6,340 Garden Web Discussions | Growing from Seed



Well jeez. Of course plants take up water with their roots, Mother Nature doesn't grow in containers, and we have drip trays! What I was getting at is....in their native environment, plants are exposed to water from above ALL THE TIME. Top watering doesn't kill plants, we humans do :)

Good info from Trev - another transplanting is needed for those plants as they are very likely already getting root bound in those cells. And based on the info you posted about dates it would at least another month from now before you could safely transplants the tomatoes and another 6 weeks for the peppers - depending on the weather of course.
Otherwise they are looking good - just crowded.
Dave

Thank you for the feedback. I have never had seedlings this healthy before so this is a whole new learning curve for me lol. So I will likely pot up again either tomorrow or by mid week next week. Do you think Solo cups would be large enough to sustain them until transplant time or do I need to get something a little larger? I am trying to get them less crowded, work in progress :)
Also, I have a cold frame built. It is made of wood and has a glass screen door as the top. Is this something that could be reasonably used for my tomatoes to be placed in say about March 30 until I can transplant them into the garden? The only other time I used the cold frame was in 2012 when I had large seedlings, but that was an expectionally warm year for us and frost just wasn't a concern that year (just the hailstorms...). BTW, I would only put them in the cold frame once they have been hardened off adequately.
If this is not a good option, I can still keep them inside but the hours of lighting would probably have to be reduced to about 8-9 hours a day instead of 12 because I would have more flats to rotate under my lights. I only have 2 light sets that are 4' long, but placed together to be wide enough to cover the whole flat. I've never had this problem, which is why I don't have more lights. That will be something I invest in next year though lol.
About my planting dates: those were frost dates I was able to find. I did notice I planted my tomatoes on April 26 last year though. According to the NC planting guide issued by the NC agriculture people they say tomatoes and peppers can be planted between 4/15-5/10 in eastern NC which is where I live. The only problem with that is I know it covers a large area with greatly varying frost dates. So I am thinking now to plant my tomatoes after 4/20 and peppers after 5/1. I think just for fun though I am going to pick 2-4 varieties I don't mind possibly losing and plant them out in the garden by 4/1 just to see what happens. I don't mind experimenting a little :)
Once again, thank you for your advice and recommendations! I truly appreciate it.
Dawn - zone 7B or 8 not sure, in eastern NC

First, I wouldn't buy that mat. It is way over-priced and especially so for one that requires an additional thermostat for control. Second, yes you likely could accomplish the same thing as long as you have the time to closely monitor the soil temps and adjust accordingly. However that would require VERY close monitoring as the temps can rise into seed-killing zones within minutes, not hours, as the mat is responding to ambient air temps not soil temps.
Cool ambient air and the mat just keeps sending more and more heat into the soil as it tries to warm the surrounding air. And in warm ambient air conditions the mat just sits there doing nothing so the soil temps can fall into stopping germination zones just as quickly.
For those reasons a thermostat control is a great benefit to both you and the plants. Honestly, it can make all the difference in seed survival, germination rates, and germination times.
But there are much less expensive options available, some with built-in thermostats and some with much cheaper thermostats. Soil heating cables with a built in therm (auto set at 72) lightly tacked to a piece of foam or wood with the trays set on top of it can be had in many lengths for approx. $35-40 and last for years. Hydrofarm and Gro-Mat make several sizes of mats all of which can be very well controlled with a $30 thermostat. We use several of the Gro-Mats in the greenhouses https://www.greenhousemegastore.com/product/gro-mat/heat-mats-chambers
all of them controlled by this thermostat https://www.greenhousemegastore.com/product/thermostat-for-seedling-mat/heat-mats-chambers
and have for years with no issues. Using these has the advantage over the heating cables of being able to set higher temps for peppers and such.
Dave

Hi Trev,
I agree with what Dave said about the apparent over-pricing. There is one thing however that you probably need to understand better. The thermostat you referred to does not require 750 watts to operate :-) A thermostat is basically just an automatic switch that requires little or no wattage. The 750 watts, mentioned in the ad, means that the thermostat can safely control external devices that use up to 750 watts. The mat you referred to uses only 150 watts.
Hope this is helpful,
Art

My sowed pots are set under lights immediately (unless the seeds need darkness). I don't use domes, but plastic wrap my 4" containers. When I see germination, I may wait a day or two to get more plants up, but that is about as long as I wait. I have never had an issue with damping off doing it in this way. BUT, I also only water once after sowing the seeds and putting the plastic on, and the seedlings won't see water for some time!

You are right Dave pros don't use the plastic humidity lids. I've watched them at my favorite greenhouse. They either put them on a conveyer belt under a mister or they put them in a propagating chamber. Since we home gardeners have neither of those machines we use the plastic domes to retain the moisture needed for plants to germinate.
I find I get better germination with the lids. I leave my humidity lids on until most have germinated. It is only a day or 2 from the first sprout until most of them sprout. An extra day or 2 is not going to promote damp off if you don't make your soil too wet to begin with. This works for me but there are as many ways of doing things as there are gardeners so experiment and find the way that works best for you.

Sorry but once legginess develops it doesn't go away. The thin stretched stems remain. The only way to compensate for them once they develop is to transplant the plant deeply into a deeper container and bury all of the leggy exposed stem. This doesn't work for all plants but will help most. And the "fix" only works when adequate light is then provided.
Dave


Thanks Dave - you're absolutely correct - that's why I go by the temperature of the probe I have placed in the soil, not by the ambient temperature. That really gets at the heart of my question, too - I'm looking for something to keep my seedlings warm because they sit in a flood table and I can't keep seed mats directly beneath them.
The reason I have them in a flood table is so I can timer-water them, as I travel for work all week, every week. I also find more benefit and convenience to bottom-watering for sensitive herbs like oregano.
In my mind, that leaves me with two options - heat the air enough to heat the soil, or find some waterproof sort of heat mat that can keep the soil heated in a flood table. My tent contains both a thermostat for measuring the ambient air temperature and a soil probe with a thermostat on it, so I can always tell the temperature of each.
I'm hoping that the creative minds of this forum may have some ideas that might help.

I have (aquarium) thermometers at soil surface. Seeds are only lightly covered with soil. I keep lights on all 24 hrs. During germination I kept domes on the seed trays which were standing on a 1 inch thick plywood shelf, one shelf above the other with the lower light warming the shelf above. It worked great over the last 4 years.



In zone 5, probably not as your season usually isn't long enough. Normally perennials in your zone would be started much earlier indoors (January). But you might luck out if the weather cooperates so it is still well worth doing and give you even greater performance next year.

Hi Dave,
Since the problem started as soon as the plants emerged I think call rule out nutrients or root rot, heat however may be the problem. I've fed them since the primary leave emerged with Maxigro diluted according ti the directions. I'm not totally for certain yet but I think cutting back the duration of the lighting is making a difference. As always I will soon be putting a fan on them to help stimulate the stem resiliency.
Thanks very much for your help.

I too find it unusual for it to be lighting. Heat, maybe. Put your hand under the lights, are you feeling heat? Get some fans going to help with that. 8 hours is not very long to have lights on the plant, you should be aiming for more hours than that. Additionally, I checked out the link you provided. The system comes with T5 bulbs, which will run a little warmer than T8's but would no way burn seedlings. I really don't see a light problem causing your issues, I agree with digdirt2 above, either overwatering/drainage issues and/or fert issues. Maybe too much fertilizer is compounded by a wet medium. Any way to post a pic?

Yeah me too, getting Dixondale onions and leeks first week of April. We lost about 50% of the snow cover in the last few days.
I remember eggplants growing a lot faster than peppers, but Johnny's and other sources says 8-10 weeks before transplanting. Should I start them at the same time as the peppers? (maybe this weekend)

I will agree with most of the advice, but reinforce the caveat that any projection is just that and not anywhere close to a hard and fast rule. I live in Northwest Arkansas and so am a bit cooler than Tulsa but a bit warmer than most of Missouri. The entire central part of this country is so highly variable from week to week this time of year that averages just aren't all that useful. In 2011 I had tomatoes in the ground April 1 because March had been dry and very warm, I was glad I did because that summer was brutal and all that grew well was okra and eggplant even with drip irrigation. Last year I didn't put them in the ground until mid May and even that may have been too early, okra and eggplant never really produced all summer. I had watermelon that I planted as seed May 15 get going and then just stall late in the month as temps dropped at the END of May. This year I plan to use low tunnels with Agribon and plant out the end of April, but that plan is just a plan...might not even need it but might need to keep it on until Memorial Day...who knows.
So , do like the other suggest and play it by ear. Hope for the best but plan for the worst and staggered planting never hurt any home grower.

Planting Tomatoes mid May and Peppers end of May is a pretty good plan regardless of your exact last frost date, which is really a crapshoot. Peppers and Eggplants should not go out until nighttime temps are stable, staying above 55. Tomatoes are a little hardier. No way to predict the weather 8+ weeks in advance. End of May is pretty safe for most (in the average US weather conditions) Planting 2 weeks after last frost is a bare minimum that is sure to hurt heat loving plants.


I am pretty sure that eggplant sprout is a Brassica. Not sure how I could have gotten a brassica seed in the soil by accident. It must be a weed. :(
Eggplants sprouting today! 1 week, not too bad. I have them on a shelf over a radiator. No sign of life yet from the peppers.