrid. I probably read it in the past, but lack of a seedling source, made me forget. I should just be happy with the Compton's. I wish I could see a Compton's (mature) in person. I have 3 about 6 ft Compton's in my yard. Well, If anyone knows a Burr X Virginiana Hybrid seedling source, I would like to try one at least.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Burlive Oak ECOS!

It's macrocarpa x turbinella (likely that from the description). Maybe not exactly what you're looking for?


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

I think it's genetically possible. I think, technically, just about any two "white" oaks and any two "red" oaks can hybridize from a genetic standpoint.

Not sure how the Cerris group (Sawtooth, etc) or ring-cupped (Q. myrsinifolia, Q. acuta, some other Evergreen Asian oaks) work. I'd assume they can cross only within their own groups.

When we haven't actually seen a particular hybrid, I believe it's due to the fact that wherever they grow in the same area their bloom times are just too far apart.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Hairmetal and anyone else reading this. I wonder if the pollen can stay in storage for the couple weeks or however the time amount in between is? All oaks bloom in spring right? As far as Oikos they are in Michigan, so southern oaks are likely not messed with, for lack of a better wording. Mossy oaks emailed me about my order, they can't gaurantee me a Comptons oak (or 4) being that they are in demand, and the seed hunting/starting is still not done, but they told me that many of their lives and Compton's "gave them problems". So of course I emailed back enquiring if they lost any to the cold winter, last winter. I begged for them to take the time to answer. Maybe the little lower trunk sprouts will do okay in the future after all. I am still planting hardier whips near them. Maybe my Compton's were okay and their's weren't because mine have some size to them. Sorry, I wish Dax was around Live oaks, he likes to try things with trees. I bet if he could get live oak pollen he would try some hybridizing. Hair, the Asian oaks that are evergreen, are they like out Live oaks in shape? I want an oak that takes after the Live oak almost exactly in shape and size, proportion. Maybe if I saw the Compton's up close in person, I would shut up and be happy. If I could talk with the guy at Mossy oaks that knows about the breeding, and will listen to my incestant questions, and take the time to listen, and answer me. Well, I'll try and post that question about Alba X Virginiana to them now.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

I sent the email to Mossy oaks about Alba X Virginiana. So I will post the answer when I get one.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

I got the answer today, yes, it is possible and they have one 3 yr old seedling. They are hoping to get acorns from it in 4-6 yrs, not really quick, I know. Well, it's quick, but when you are impatient a bit, it's not . They found it in a pot where their live oak seedlings were. They don't pollinate their trees, they are natural hybrids. I have dibs on one if they get a bunch of them, or so they told the crazy lady who kept emailing with questions (me), they said the Compton's should take after Live Oak in shape, even more-so than Alba and Virginiana, that Overcup, when open grown gets twisted branches like live oak, more than Alba, they posted a pic of Compton's that showed the underneath of a mature Compton's. Hell, if my Late drops, live a few years and one bears seed in a couple years, I should go and try to pollinate some white oaks near me. But how do you know which acorns are hybrid, and which are not. I guess they look different. Some of the Albas are too tall to mess with. So, that's the answer to that, be patient, and they may have them in their catalog in 5-7 years, they said it could be sooner, but nothing for sure, that is about the Alba X Virginiana hybrid. They had mentioned one "late drop" L.O. named nugget that bore seed at age 3. If I can get one to live that long in my yard, though. I could cheat with protection, but they may get fungus on them.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Maybe the Compton's is enough like Virginiana

Here is a link that might be useful: Compton oak photo.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Could'nt resist posting this one either.

Here is a link that might be useful: Compton's oak.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

FWIW, my experience with compoton oaks (apparently seed from these type of trees so likely at least technically "F2" ---2'd generation crosses) is that these trees may vary in their characteristics with some mostly evergreen in our coastal oregon (USDA zone 9) winters and some partly to wholly deciduous---especially in a cooler than normal winter.. there is probably no guarantee that any crosses of deciduous white oaks (alba, lyrata, etc.) will be reliably evergreen---especially in marginal climates or colder winters even in milder areas. IOW, people potentially trying to get cold hardy "evergreen" trees thru these crosses may (or may not, LOL) achieve those goals.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Looking on Yahoo images, A red oak Q. Nigra Water oak, looks like Live oak< I thought the images were wrong, but there were a few that showed it to be Water oak zone 6, and looks like Live oak. They don't live as long about 60 -100 yrs tops, but I ordered one from Ebay anyway. The Mossy oak trees are sold out, I hope to get my Durand and 3 Compton's in fall, I took I off the list from 4 to 3 Compton's. Hairmetal, if you haven't already you need to order a Compton's, you need to order over a certain $ amount before they will ship to you, it is $20 ish maybe close to $30, it is before shipping, if you want and I still can, I can add another Compton's to my order and then you can pay me for the tree and shipping. I think the tree is $8 + check the site. If you want other trees and can spend the minimum with them, no need for me then. They used to have Magnolia Grandifolia, not the last I checked though.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Georgein oregon, I don't need an evergreen, it's the shape that is important. I have a couple live oaks who came back from the lower trunk. Maybe if they get bigger before next brutal winter, they will be okay. I will try to be happy with my Compton's and if the Alba X Virginiana hybrid is available later, I'll try one.


 o
RE: Does Q. Virginiana hybridize with Q. Alba?

Just want to add that georgein-----oregon, I know what you mean I have a Compton's that holds it's leaves most winters and the other 2 not so much. They are all young 4-5 yrs old, maybe when they have more mass to them they will hold some more?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Trees Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here