Return to the Trees Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
American Hardwoods in Europe

Posted by greenthumbzdude (My Page) on
Mon, Jul 21, 14 at 21:44

I know redwoods and sequoias do well in most of europe....how about eastern american hardwoods like tulip poplar and white oak?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Tulip poplar is allright, there is a few around even where I live in western Sweden. They do freeze back a little some winters though. White oak should be even hardier, but I never saw one. They are not as ornamental I guess.

But the summers of western Europe is generally not warm enough for the eastern american trees to really thrive. That is probably most obvious in spring time, when american trees get green much later than trees from Europe and Asia.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

I've heard Black Cherry is actually invasive in parts of Europe.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Black cherry is somewhat invasive in Scania in southern Sweden and pobably even more so in mainland Europe where it is warmer. Red oak (quercus rubra) is invasive in Germany. But the worst invasive species is probably black locust (robinia pseudoacacia) wich is a real pest in Hungary, Romania and adjacent countries.

This post was edited by Huggorm on Tue, Jul 22, 14 at 6:42


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Liriodendron tulipifera aka Tulip tree thrives here. There's a huge one near me probably planted in the late 18th century.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

  • Posted by dbarron Z6/7 (Oklahoma) (My Page) on
    Tue, Jul 22, 14 at 12:50

I love the white oaks, but they're not a fast growing tree, so may be very slow growing in a cooler environment and thus less popular. I wonder, we sure don't grow very many landscape trees from the Continent over here either ?


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

We have got quite a lot of native oaks in Europe to, so I guess those are more common to grow.

Also, many european gardens are too small for oaktrees and the sun isn't as hot in eastern US so there is no need for shade trees.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Yes - I agree. Most of us just don't have the space for trees and shade is not much valued. Parks and public open spaces, however, have a huge variety of non-native trees. Few become problematical, in the UK at least.

This post was edited by floral_uk on Wed, Jul 23, 14 at 9:18


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

The only large European trees I see around here are Fagus sylvatica, which does OK although gets a bit worse for wear from the heat, and Acer platanoides, which is an invasive pest from here northwards.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

I think a well grown white oak is one of the best looking deciduous oaks, but they are rare (IMHO) even in their native range. People don't plant them in yards or municipal spaces because nurseries push the faster growing red oaks. In the woods, they develop as you would expect trees to develop w/competition of other trees. They really need a big oak space to spread their wings, so to speak.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Good point, David. White Oaks are common in the woods, fairly uncommon in landscapes - but the one exception being, if a house is on a wooded lot.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

"But the summers of western Europe is generally not warm enough for the eastern american trees to really thrive." Yes but they do grow, don't they? When I look at the Arboretum Wespelaar collections page, I find many classic trees of the southern USA like Taxodium, Nyssa sylvatica, Magnolia grandiflora, etc. The likely reason warm-climate trees are more adaptable to cool summer areas than cool-summer trees are adaptable to warm summer climates is that, during past ice ages, the North American glacial refugia experienced markedly cooler summers. The plants had to adopt to this and it is still in their genomes. OTOH, cool summer areas of the world: NZ, western Europe, Chile, etc., might have had even cooler summers, but they never had summers with our continuous high dewpoints and patterns of drought and heavy rain, which wreak havoc with root systems in particular.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Some trees are more sensitive than other though. You have to go quite far south in Europe to find thriving sweetgum or redbud.

But I think all eastern US trees would thrive in europe, if planted at the same latitude as they came from.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Red oak invasive in Germany? wow that pretty crazy.........how about American Chestnut...I head this one planted in parts of Northern Europe and has not shown signs of blight.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

There is no chestnut blight in Europe, as far as I know. I have got some american chestnut seedlings myself that I will try. I don't know what they think of cold summers yet, even if this particular summer probably is warm enough for them


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

I don't know much about some trees surviving in Europe which are from the Southeastern US, but the Southern Live oak, being zone 7 hardy, for some reason doesn't thrive in zone 7 Europe (UK especially), likely not enough hot sun. I would think that the oak that likes (or can take ) high ph soils Q. Meulenbergi ? Would do well in the UK. Quercus Robur and Cerris are seen very often across most of Europe, and Q. Libani has been made aware to me by Dax as common in Europe, even the drier places in Europe and IF I RECALL CORRECTLY in the mid east.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

'There is no chestnut blight in Europe, as far as I know'

I am afraid there is. It's been in continental Europe since the 1930's and arrived in the UK in 2011.

Regarding Liquidambar and Cercis - there are plenty in the UK. South as far as Huggorm in Sweden is concerned but not very far South in terms of all of Europe.

This is my nearest Liriodendron tulipifera, seen between a copper beech and a plane tree of similar vintage.

Here is a link that might be useful: Chestnut Blight

This post was edited by floral_uk on Sat, Jul 26, 14 at 6:51


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

I have heard that Osage Orange is making a pest of itself in Italy and Spain.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

I remember seeing "Tulip tree" in a book, mentioned that there are some large specimens in the UK, so they can do quite well there. They also feature coast redwoods, doing quite well, with pictures to show the trees. Red oak and Black Locust aren't trouble here, unless you have a large red oak or Black locust and you don't regularly take care of your trees under canopy, clearing weeds and other crap. Huggorm, we in Pa (northeastern US) get quite a bit of heat. I am interested in having many oak shade trees. And 2 Q. Albas are already in my yard. Q. Rubra and Q. Cerris are in my yard also, but I am aware that they are good in areas in northern Europe where the sun isn't as intense. Q. Alba is prevalent in an area close to me, where there is alot of shade, it loves full sun but could likely bfine in some areas in the UK or n. Europe.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Q. alba, IIRC, does fairly well in the PNW where summers are drier and cooler than in the native range, so it would make sense it would do OK in Europe.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

International Oaks,the publication of the International Oak Society, often has articles detailing the various arboreta in Europe and the numerous North American species - not just oaks - that are grown there; some do well, others struggle.

Here is a link that might be useful: International Oak Society


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

What about Magnolias...evergreen or deciduous species , from North America? How do they succeed in Europe?

Magnoliaphile here.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

There is a magnolia virginiana in Gothenburg botanical garden that is doing quite well, and several more in Denmark so it should be ok in most of europe. And magnolia acuminata is bone hardy, absolutely no problem with that one. Magnolia grandiflora is not as hardy but will do fine in most of western europe anyway. I think asian magnolias is more commonly planted though, even when it comes to straight species.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Magnolia grandiflora is very common. Often seen as a wall- trained tree on old houses.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

I just thought of something though. There are some places in Europe which may have calcerous soil, and white oak, Q. Alba (if I recall correctly) like slightly acidic soil. That may be the reason why Q. Alba isn't seen in some European places. I have 2 Q. Robur here and a baby Q. Cerris, so they must be able to cope here in slightly acid soil, and our trees need a lower PH, this is my guess. But if there are peat bogs there must be areas near these bogs that could support a tree that likes things acidic or neutral. These bogs must have affected areas nearby with rain run-off helping to buffer the high PH, unless I don't know what I';m talking about, which is likely. Another thing to mention to those in Europe unfamiliar with US summers. I can only speak about Pennsylvania, I suppose. Even though we are far up north kinda, it can be mostly 80 + F, sometimes 90 + F, which would be 27-33 C. Mostly in the 80's F, so high 20's C. I wish we had cool summers. I usually wait for it to be pretty cool out to do much work outside.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

This summer has been very hot in northen Europe, we have had several weeks with temperature hovering around 30 C with top notes over 34 C or 93 F. Some summers are cool here but other are not that cool. Too bad it has been drought to, I see large trees all over with brown or yellow leaves.


 o
RE: American Hardwoods in Europe

Geez Huggorm, I never would've guessed you would have 93 F in Sweeden. But I guess even the UK has sweltering summers sometimes and I always associated the UK as being cool, cloudy and wet. Even our Minnesota here in the US has hot summers sometimes despite having the coldest winters in the continental US. We're talking -30 F, maybe colder.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Trees Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here