Return to the Trees Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

Posted by mary_max Z 5 Utah (My Page) on
Tue, Nov 6, 07 at 22:47

I would love to winter sow some London Plane or Sycamore tree seeds. I collected two seed pods today and have tons of seeds. How sucessful do you think this will be? Is it pretty easy to start these trees from seed? Thanks so much.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

Yes, its easy, I just sprinkled some in this container then, (see the little seeds laying in the Sunny D jug)? After they sprouted I'd pot them up. And they grow fast, I'd have a 4 gallon pot ready for them after 2 years. If you have 2 seed-balls you have plenty. I'm not familiar with the Utah Sycamore, it could have different habits, though likely similar.
Will


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

Oh thanks for the encouraging words!! How cool and the picture was nice to see. Thank you. Do I cover the seeds? I plan to winter sow them later part of December, does that sound right?


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

You don't really need to soe the seeds till spring. If you notice the seed balls hang in the tree all winter then release the seeds in the early spring.
The sycamore makes an excelent long lived tree for erosion control.


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

i grew up in a late 1950's subdivision that had a sycamore in front of every house ....

setting aside my hatred of them .. lol ... in volume .. the FUZZ BALLS .... can lead to respiratory failure during the weeks they are falling off the trees.. and being shredded by cars and lawnmowers ....

in 35 years i have NEVER SEEN A SELF SOWN SEEDLING ... aka volunteer .. it might not be all that easy in zone 5 ....

so.. know your odds .. and .. good luck

ken


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

They are attractive trees, esp. from a distance. However, while I am not trying to rain on your parade, Ken makes a good point about the allergy causing aspects. A friend had an old Sycamore removed after a large limb fell - luckily into the garden rather than the roof, which other branches were over-hanging. Her allergies cleared up by better than 50% - the guy who took it down said it seems to be one of the more allergy causing trees around - not just the flowers, and the pollen from them in spring, and the seed pods in fall and winter and spring, but also the leaves have little hairs on them which constantly break off and are in the air. If you or anyone in your household are at all prone to hay fever or asthma or allergies in general, you might want to re-think growing it. Or else site the trees well away and down-wind from the area you do most of you outdoor recreation in, if such is possible.


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

I have also thought about starting some from seed. The main drawback is you never know what you're going to get in the long run. There are some trees around here that are huge and truly beautiful, and there are others with lots of top dieback that are eyesores. I'm not sure what cause the dieback, maybe drought or anthracnose.


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

Yes, winter sowing in December sounds good, so long as you don't ruin the seeds before that. Storage of the seeds in the mean-while is important, for ex. they can't be left in the house at room temperature, they'll dry out and die. I'd just store them outside until then.
Cover them up? I think what I did was just sprinkle them in the pot of mud then gently just swirl them around in the mud so most got dirty and covered up (requires getting the fingers dirty). Remember, you have hundreds of seeds not just a few. They don't really need protection. They must be very hardy as seeds because they came up like gangbusters. I'll insert a photo of an American Sycamore seedling that I don't think was even a year old, in fact it may have been one that I grew from a seed that Spring.
Sorry I didn't reply sooner, I am nursing a kidney stone, I had some of the worst pain of my life yesterday.
Will


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

Cold stratification is not required for seed germination of American Sycamore. Just sow the seeds a tad under some good draining soil no deeper than 1/4 of a inch and keep them moist but not wet, also in a warm sunny place 70F to 80F. If you keep a fan blowing on the pot it it will help with damping off fungus from killing them but make sure the soil does not dry out. After they grow a somewhat tough woody stem, put them in a chilly place that stays around 40 or 50F until spring.


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

My $70 book The Reference Manual of Woody Plant Propagation by Dirr and Heuser says this about Platanus occidentalis on the seeds: "While pregermination treatments are not required, there is evidence cold stratification improves germination."


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

For the eastern american species:

"Seedling Development- Pregermination treatments are not required (3). A large percentage of sound seeds usually germinate, but the great variation in number of sound seeds in a lot results in a wide range of germinative capacity.

Germination is epigeal and is affected by light. In tests made at temperatures ranging between 23 to 27 C (73 to 810 F), the mean germination under artificial light was 17.5 percent and only 3.1 percent in the dark (21). Seeds failed to germinate in the river-bottom soils of southern Illinois wherever litter was more than 2 inches deep. Sycamore seedlings must have direct light to survive; under favorable conditions they develop a strong, spreading root system and grow rapidly, as much as 91 to 122 cm (36 to 48 in) in height the first year. Roots also penetrate deeper in loess soil than in alluvial or clay soils."
http://www.na.fs.fed.us/pubs/silvics_manual/volume_2/platanus/occidentalis.htm


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

I want to thank all of you for this cool information! You folks sure know your stuff. Thanks a million!


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

On my land I have about 50 come up every year on their own from wind-blown seed. They come up in an open field and I end up mowing them over. I think most come from a giant 6-8 foot diameter sycamore on my north property line. I'm in zone 5/6. They are "pioneer" trees around here. Agree with shortleaf - just sprinkly the seeds in good soil - just barely covered and let them go. Don't make it overly complicated.

Also, I wouldn't do much watering other than what natually falls. I think more people kill trees (especially small ones) from overwatering than underwatering. The root system won't develop properly if given too much water.

John


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

I picked up a Sycamore seed ball from the National Zoo last
year. I spread about 20 seeds on a wet paper napkin and
placed it in a plastic bag. I checked on it every few
days. After 4-5 days, little roots started poping out
of some of about half of them. Easiest things I've ever
germinated.


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

Maybe a stupid question... but what do you get from London Plane seeds? They are hybrids... do you get unpredictable seedlings? Viable seeds that would continue future generations?

The oldest pre-"civilization" surviving trees in my city area are American Sycamores, I think they are pretty cool when huge


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

London Planetree, FWIW seems to breed fairly "true" from seed, unless there's another Platanus species nearby.

However, to be honest, all the Platanus species, but esp. American Sycamore, Platanus occidentalis and London Planetree, Platanus x acerifolia, look a LOT alike..

My question is: Does anthracnose, in years like this when it's bad, also hit seedlings?

I've heard conflicting info - one says that seedlings are generally less affected, because less vigorous shoots are less affected, but I've also heard they can be killed outright by it.


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

I've picked up dried seed balls from near my house. How does one open the balls to extract the seeds? Bashing with a rock results in squashing the seed ball.


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

Those who are speaking of Sycamore trees causing allergies are half-right. I have severe allergies to maple, elm, cedar, and cottonwood pollen, but not to sycamore. You are usually alergic to whatever you are around a lot. For example, Ken was alergic to Sycamore pollen because he grew up with them, but he may not have any reaction to oak or maple tree pollen.
I would not be afraid of Sycamore trees if I were you. They are a native American tree and one of the oldest genus' of tree in the world.
As far as growing them from seeds... You won't know until you try. That's what I am going to do. If I can grow my own, it beats paying $60 to $70 at a nursery for one tree. Good luck and happy planting.


 o
RE: Growing Syamore Trees from Seed

Interesting way to revive an old thread - post an incorrect statement. Sycamore is well-known as a highly allergenic tree.

Dan


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Trees Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here