Return to the Trees Forum | Post a Follow-Up

shade tree in clay?

Posted by motocita 7a (My Page) on
Wed, Jul 30, 14 at 15:59

I live in zone 7a in Utah and I need to plant a tree for shade. The house has no permanent plantings yet, just my veggie garden. The tree will go in a southwest corner against the fence and hopefully shade a trampoline or sitting area under it. Our soil in this spot is clay. We have drip irrigation and sprinklers coming soon.

I would love a tree with these traits (in order of priority):

-does not drop anything spiky nor messy
-attractive to wildlife
-fast growing! we are in desperate need of shade!
-native/beneficial to the environment would be awesome
-underutilized species
-no/little pruning necessary
-fall color
-ok to walk over roots

Can you please give me some ideas of what trees I should consider? Temps are about 100 here now so I will probably keep it in a container until Fall and then plant it.

The Utah tree planting site recommends these:

I love the gingko trees but it seems like it's a slow grower? I'm confused because some sites say it has moderate or medium growth rate.

Any comments/advice, please chip in!

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: shade tree in clay?

not too many expectations.. eh??? ... lol ...

anything that is known to grow fast.. will just about.. rule out all your other wishes...

do not buy a 'fast growing tree' ... many trees.. grow just fast enough ...

and as to climbable... the kids outgrew everything i planted 14 years ago ... now they wont turn off their computers .. and go outside ...


RE: shade tree in clay?

Agree with Ken. Fast-growing also usually means weak-wooded, and prone to breaking apart in storms. Silver maple comes to mind as an example, but even that would take years before you can sit under it. It's native, but many people consider it one of the worst shade tress to choose. Doesn't have fall color to speak of either. I don't think you'll find a tree that you can plant now and sit under in the foreseeable future, or have your kids climb on before they outgrow that interest.

Gingko is beautiful (although not native), but if you get one, make sure it's male, or it will violate your wish no. 1 big time...

If I had room and need for more shade trees, I would plant a Yellowwood (Cladrastis kentuckea).

RE: shade tree in clay?

I've read that Ginkgo may take 2 or 3 years to sit there, adjusting to transplant, and then start growing at a moderate rate. I think somebody on here once posted of one growing about 18 inches/year, for whatever that anecdote is worth. So not fast growing.

As for spiky, be mindful of cultivars that may avoid the product - Rotundiloba in Sweetgum, some Honey Locust, etc... So even if a species does something, maybe there's a cultivar that does not.

I'd forget underused; you're trying for enough criteria that you can't be too picky.

What do you consider messy? If acorns are a big deal to you, that would write off the oaks, which is sad, since that might be a good option otherwise.

Forget anybody climbing it but the grandkids, if your kids are little now.

I don't know what prospers in your area. Some trees with a rep. for fast growth that I don't hear much about being weak wooded include red oak group, maybe red maple, tulip poplar, sycamore, dawn redwood, lacebark elm.

How dry is your soil? Any idea how alkaline? Are highs around 100 typical for you in summer?


RE: shade tree in clay?

Unfortunately, #1 contradicts #2 and 4. The best thing for wildlife would be a native that produces berries and is evergreen to provide shelter...berries can get messy. A seed grown/species native is more "earth friendly" because it might interbreed with neighborhood trees and broaden their gene pool.

A bit small, but what about
Washington hawthorn (Crataegus phaenopyrum)?

Common Hackberry (Celtis occidentalis)

Not native, but crab apple are good for climbing and wildlife like them.

RE: shade tree in clay?

Thanks everyone for your advice. I'm dropping all the requirements except for shade. And I would like either fall color or attractive to wildlife.

Richard, temps are 100ish all of July and some of June too. I'm not sure how alkaline, I just figured it was alkaline because it's clay.

A red maple sounds nice. From what I'm reading it seems that I can grow Autumn Blaze here. Grows moderately fast, tolerates clay, nice color, low maintenance and the size is right. For some reason they seem not to be liked on this forum. Maybe they are over used?

Also considering the tulip tree although I'm worried the size is too big for my space. The corner I have picked out is a triangle at the junction of the fences, measuring 12x12x12'. Bummer that the flowers don't come for 5-10 years. Also the weak wooded thing is a concern because we have high wind here sometimes. Any thoughts about this?

RE: shade tree in clay?

What suitable trees are naturally native to your area? That would be a good start. Unfortunately, I am not familiar with what trees are native to Utah.

RE: shade tree in clay?

Bur oak would be among my top contenders - and it's on the Utah list.
Very tolerant of soil type/pH and drought-resistant once established. Among the fastest-growing (2+ft/yr) - and longest-lived - oaks in my part of the world. Not much for fall color, but looks great the other 50 wks of the year; multi-season interest.
Produces 'sweet' low-tannin acorns that are relished by deer/squirrels/turkeys, etc.

RE: shade tree in clay?

Bur oak I think is too big for my space. I think esh_ga's suggestion to start with the natives is what I will do. I'll go back over that list I have, this time only looking for the *real* requirements: shade, spread, and not slow growing.

thanks everyone for the great suggestions, learning a lot here.

RE: shade tree in clay?

I've decided to go with Chitalpa. It's the perfect size for my yard, grows fast, clay tolerant, under utilized in Utah, and attracts birds and bees.

RE: shade tree in clay?

Sounds good!

RE: shade tree in clay?

What about Bigtooth Maple?

Acer grandidentatum. A Utah-native alternative to the eastern Sugar Maple - with the same fall color, higher tolerance to heat, drought, and high soil pH.

RE: shade tree in clay?


Is this maple like the others in that the roots won't allow any other growth? I have a veggie garden that is 20-25 feet away and I wouldn't want the maple to suck all the water away from those plants.

RE: shade tree in clay?

Somewhat, but probably not to the degree of, say a Silver Maple, but I can't say for sure.

They're not huge trees, so 25' away may be OK, especially if in a sunward direction.

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Trees Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here