Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

Posted by saood Saudi - 10b (My Page) on
Thu, Oct 17, 13 at 4:19

I know you all have been saying that cucumbers are not transplant friendly, but I still went ahead with indoor starting and had three seeds germinated in a 4" pot. One died earlier after showing its first true leaf (that I discussed in another thread the link of which is provided below). The other two also died in the same pot. These two however, fell over - their stem became weak and it fell to the ground. The pic is included.

I don't know why this happened. This all happened even before I had done any sort of effort to remove them from the soil for transplanting. They had about 2-3 hours of morning sun and then had around 12 hours of 6500K florescent CFL kept at a distance of 2-3 inches above them. Watering was also done when required.

What can I learn from it?

Here is a link that might be useful: Cucumber seedlings.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

That seedling got way too top-heavy if that's a 4" pot. It doesn't look like a dampening off issue.

Basically, a lack of direct quality light and keeping the indoor bulb 2-3" away rather than 1/2-1" away caused it to "stalk" tall and fall over. Technically, they're still healthy, but they need to be planted out if they're to be saved...they're most likely not going to "perk up" and start growing under artificial light at this point.

They do much better direct-sowed, though. Cukes...like most vining plants...aren't as good with strong upright growth early on compared to other plants without a quality light source. A lot of plants can deal with getting "leggy" and stalking, but cucumbers don't deal very well with it early in their growth.

Also, in your area you might want to look into "Armenian Cucumbers"/"Yard-Long Cucumbers"/"Snake Cucumbers" for the hotter parts of the year...which are really a type of melon...but can be used like a cucumber for everything but pickling (though some do pickle them). They deal extremely well with high heat and intense full sun.

This post was edited by nc-crn on Thu, Oct 17, 13 at 4:44


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

  • Posted by saood Saudi - 10b (My Page) on
    Thu, Oct 17, 13 at 6:58

Thanks NC-CRN

Yes, I got those Armenian cucumbers and have planted them. The seeds have germinated and are growing good under very close lights. I think the temperatures are reducing over here and I will quickly transplant those in bigger pots right away so that I dont need to transplant them when the root structure gets bigger and tangling.

Unfortunately for the cucumber seedling, I took it out of the pot thinking that it has died, so that I could check its root length. The stem is like 2 inches tall, but the root was not more than 3/4th inches. Is that normal for cucumbers?


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

The potting medium might be a problem. It looks fine-textured, almost dusty. Were you able to water properly....deeply......and did the containers drain swiftly?


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

I’ve heard that cucumbers don’t transplant very well myself. But I had the space and decided to give it a shot. I had Market More 76, Burpee Burpless, Diva, and Spacemaster. I started them in 4” pots about 3-4 weeks before the last frost. They did even better than the ones I direct sowed. I think this is partially due to the ones transplanted started to shade out the direct sowed. I was planting them about a foot apart and training them up a 6 foot trellis.

I grew mine in the Basement with only artificial light. 6500K 48” florescent bulbs. I had the lights only about ¼ inch from the tops, and left them on 16hrs a day.

It looks to me like your problem is coming from insufficient light. Florescent bulbs to tend to drop in lumens over time. If the bulbs are old I would replace them. But otherwise it seems like what you are doing should work very well.

Best of Luck!!


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

  • Posted by saood Saudi - 10b (My Page) on
    Fri, Oct 18, 13 at 8:01

Thanks Tool Geeks.

Its was good to to know that you grew them inside and then transplanted outside. Now I have at least one positive review about transplanting :)

How did you plant them inside. I mean how many seedlings were in one 4" pot. If it were more than one, how far spaced were they and what precautions one can take when transplanting small cucumber seedlings (or for that matter any other seedling) which are placed close together in one 4" small pot? Is it worth the risk to use all those seedlings ad place them in their individual containers or just thin out all keeping only the strongest?

Also, what could happen if there are 3 cucumber (or tomato or pepper) plants growing in one 5 gallon container and planted very close to each other?


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

Also, what could happen if there are 3 cucumber (or tomato or pepper) plants growing in one 5 gallon container and planted very close to each other?
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
They will compete for the limited space for roots and nutrients.
As a result they will produce much less fruits, smaller fruits and will become dwarf like plants.
Container growing is a more challenging task than growing in the ground.


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

For starting my seeds inside it depends a little bit upon what seeds I’m starting. For cucumbers I’ll put 2 seeds per pot, I have always had a very good germination rate with cucumbers, and I will thin the smaller of the two.

I have also started seeds cucumber seeds in 2” pots, when they each form at least one good true leaf I’ll dump the pot, pull them apart and pot them on into bigger containers.

Under the lights I’ll pack them really close, with the pots touching each other. This will works pretty good for me for about a month, then they start to get bigger and are competing with each other for the light, so I just move them a little farther apart. If the soil is warm enough outside and no expected frost I’ll just plant them out.

As far as precautions, it’s best to have everything ready before you start. Get your pots, soil, and tags all ready before starting so everything is in arms reach(probably not necessary, but it makes it more enjoyable for me). Then just be slow and gentle. Try to hold the top of plant by a leaf and give some support under the root ball. If you break leaf or a few small roots it’s not that big of an issue they will grow new ones. But if you break a stem or a large chunk of root you’re probably better off starting over. Also, the less you can transplant something the better. I’ve never encountered a plant that didn’t go through a little bit of shock when it was transplanted.

For containers, I’ve had mixed success. Tomatoes and cucumbers are large plants, and I have never experimented with growing more than one in a 5 gal pot. I don’t see why you couldn’t, it seems as though fertilizing and watering would need to happen more frequently.

I didn’t have much success with cucumbers in 5gal pots, grown outside. They really like constant moisture, and cool roots. I think the black pots I grew them in got too warm in the sun, and even though at some points I was watering twice a day, the pots still dried out.

As for tomatoes, great success in 3-5 gal pots. Whether I’ve trained them cordon, or just letting them sprawl they just do really well for me.

I would say if you have the space experiment. Try with only one in a pot, then try with 3 in a pot. Just remember these are really big plants, my cukes made it all the way up my 6 foot trellis then all the way back down and then half way back up. And my Belgium Giant grown in a 5 gal pot trained similar to an espalier is about 10-11 foot tall.

They best thing you can do in gardening is gain experience. Not only what the plants will do, but what works for you. I’ve had friends grow excellent plants and I’ve tried to copy what they did and didn’t get the same result. I don’t have a green thumb, I’ve just killed enough plants I know what not to do anymore.


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

  • Posted by saood Saudi - 10b (My Page) on
    Fri, Oct 18, 13 at 11:51

Thanks Seysonn.

As you know that I have to transplant the cucumber seedlings (3 in one pot), what is the best I should do? Thin out two of them? or try to prick out each of those for individual containers which has a increased chance that it might disturb their roots

I have a total of two more pots each with 3 seedlings (actually they are the Armenian cucumbers).


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

Usually cucumbers are planted in clumps of two , sometimes three per hill in the garden. I prefer TWO. But never ONE,
I usually plant 4 or five seeds together and after the have sets of true leave I keep two and pinch the rest. The reason for this is that they push the soil away and come up better. A single seed might just struggle to do by itself. It depends how the soil is. I seed directly in the garden. If I decide to buy seedlings I would choose the smallest and shortest and more green ones. Never leggy ones that look pale. I transplant them deep and fill the soil aound them up to the lowest leaves. And later I hill them even more.


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

Thanks Tool Geek once again for the detailed explanation

1/ When you say,
"I have also started seeds cucumber seeds in 2” pots, when they each form at least one good true leaf I’ll dump the pot, pull them apart and pot them on into bigger containers."

You mean that you put 2 seeds in one 2" pot and then later pot each of those seedlings in a separate 4" (or bigger) individual pot without thinning out one of them?

Did I get that right.

2/ Also for the container cucumber, you said you sometimes watered them twice a day and still found they dried out. As you know I live in a very hot climate, these days the temps reach comfortably above 95F at or around noon. I had over watered one tomato and pepper plant in my peat based potting soil and believe me this was like 10 days back. I still have not watered them again and I can still find moisture. Was it that your potting soil was not so water retentive or is it that when cucumbers get big they demand a lot more moisture than tomato and if that is a case a more water retentive soil will be advisable?

3/ One last thing - what are the signs that the plant is experiencing transplant shock? How can you tell that?


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

1/ that's right. 2 seeds in 2" pots. Then gently tease them apart and pot them up.
2/ they do get very big. And like a lot of water. Here it gets into the 100's and is quite dry mid season. I did use a peat based compost, and would water when I stuck my finger in the soil 1" and it was dry. And would water until it was draining from the bottom.
3/ transplant shock can be as little as the plant just seems to slow down growth to wilting disastrously. Don't worry about it too much, just keep them watered and wait, almost always they will pull through. And the younger the plant the better it will transplant.

I'm not trying to discourage on growing cukes in containers. I did get fruit, just not nearly as much as in ground cukes. And it was more effort. If I were to try it again I would try to keep the pot cooler by keeping it shaded, and maybe adding some mulch. Straw or leaf mold.

Good luck!


 o
RE: Third cucumber seedling dies.... What did they teach me??

The olnly time I get a cucumber crop I straight seed them. Starting them in pots I am lucky if I get 1 fruit per plant.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here