21,401 Garden Web Discussions | Roses

Personally I think you should since you bought it directly from them. They should be held responsible for the quality of their products. As buyers, we allow them to continue the practice of using infected rootstock.
If I was not getting the recent rose as an exchange, I would not have purposely purchased it. But from walking a variety of rose fields, I see a lot of zigs and zags out there.

I agree with Seil, and I agree with Kippy. The virus is out there. It is ubiquitous. In my mild climate, it is not a death sentence for the rose (I have roses planted in 1987 which I KNOW to be virused, and which are still corking right along. I know of old plants of Ragged Robin rootstock, which are virused, and which are probably close to a century old. Doing fine.
Would I ask Austin (or any grower) for a refund?
Sure -- Why not?
I'm pretty sure a replacement PLANT would also be virused, no matter where you bought it. Still, it doesn't hurt to put them on notice that we are aware of the fact that they are selling defective merchandise.
Below, a bloom on our oldest (yes, virused) 'Sombreuil,Cl.' -- planted in 1987.
Jeri


Thank you, Henry, for helping us to understand the research and abstract. I like what you posted:
2) The microorganism must be isolated from a diseased organism and grown in pure culture." ... they comment about why they could not meet this postulate.
"3) The cultured microorganism should cause disease when introduced into a healthy organism." .... They were not successful with graft transmission tests.

Ah - Kathy, your photo so perfectly depicts the beautiful foliage of Ingrid (as well as her gorgeous blooms of course). I'm so bloom focused I don't normally notice foliage, but Ingrid's is just so perfect it's hard not to notice (in our Zone 9 of course, and not wanting to speak to any other zones).

Thank you! We are quite rainy at the moment, but I will look for spider mites when the rain is over.

I do not have a terrific camera and will try for a better picture when the rain passes- but hopefully you can see the dark area on the left leaf toward the tip.
These markings are only on the leaves at the bottom of the shrub. I had clipped the curled leaves before taking this picture, and will watch for any more to develop. Hopefully this is nothing-- I think I'm just antsy since it's my first David Austin!
Thank you again for any suggestions or advice.


If there is doubt as to whether a cane is dead, cut off a bit and examine the cross section. With live wood, you will see a thin ring of green inner bark.
If all the canes are dead, the plant is probably dead. If there is some live wood, the plant will probably grow out in time.
Mid March is optimal for zone 6 bare-roots, but late April is not so late that you should expect widespread failure.

I'm in zone 6 and I can never plant in March. The ground is still frozen. I usually can't plant until mid-April. And this year it's only just gotten warm enough the last week or so TO plant. I don't know where you are and there are a lot of different conditions that are all zone 6 but it's been very cold and very wet here this spring and everything is behind in growth. So I'd say it's no where near too late for planting.
Kate and Michael have good points about checking the canes. If they're green do what Kim suggests and they should be fine. And relax and be patient. 10 days is way too soon to be worrying. They need time to settle in and get some root growth going before you can expect to see much or any top growth.


I agree grass is a waste. You fertilize to make it grow then you cut it, then people spray chemicals to kill the weeds so the grass will grow more so you can cut it.
I am doing as much as I can. Because I am up in age, bad back I am doing what I can with the roses but most of mine will be fruit trees, ornamental bushes and hard scape. The roses do not like me but I am working my way through the list to see what will survive.
All you zone 5-6 people please continue to post and report what is surviving in our zone.

Yes, when the plants are smaller, the blooms will be smaller. (I notice, this spring, that our 5-Y-O "Old Town Novato" has never had such large blooms as it does this spring.)
They may get MUCH larger as they mature, they may have more fragrance, and probably more petals.
Frangrance is the MOST changeable thing -- altering with all sorts of changes in the plant's environment.
All in all, watching roses develop as the plants mature is a pretty interesting business. :-)
Jeri

Newly planted roses are prone to wilting. If the buds die I prune them off, otherwise I don't remove buds.
Austins can take years to establish, and in hot summer weather the blooms can fade quickly. As the plants become established the blooms last longer.




Preen products contain a pre-emergent herbicide. In layman's terms, it keeps seeds from germinating -- and that's how it keeps beds weed-free. It won't kill existing weeds but will keep new weed seeds from germinating. Keep in mind that it actually prevents ANY seed from germinating, so if you have beds with self-seeding annuals, you will keep those seeds from germinating as well. If the only annuals you grow are those you put in as plants (either purchased as such, or grown from seed in trays to be transplanted into the beds), then you're fine.
I don't think the products are necessarily bad, but I wouldn't use them because I like the idea of self-seeding annuals (they'll be the icing on the cake after I get the roses and perennials planted). If that's not an issue for you, then ignore my warning.
:-)
~Christopher


I have been growing this one for 3 years. I think mine came from Palestine the last year they were able to sell the Freelanders. IT was noticebly smaller in its first year, catching up a bit last year. I don't remember how big it is this year but its doing fine. It is not nearly as huge as some of the other Freelanders. The flowers are beautiful and fragrant.

For rabbits I make cylinders of hardware cloth or chickenwire. Measure out about 5 feet of hardware cloth or chicken wire, cut with wire cutters, then wire in 3 places to make a cylinder. Put around rose bush and use sticks or stakes to hold in place. the local nursery recommends burying it a few inches. For squirrels you might have to make some kind of lid. As I recall the square foot gardening guy (who was a retired engineer) recommended making some kind of cages to protect veggies.

Squirrels will reach through regular chicken wire (1" mesh) if it's something they really want, so you have to make cages/cylinders out of aviary wire (1/2" mesh). That really does work, I've used it for many containerized vegetable plants. Hardware cloth is usually 1/2" mesh, but it costs more unless you buy 100 foot rolls.






Well, if it's a hundred KOs planted in the median strip, the correct advice is clearly to remove symptomatic plants. If it's a particularly valuable plant, newly symptomatic, in a garden where it will be inspected very frequently, the correct advice is to try and save it. Then there would be tweeners.
The following was stated: "Well, if it's a hundred KOs planted in the median strip, the correct advice is clearly to remove symptomatic plants."
-----------------------------------------------
H.Kuska comment. For me the above is not "clearly" at all. I would recommend first checking if the city used a herbicide on the median strip.
If the investment is as large as a 100 KOs, one could send off a sample for a PCR test.
"Our prices are subject to change, but our current fee is $25 per sample for RRV testing."
Here is a link that might be useful: link for testing (scroll down)