Return to the Seed Exchange Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Looking for your valuable input, please

Posted by chemocurl zone 5/6 S INDIANA (My Page) on
Mon, Jan 18, 10 at 12:24

IMHO, GW is the best because of the input of all of its wonderful members, both old and new. There is so much to be shared and learned here, and even newbies who ask questions or who are seen as potential seed addicts to us enablers have much value. There is no such thing as a stupid or silly question, as chances are, there are likely other members who have been wondering about the exact same thing.

I'm think of later starting a new thread with clickable links to different threads here on this side.

I'd like to organize them somehow, but am not sure exactly how.

I thought I'd maybe group them under headers like...
Trading-good to know info.

Getting started...all set upand it would cover having a Member Page email link, what an unblocked email link is, Member trade lists, more on member trade lists.

Some threads I'd like to link to would cover, harvesting, packing and trading seeds,getting follow-up replies sent vie email, Newbie question and answer thread, 10 most frequently asked questions, etc.

I know there are some FAQ here, but they are somewhat lacking in covering so many things pertaining to trading seeds, and/or the info is obsolete, or maybe even in some cases wrong.

I think it would be fun to include a category of Just for fun and include graanieb's thread Know you're addicted to Seed Exchange-s...when... It is a wonderfully funny thread that will soon be 4 years old! There are a number of other funny ones too.

Maybe a catagory for 'rants'? They all contain some good to know info as to why one is ranting, right?

I have started a lot of threads over the years, wanting to draw info from members, so will include a lot of them. I found them via a search on my name here, and since I started them, I am familiar with them.

What ones have you maybe started or think might be good to be included? There is so much to be learned by the many questions that have been asked and then answered by so many, over the years. I thought consolidating the links to them, might help some folks who are new or newer here, as well as maybe encourage folks to ask questions, and/or read a lot of the good ole threads.

Now...put your thinking caps on.

Sue...who has likely had too much coffee and time on the computer.

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Looking for your valuable input, please


I so appreciate all of the effort you put into making Garden Web the place that it is. I can only imagine how much time it takes to assemble these informative threads.

I can tell you since I've been at Garden Web for several years, in my opinion, the biggest challenge is that it can be overwhelming. There are so many forums each with their own FAQ, conversation, and/or gallery pages. Trading is a beast all of it's own, and as I've mentioned to you in another post, it's taken me some time to muster up the courage to attempt it. I can only speak for myself, for whatever it's worth, I think one of the most helpful things you could do is get some of these different threads linked together in one place. It can be exhausting to go through the pages and pages of FAQ's for each forum and then the rant threads or suggestion threads or preference threads. To have everything in place so there can be no question what is expected or preferred of members would be wonderful. :)

RE: Looking for your valuable input, please

Hi Quilt!

Being retired, I probably have a lot more time than most to 'play' here on GW. My day usually starts with GW over several cups of coffee before I get moving....thus some of my posts being very wordy....and that's probably putting it mildly for some.

After I posted this, I got to thinking about other most pertinent forums for those who would be trading (and hopefully) growing from seed.

Like the WSing forum and a link to the FAQ there, that are really great.

A link to Seed Saving as well as the FAQ there.

Growing from Seed
Growing Under Lights

I can tell you since I've been at Garden Web for several years, in my opinion, the biggest challenge is that it can be overwhelming.
Hey, tell me about it. When I first joined GW I was also pretty new to a computer and had never been to any forum before in my life. I didn't know how to get to my member page or my trade list once it was set up. A nice member sent me the URL for both my Member Page and my Member trade list. At that time, I didn't even know how to copy and paste, and it was years and years later before I learned about how to have multiple tabs or windows open. I was sooo computer challenged.

Trade lists with pics...note to self about other threads to include...


RE: Looking for your valuable input, please

Sue - You are wonderfully wordy and I enjoy every moment of it. I'm a wordy girl myself. :) You have come a long way from computer are quite the savvy one around here!!! I too could not find my member page or trade list page, glad to know I'm not the only one! The way it is situated is a little tricky if you ask me, but I cannot complain because as overwhelming as GW may be, I enjoy it so very much. Wonderful ideas and I look forward to seeing and visiting the links that are shared.

RE: Looking for your valuable input, please

How about adding something about the importance of sending the size bubble envelope requested, not smaller and if possible not larger.

The bubble envelope size that is requested is for a reason. The seeds fit in that envelope size and for the postage requested and usually will go for first class large envelope rate.

I know that when I send the info for a BEAP I have used my digital postal scale, weighed the bubble envelope, the weight of the seeds, added to pieces of 8 1/2 by 11 inch paper to the scale and have everything all totaled to go for the first class weight.

The reason I've added to pieces of paper to the weighing is one sheet covers the weight of the paper requested with the list of seeds on it, and the other one covers the weight of packing tape and label.

When someone sends a smaller envelope than requested, the seeds can't fit for the amount of postage sent and the same thing can happen if a larger envelope is sent.

Just in the huge BEAP post I made a few weeks ago, I've gotten quite a few bubblies that where either too small or too large and there wasn't enough postage to send all the seeds.

Most times, a larger envelope will be OK, but not always.

Another thing is the simple fact that it isn't necessary to send the bubble envelope inside another one to get the BEAP seeds.

I've lost count with how many bubblies have come to inside a second envelope, even when I have given the following instruction.s

"just address the bubble envelope to me, put everything inside that I requested, tape it closed and mail it to me. There is no need to but the bubble envelope inside another one to send it to me."

OH, Just thought of another one. Figure out how to explain don't use the the tape seal on the bubble envelope to seal up the bubblie. Most times, they stick so well, that you can't get the envelope open and have to cut the bubblie to open it.
If you just take it closed with package tape, it's much easier to open the bubble without cutting it to do so.

I think it's scotch that is making bubble envelopes now with a shiny material now and if you seal that closed with their seal on it, there is no way on earth that you can get it open without cutting the bubble.


RE: Looking for your valuable input, please

RE: Looking for your valuable input, please

  • Posted by mgpb 9b Central CA (My Page) on
    Sat, Jan 30, 10 at 21:56

Hi Sue,

I like this idea of yours.
As a semi-newbie now, I remember being confused in the beginning (not hard for me) because there seemed to be multiple places to post the same thing. Ex: there's at least 2 'Name that Plant', 1 in Forums & 1 in Galleries. I've also noticed seed trading requests in various forums rather than just seed exchange.

How about something like:
"First time? Start here", with a link to an Outline page with topical links? The Outline titles would also let newbies know about things they might not even have thought about. For ex: I didn't know I needed to learn about BEAPs when I first started. But if I'd seen the title in an outline, it would've alerted me to something I needed to check out.

I don't know if this is along the lines of what you were asking, not having the experience of longer term members (notice I didn't say older) :), but I sure appreciate all the time & effort you put in to making things run smoothly. Thanks!


RE: Looking for your valuable input, please

You should put in the search terms too for the particular links Sue, that way when they go stale the folks can still find similar info. Stale links are a bane of the internet, so in a place with limited thread storage like GW, it's vital to provide the search terms for future users. Like you said, one of the links is from a four year old post--which may or may not be here months from now.


RE: Looking for your valuable input, please

I haven't been here too awful long and I have came and read a lot just to see who is here and what do they have to say. Being a newbie just this last year (2009) and this will be my first garden year for flowers (2010) I have been very busy this winter on my first winter sowing, first time starting seeds in the basement and watching them grow. All the work in planning what I am going to plant and where, doing a lot of research about the plants and the colors to look forward to. I was thinking that maybe there needs to more information and easier information to get. Sue you have A LOT OF FANTASTIC IDEAS with such a personality that goes along with it, and with the easy steps you have told me and got me going and informed, Just keep it up

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Please Note: Only registered members from the U.S. are able to post messages here (this may be indicated by the title of the forum. All exchanges not indicated otherwise are restricted to those living in the U.S.)

If you are a member from an area mentioned above, please log in.

Return to the Seed Exchange Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here