21,402 Garden Web Discussions | Roses

Tammy -- Thanks for posting your photos and for the honest assessment of your previous order. The plants you've just received look good, and I'm glad you're pleased with them. I hope, though, that you notified Rose Petals Nursery of your dissatisfaction with the plants you received last year.
I've received one acceptable order from Rose Petals, but my second was very similar to your first order from them. I had an even worse experience with a large order I placed with another Florida-based supplier of OGRs (again, a repeat order). I'm baffled by vendors who ship plants (even to repeat customers) that one knows the vendors themselves would be horrified to receive, realizing they had squandered precious resources on woefully substandard plants -- PLUS the costs to have those plants shipped.
Let's hope that all of the few vendors remaining adopt and adhere to practices that will promote their continued existence.
This post was edited by windeaux on Fri, Apr 26, 13 at 21:58

Hi Windeaux, I did contact Rose Petals about my order last year, and requested either a replacement or refund for 6 of 8 roses (I think that was the number), and the nursery promptly appologized and issued a full refund for all of the plants...even the two I found acceptable.
I completely agree with you that consistancy is a must! Nobody wants to buy from a seller that sends beautiful plants one time, and the next barely viable plants. Like I said in regard to RPN, I've had one good, one bad experience, but the bad experience was corrected quickly, so that's why I decided to try them again. One thing they do is list the number of plants of any one variety that they have in stock. I tried to pick varieties that had a large number in stock, in hopes that they would chose one of the better looking ones to mail, and give the others more time to grow out.
That being said, I received two large orders this year from a vendor with an excellent reputation, and received barely rooted twigs for about 5 of my plants (literally about 2-3 inches tall and no branching) that promptly died a couple of days later. You just never know I guess, but there are certain nurseries that I have never received a bad plant from (High Country, Chamblees, ARE and Roses Unlimited pop to mind). I'm happy to accept a plant that is small, but is rooted well enough that I can put it in my greenhouse and baby it for awhile. We just have to trust the sellers to do the right thing, and correct it if there is an error or dissatisfaction. Of over 600 roses in my collection, virtually all of them were purchased online, and I've only complained twice, so you know it had to be bad!
Tammy

I added DP this year after seeing it (and smelling it) last year in a public garden. I ordered it from Witherspoon Rose Culture. Their prices are a bit steeper than most, but the bare root plant I received from them was superior -- one of the best I've seen in recent years. The same is true for the other two I ordered from Witherspoon -- Pope JP II and Cary Grant.

As others have said, Dolly isn't a non-stop bloomer but LORDY! When she comes out, she takes the stage! This bush is appropriately named.
Nice fragrance too. Her blooms took the heat impressively during last summer's non-stop inferno. I'd definitely recommend her.



Andrew,
Last fall we found a huge and ugly witches broom way out on a cane of my very large bush of R. x fortuniana. We cut it off fast and as low as we could.
So far, I don't see aberrant growth coming up from the roots. It may be something to do with the vigor of the bush itself.
Will this extend to roses grafted onto Fortuniana? I don't know, but it's worth a try if you can see the expression of the disease when it's limited to one or two nodes out on a cane.
Ann

Fortuniana is susceptible to it. It might increase your chances of the plant surviving because it is pretty hardy. I live in Tampa Bay so besides a few odds and ends, I graft everything on Fortunina.
I hope the plant does recover Ann! Best of luck with it.
Regards,
Andrew

If the NEW leaves are pale with ONLY the main veins dark green, it is iron deficiency.
These symptoms often occur early in the season and then clear up, because, for some reason, roses have trouble taking up iron from cold, wet soils. So there is no urgent need to do anything.
I wouldn't bother to buy an iron product. There is almost always plenty of iron in the soil. The problem is likely caused by a combination of pH above 6.8 and cold, wet soil. However, fertilizing with a soluble such as Miracle Gro for Roses or Miracid will supply available iron.
To reduce the recurrence of symptoms, check the pH and apply sulfur to get a pH of 6.0-6.5. It takes about a year to react fully on the soil..


Thanks everyone for your feedback. This is truly a post revived from the dead.
As an update, I did decide to plant (6) SIR's in the spot I noted in my earlier post. They are underplanted by Lavender. For the most part, I have been happy with the planting and the rose performance, but the blooms do struggle somewhat in the relfected heat. In cooler temps, they are certainly eye-catching. Disease resistance has been better than expected as well, but there is little to no fragrance. Overall, I'd rate it as good to above average as a rose.
I did lose one of the SIR's this year to an errant foot by a contractor last fall and the cold of this past winter. I have planted a very similiar variety called South Africa in its place to compare it directly under the same conditions to my SIR's. If South Africa tolerates the heat better and outperforms SIR, then I'll likely make a change.



Your description of White QE equates to my experience with this sport. I can affix the same description to at least a couple of other "white" sports of pink roses -- 'Augustine Guinoisseau' ('White La France') and 'White Gene Boerner'. (The jury is still out on 'Weisse Gruss an Aachen'.) The color tends to fade to white under the blinding mid-summer sunshine in my zone, but they all open pink, and usually remain a pale pink in the spring and fall.

It looks like the one which has grown at my sister's house for twenty years. When Santa Clarita heats up, the pink disappears and it's white (as is "Yellow Queen Elizabeth"). The pink you're seeing is normal for cooler, damper weather. Cook the devil out of it with lots of reflected, radiated and direct heat/sun and it will bleach out to pure white, just like the yellow sport does. Kim





At the beginning of the 2006 growing season, I switched from Banner Maxx to Honor Guard PPZ, both of which have the same formulation. In my experience, there is no difference between the two, except for a substantial difference in price. Even tho I spray only sporadically, I find that Honor Guard works very well for me. I still have almost 2/3 of my original bottle of concentrate left, so I don't know what has happened to the price during the intervening years.
I'm not familiar with Lesco Spectator. If the active ingredient is the same as that found in Banner Maxx, the effectiveness should be the essentially same.
Just googled Lesco Spectator & it has the same active ingredient as Banner Maxx so should work the same as windeaux says. I use a Fertilome fungicide that is a more dilute version of Banner Maxx & it does fine, just follow the directions. Also remember to mix in another type of fungicide, such as Mancozeb, from time to time to prevent resistance.